case study of labour

• SUGGESTED TOPICS
• The Magazine
• Newsletters
• Managing Yourself
• Managing Teams
• Work-life Balance
• The Big Idea
• Data & Visuals
• Reading Lists
• Case Selections
• HBR Learning
• Topic Feeds
• Account Settings
• Email Preferences

Case Study: Navigating Labor Unrest

• Jorge Tamayo

A factory manager considers whether to accept or resist union demands.

Paulo Ferreira, the president of Luna Brazil, has an ambitious plan to turn around the dismal performance of the plant he oversees in Campinas. The wrinkle is, he needs the buy-in of the powerful local union, which is still smarting from a 10-year-old labor conflict and lately has begun to step up its demands and picket outside the factory. Headquarters, running out of patience with the dispute, wants Paulo to consider converting the plant to a distribution center. But that would mean hundreds of layoffs, which would decimate the local community that Paolo loves.

In the corner office at the Campinas plant of Luna Motors, the dim light of a desk lamp illuminated a series of charts. Paulo Ferreira, the president of Luna Brazil, had been so deep in thought he hadn’t even noticed that it was now dark outside. Each line, curve, and number on the papers in front of him painted a disheartening picture of the plant’s performance: rising defects, increasing absenteeism, and a record high in vehicles lost to labor issues. The plant was no longer competitive within the larger Luna network.

• JT Jorge Tamayo is an assistant professor in the Strategy Unit at Harvard Business School.

Partner Center

• Browse All Articles
• Newsletter Sign-Up

• 11 Apr 2024
• In Practice

Why Progress on Immigration Might Soften Labor Pains

Long-term labor shortages continue to stoke debates about immigration policy in the United States. We asked Harvard Business School faculty members to discuss what's at stake for companies facing talent needs, and the potential scenarios on the horizon.

• 02 Apr 2024
• Research & Ideas

Employees Out Sick? Inside One Company's Creative Approach to Staying Productive

Regular absenteeism can hobble output and even bring down a business. But fostering a collaborative culture that brings managers together can help companies weather surges of sick days and no-shows. Research by Jorge Tamayo shows how.

• 22 Mar 2024

Open Source Software: The $9 Trillion Resource Companies Take for Granted

Many companies build their businesses on open source software, code that would cost firms $8.8 trillion to create from scratch if it weren't freely available. Research by Frank Nagle and colleagues puts a value on an economic necessity that will require investment to meet demand.

• 16 Feb 2024

As AI Upends Recruiting, Job Seekers Need a Waze App for Careers

Companies have jobs to fill, and skilled candidates are looking for the right opportunities, but too often, technology stands between them. A report by Joseph Fuller and colleagues says that a career navigation system that meets four key imperatives could bridge the gap.

• 25 Jan 2024

Being a Team Player: Why College Athletes Succeed in Business

Forget rocks for jocks. A study by Paul Gompers of more than 400,000 Ivy League athletes probes how the rigors of college sports can help people climb the corporate ladder faster and into higher-paying positions.

• 02 Jan 2024

10 Trends to Watch in 2024

Employees may seek new approaches to balance, even as leaders consider whether to bring more teams back to offices or make hybrid work even more flexible. These are just a few trends that Harvard Business School faculty members will be following during a year when staffing, climate, and inclusion will likely remain top of mind.

• 14 Sep 2023

Working Moms Are Mostly Thriving Again. Can We Finally Achieve Gender Parity?

The pandemic didn't destroy the workplace advancements moms had achieved. However, not all of the positive changes forced by the crisis and remote work have stuck, says research by Kathleen McGinn and Alexandra Feldberg.

• 08 Aug 2023

Black Employees Not Only Earn Less, But Deal with Bad Bosses and Poor Conditions

More than 900,000 reviews highlight broad racial disparities in the American working experience. Beyond pay inequities, research by Letian Zhang shows how Black employees are less likely to work at companies known for positive cultures or work-life balance.

• 24 Jul 2023

Part-Time Employees Want More Hours. Can Companies Tap This ‘Hidden’ Talent Pool?

