phd thesis examiner comments

This paper focuses on what examiners write in reports on theses that are returned to the candidate for major revision and resubmission. It compares examiner comment on six PhD theses, with particular emphasis on the nature of the initial examiner comment and then comment after resubmission. It also compares examiner comment on the six resubmissions

What the examiners said. In Australia, a thesis must be submitted to three examiners: one in the University and two external, one of whom must be overseas. The comments are sent back to the examinations committee, who decide whether the candidate's thesis is. Acceptable only with major additional work and re-submission. Unacceptable.

Often, you can't answer all the research question (s) even with a PhD and so you need to write what you could not do in the final part of the thesis as suggestions for further research. Otherwise an examiner may bring up the gaps and absences as negatives in their assessment of the thesis. You need to have thought about this and noted these gaps.

A study by Holbrook et al. (2004) looked at examiner feedback on PhD theses that were resubmitted for examination, by comparing initial and re-examined comments. They found that examiners may enter into expert and gatekeeping roles, particularly in cases of re-examined theses, where they were examining according to standards that they see ...

Responding to Examiners - Guidelines. You should use the following guidelines in preparing your report: Make any corrections or revisions in your thesis using 'Track Changes'. Before doing that, however, make sure that you keep a copy of the original thesis that you submitted for examination. Your response to the examiners comments should be ...

Thus, in this respect, in the assessment of a PhD examiners provide information about a performance (the thesis). 27 The PhD examination report is also considered from the feedback perspectives because some of the comments provided by the examiners may provide developmental experiences and encourage self-regulated learning.

guidance for a thesis student. A thesis examiner is an academic who reads the fin-ished thesis, and gives a report recommending a result. The aim of our review is to clarify what thesis examiners do as they examine a written thesis submitted for a research higher degree. In some countries, such as

study (Holbrook et al., 2015) specifically investigating examiner comment on the use of theory in PhD theses found that examiners favoured a PhD thesis that demonstrated engagement with theory. This engagement is demonstrated through the use of up-to-date sources and evidence of under-standing pertinent theoretical criticisms.

Internal examiners are sometimes responsible for the organisation of the viva and arrangements for the external examiner's travel, accommodation and 'entertainment'. Reading and evaluating the thesis. Writing a pre-viva report on the thesis. Conducting the viva. Making a recommendation of award.

Notes for Examiners of PhD Theses. Reference: Doctoral Regulations for PhD and other Doctorates with Theses 4.12.1 and Doctoral Procedures 10.0 ... Dean would appreciate your comments on the following: • The extent to which the Candidate has demonstrated originality, critical insight, and the capacity to carry out independent research

Examiners should and do go beyond the thesis to comment on other things you can think about and do post-PhD; they comment on the theory and how your have used it, on methodology more generally and on how you have realised yours, on the strength of your analysis and on things you could have done differently, and might want to do differently in ...

Reply to Each Comment in Turn. After your general letter, copy each reviewer comment into the document and reply to it specifically. I usually put the reviewer comments in bold and then my answers underneath. You don't have to respond to every single comment, especially if they are of the 'typo on page 15' type.

Examiner expectations about coverage and use of 'the literature' in Ph.D. theses. Downloaded by [University of Newcastle (Australia)] at 21:54 22 October 2014. 354 A. Holbrook et al ...

for PhD theses at University NZ (New Zealand)) for examples. ... While this examiner ' s comments also fall mainly under summative ... If there is no critical concern about the thesis, examiners ...

This article investigates the expectations of 'the literature' in research and scholarship at Ph.D. level from the examiner and assessment perspective. The analysis draws on the examiner report data for 501 candidates (1310 reports) across five Australian universities. On average about one‐tenth of an examiner report is devoted to the ...

Examiners' comments on introduction chapter in theses. 2. Outline 2 1.Introduction 2.Thesis Structure 3.Thesis examination: procedures 4.Thesis evaluation forms: Examples 5.Comments on the Title 6.Comments on the Abstract 7.Comments on the Introduction Chapter 8.Conclusion. 4. 4 Learning in higher education is considered to be an adaptation to ...

PhD degree is awarded to the research scholars largely based on the deconstruction of examiner's reports. Examiners scrutinize the thesis from a level of ambiguity within the thesis, or lack of certainty and provide following one of the recommendations viz., without the requirement for revision OR, subject to minor nominated revisions, OR major nominated revisions to the satisfaction OR ...

To assist the student in understanding the full import of the examiners' comments. To assist the examiners to reach a decision where the thesis is on the borderline between pass or failure. An oral examination will be held for all students enrolled in the PhD, EdD, SJD, DHSc and DMA programmes.

4. Examiners read a thesis as an academic reader and as a normal reader. A thesis should be an enjoyable read in order to sustain an examiner's good impression. Examiners take a lot of time and effort to assess a thesis, and if they are not enjoying the read, they are more likely to judge it to be poor quality.

Elena OREKHOVA | Cited by 2,249 | of Moscow State University of Psychology and Education, Moscow | Read 98 publications | Contact Elena OREKHOVA

Russia's oil output strategy, as it has been formulated in ES-2035, sets the upper limit of production at a relatively flat level of 560 tons per annum from 2024 to 2035, in the optimistic scenario. In 2018, Russia's oil output amounted to 555.7 million tons, capped by the OPEC+ agreement.

PhD degree is awarded to the research scholars largely based on the deconstruction of examiner's reports. Examiners scrutinize the thesis from a level of ambiguity within the thesis, or lack of certainty and provide following one of the recommendations viz., without the requirement for revision OR, subject to minor nominated revisions, OR major nominated revisions to the satisfaction OR ...

The Economics PhD programme is designed to prepare professionals in economic research and education of the highest academic calibre in Russia, as well as the global academia. The Doctoral School of Economics offers training in the following fields: Economic Theory. Mathematical, Statistical and Instrumental Methods of Economics.

I am currently a second year PHD student (future PhD Candidate). I recently won a "full-time postgraduate" grant - I am actively pursuing further research for my PhD thesis, writing and publishing articles, participating in various IP conferences, and giving lectures and seminars for Master's students in IP and other disciplines. At the moment I'm teaching a course to second year Master's ...