Businesses need more staff and employees need more work, so what's standing in the way? A report by Joseph Fuller and colleagues shows how algorithms and inflexibility prevent companies from accessing valuable talent in a long-term shortage.

• 01 Jun 2023

A Nike Executive Hid His Criminal Past to Turn His Life Around. What If He Didn't Have To?

Larry Miller committed murder as a teenager, but earned a college degree while serving time and set out to start a new life. Still, he had to conceal his record to get a job that would ultimately take him to the heights of sports marketing. A case study by Francesca Gino, Hise Gibson, and Frances Frei shows the barriers that formerly incarcerated Black men are up against and the potential talent they could bring to business.

• 31 May 2023

Why Business Leaders Need to Hear Larry Miller's Story

VIDEO: Nike executive Larry Miller concealed his criminal past to get a job. What if more companies were willing to hire people with blemishes on their records? Hise Gibson explores why business leaders should give the formerly incarcerated a second chance.

• 16 May 2023

How KKR Got More by Giving Ownership to the Factory Floor: ‘My Kids Are Going to College!’

KKR turned around a struggling door company and sold it for 10 times its investment—giving factory workers a life-changing cut of the returns. A case study by Ethan Rouen and Dennis Campbell offers lessons for companies trying to instill an owner's mindset in employees.

• 09 May 2023

Where to Find Remote Work Now: 250 Million Job Postings Paint a Complex Picture

While many companies let employees work remotely during the height of COVID-19, conditions have since become more nuanced, according to research by Raffaella Sadun and colleagues. What do these shifts mean for talent managers?

• 07 Feb 2023

Supervisor of Sandwiches? More Companies Inflate Titles to Avoid Extra Pay

What does an assistant manager of bingo actually manage? Increasingly, companies are falsely classifying hourly workers as managers to avoid paying an estimated $4 billion a year in overtime, says research by Lauren Cohen.

• 01 Feb 2023
• What Do You Think?

Will Hybrid Work Strategies Pull Down Long-Term Performance?

Many academics consider remote and hybrid work the future, but some business leaders are pushing back. Can colleagues working from anywhere still create the special glue that bonds teams together? asks James Heskett. Open for comment; 0 Comments.

• 20 Dec 2022

Employee Feedback: The Key to Retention During the Great Resignation

Employees need to feel that they're on the same team as managers—not adversaries in a zero-sum game. Michael Beer offers six guiding principles for senior leaders who are ready to listen to and act on employee feedback.

• 29 Nov 2022
• Cold Call Podcast

How Will Gamers and Investors Respond to Microsoft’s Acquisition of Activision Blizzard?

In January 2022, Microsoft announced its acquisition of the video game company Activision Blizzard for $68.7 billion. The deal would make Microsoft the world’s third largest video game company, but it also exposes the company to several risks. First, the all-cash deal would require Microsoft to use a large portion of its cash reserves. Second, the acquisition was announced as Activision Blizzard faced gender pay disparity and sexual harassment allegations. That opened Microsoft up to potential reputational damage, employee turnover, and lost sales. Do the potential benefits of the acquisition outweigh the risks for Microsoft and its shareholders? Harvard Business School associate professor Joseph Pacelli discusses the ongoing controversies around the merger and how gamers and investors have responded in the case, “Call of Fiduciary Duty: Microsoft Acquires Activision Blizzard.”

• 01 Nov 2022

Why Aren’t Business Leaders More Vocal About Immigration Policy?

Immigration fuels the American economy, feeds the talent pool, and can directly affect company performance. And yet few executives and entrepreneurs have waded into the policy dialogue, says James Heskett. Open for comment; 0 Comments.

• 03 Oct 2022

Why a Failed Startup Might Be Good for Your Career After All

Go ahead and launch that venture. Even if it fails, the experience you gain will likely earn you a job that's more senior than those of your peers, says research by Paul Gompers.

• 12 Jul 2022

Can the Foodservice Distribution Industry Recover from the Pandemic?

At the height of the pandemic in 2020, US Foods struggled, as restaurant and school closures reduced demand for foodservice distribution. The situation improved after the return of indoor dining and in-person learning, but an industry-wide shortage of truck drivers and warehouse staff hampered the foodservice distributor’s post-pandemic recovery. That left CEO Pietro Satriano to determine the best strategy to attract and retain essential workers, even as he was tasked with expanding the wholesale grocery store chain (CHEF’STORE) that US Foods launched during the pandemic lockdown. Harvard Business School Professor David E. Bell explores how post-pandemic supply chain challenges continue to affect the foodservice distribution industry in his case, “US Foods: Driving Post-Pandemic Success?”

• Casestudies

Forced labour

"how can a company practically and responsibly identify and address problems of forced labour in lower tiers of its supply chain, particularly when it extends into areas or sectors known to use forced labour", dilemmas and case studies.

• Access to water
• Child labour
• Community relocation
• Conflict minerals
• Cumulative impacts
• Doing business in conflict-affected countries
• Freedom of association
• Freedom of religion
• Freedom of speech
• Gender equality
• Health and safety
• Human trafficking
• Indigenous peoples’ rights
• Living wage
• Migrant workers
• Non-discrimination and minorities
• Product misuse
• Security forces
• Stabilisation clauses
• Working hours
• Working with SOEs
• Case studies

This page presents all relevant good practice case studies that showcase how business have addressed the Forced labour dilemma. Case studies have been developed in close collaboration with a range of multi-national companies and relevant government, inter-governmental and civil society stakeholders. We also draw on public domain sources, including the UN Global Compact's own published Communications on Progress through which signatories are required to report on their performance against the Ten Principles.

The case studies explore the specific dilemmas and challenges faced by each organisation, good practice actions they have taken to resolve them and the results of such action. We reference challenges as well as achievements and invite you to submit commentary and suggestions through the Forum.

IN-DEPTH (Print seperately) Responsible Cotton Network: Combating forced child labour during the cotton harvest - Uzbekistan

IN-DEPTH (Print seperately) ICC: Combating slave labour in the Brazilian charcoal and steel sector - Brazil

Verite, a US-based NGO, conducts research on forced labour and human trafficking around the world, with a particular focus on exploitive labour broker practices. Some of Verite’s projects include:

·          The use of forced labour in the electronics sector in Malaysia

·          Unscrupulous labour practices in the Guatemalan palm oil sector

·          Human rights abuses perpetuated throughout global supply chains of artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM), with a focus on ASM gold in Peru

  Verite aims to engage with companies in implementing strategies to identify and eliminate exploitive labour broker practices from their supply chains in order to minimise the risk of forced labour. Verite also provides courses that provide participants the competencies to perform audits of labour practices within companies, with a focus on auditing compensation, business ethics and working hours. These audits are run by Verite’s partnership organisation, the Electronic Industry Citizenship Coalition (EICC). 

http://www.verite.org

Established in 2002, the International Cocoa Initiative (ICI) is a partnership between NGOs, trade unions, cocoa processors and companies focused on tackling exploitative child labour. Member companies include: Cargill, Hershey’s, Kraft Foods, Mars, Nestle, Twinings and Toms International, amongst others. The ICI works at both the national- and the community-level to foster programmes to combat and prevent forced child labour. The ICI has implemented programmes in Cote d’Ivoire and Ghana.

http://www.cocoainitiative.org

Business Social Compliance Initiative (BSCI) was launched in 2003 by the Foreign Trade Association, a Brussels-based trade association that represents the trade interests of European companies. BSCI acts as an umbrella group for around 1,300 retail companies focused on improving working conditions in their supply chains.

The organisation has developed the BSCI code which addresses a wide range of supply chain issues, including a prohibition on forced labour as well as disciplinary measures for suppliers failing to comply with the code. Members adopt the BSCI Code internally and require their suppliers to come into compliance. BSCI provides capacity building in the form of training and technical assistance. BSCI also relies on external monitoring to ensure conformance to the code. BSCI is a member of the UN Global Compact.

http://www.bsci-eu.org

Founded in 2004, FFC is a New York-based membership organisation of companies seeking to improve working conditions in factories that make consumer goods. FFC shares compliance data between companies in order to improve the availability and standardisation of standards and audits on social, environmental and security standards. Amongst its members are Wal-Mart, Reebok, and Levi Strauss & Co. The FFC receives funding from the US Department of State. Its founders include Reebok, the National Retail Federation and the Retail Council of Canada.

http://www.fairfactories.org

The International Council on Metals and Mining (ICMM) is a CEO-led initiative founded in 2011 which focuses on promoting good practice in the mining and metals sector. Composed of 18 of the world’s largest mining companies and 30 associations, its corporate members include Anglo-American, BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto, Vale, Newmont and Mitsubishi Materials. Members commit to implementing ICMM’s Sustainable Development Framework. The framework comprises a set of 10 principles focused on integrating ethnical business practices across the mining sector, supported by public reporting and independent third-party assurance. The principles were adopted in May 2003. Principle 3 prohibits the use of forced, compulsory and child labour.

Global paper manufacturer Glatfleter implements a policy focused on combating forced labour in its supply chain, based on ILO conventions and national law. The company’s ‘Child and Forced Labor Policy’, which “recognises regional and cultural differences”, explicitly prohibits exploitative working conditions and the use of any forced labour. In order to address the problem, Glatfelter engages with suppliers, industry organisations, civil society representatives and governments.

In its policy document, Glatfelter acknowledges that the risks are particularly elevated for companies sourcing raw agricultural products, due to supply chains which are often long, complex and at risk of perpetuating forced labour use. The company strongly encourages its suppliers, subcontractors and business partners to adhere to its principles on the issue.

http://www.glatfelter.com

As part of its ‘No Child or Forced Labour’ policy, Indian multi-business conglomerate ITC Limited prohibits the use of forced or compulsory labour at all of its units, and maintains that no employee be made to work against their will or be subject to corporal punishment or coercion. The policy is made available to all employees through accessible induction programmes, policy manuals and intranet portals. Trade unions also engage with workers at each ITC unit to ensure they are aware of their rights. All units provide an annual report on any incidents of child or forced labour to divisional heads, and are subject to Corporate Internal Audits and Environment, Health and Safety assessments.

http://www.itcportal.com

Under the California Transparency in Supply Chains Act of 2010 (SB 657), which applies to retail sellers and manufacturers “doing business in the state”, multinational automaker Ford has disclosed its four key principles for the prevention of forced labour use in its supply chains:

·          Firstly, the company engages in risk assessment of its supply base, taking into account the geographic context, commodity type, level of labour required for production, supplier ownership structure and quality performance and the nature of the transaction.

·          Secondly, Ford operates purchase orders which require suppliers to certify compliance with standard terms and conditions on the prohibition of forced labour.

·          Thirdly, along with the other members of the Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG), Ford conducts training and capacity building for global purchasing staff and suppliers in high-risk markets.

·          Finally, the company carries out regular audits of at-risk ‘Tier 1’ supplier factories, resulting, if necessary, in the completion of corrective action plans to then be reassessed six to 12 months after the original audit.

http://www.ford.com

On 6 May 2013, global sportswear brand Adidas announced that it was gradually launching a new whistle-blowing helpline at all of its Asia-based operations – to enable factory employees to voice potential grievances about labour violations. Workers employed in factories supplying Adidas will be able to send anonymous text messages – limited to 160 characters – to the  SMS Worker Hotline . While managers at the factories will be the main recipients of these text messages, Adidas will also be able to access them. This will allow the company to take direct action – particularly in cases where serious violations such as forced, bonded or child labour are identified.

Adidas acknowledges that workers sometimes do not feel comfortable in bringing issues to the attention of factory management in person. The move by the Germany multinational follows a spate of deadly incidents in Bangladeshi garment factories during 2013, one of the most important source countries for the global clothing industry. In this context, the establishment of worker hotlines can enable factory employees to raise practical issues related to health and safety, as well as labour violations.

Ford implements a supplier training programme to promote responsible working conditions in its supply chain. The programme is focused on “high-priority” countries including those in:

• The Americas (Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Dominican Republic, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua and Venezuela)
• Asia (China, India, Malaysia, the Philippines, South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand and Vietnam)
• Europe, the Middle East and Africa (Morocco, Romania, Russia, South Africa and Turkey)

Training was originally based on Ford’s own Code of Basic Working Conditions and was implemented by Ford at supplier factories. The programme is based on one-day interactive workshops involving multiple suppliers, and is targeted at human resources, health and safety, and legal managers within supplier companies. Each participant is expected to ‘cascade’ relevant training materials to personnel within their own companies – and to their own direct suppliers. Indeed, Ford requires confirmation from participant suppliers that training information has been disseminated to these target groups within four months of each workshop.

The programme has since evolved into a joint initiative with other car manufacturers – in order to reach a larger number of suppliers (many of whom provide parts to multiple brands) more efficiently. This resulted in the formation of the Automotive Industry Action Group (‘AIAG’) through which car manufacturers from North America, Europe and Asia have developed common guidance statements on working conditions – as well as an online training programme for suppliers to the sector. These cover a range of issues including child labour, forced labour, freedom of association, discrimination, health and safety, wages and working hours.

Ford estimates that its training activity (carried out both unilaterally and in conjunction with the AIAG) has reached 2,900 supplier representatives – and been ‘cascaded’ to around 25,000 supplier managers, 485,000 workers and 100,000 sub-tier supplier companies.

• Harvard Business School →
• Faculty & Research →
• March–April 2024
• Harvard Business Review

Case Study: Navigating Labor Unrest

• Format: Print
• Find it at Harvard
• Register to Read

About The Author

Jorge Tamayo

More from the author.

• January 2024
• Economic Journal

Helping Children Catch Up: Early Life Shocks and the PROGRESA Experiment

• Faculty Research

Rapport in Organizations: Evidence from Fast Food

• October 2023

Foodology: Creating a Virtual Restaurant Group in Latin America

• Helping Children Catch Up: Early Life Shocks and the PROGRESA Experiment  By: Achyuta Adhvaryu, Theresa Molina, Anant Nyshadham and Jorge Tamayo
• Rapport in Organizations: Evidence from Fast Food  By: Achyuta Adhvaryu, Parker Howell, Anant Nyshadham and Jorge Tamayo
• Foodology: Creating a Virtual Restaurant Group in Latin America  By: Rembrand Koning, Jorge Tamayo and Jenyfeer Martínez Buitrago

SustainCase – Sustainability Magazine

• trending News
• Climate News
• Collections
• case studies

Case study: How Target prevents forced labour in its supply chains

As one of the largest retailers in the United States, employing almost 350,000 full-time, part- time and seasonal employees, Target works with strategic partners to reach the goal of elevating the lives of at least three million people in the factories and communities where Target’s goods are produced, deepening its commitment to identify and, if discovered, eliminate forced labour in its supply chains.

This case study is based on the 2018 Corporate Responsibility Report by Target published on the Global Reporting Initiative Sustainability Disclosure Database  that can be found at this link . Through all case studies we aim to demonstrate what CSR/ ESG/ sustainability reporting done responsibly means. Essentially, it means: a) identifying a company’s most important impacts on the environment, economy and society, and b) measuring, managing and changing.

Target believes it has a responsibility to protect the people who help create its products     Tweet This! and make every effort to deliver products that are made ethically and responsibly. Accordingly, Target is working alongside its suppliers, global sourcing experts and other key partners to help prevent forced labour in global supply chains. In order to prevent forced labour in its supply chains Target took action to:

• adopt a Resolution on Forced Labour
• develop policies to protect workers in supply chains
• promote responsible recruitment
• prevent human trafficking
• monitor child labour risks

Subscribe for free and read the rest of this case study

Please subscribe to the SustainCase Newsletter to keep up to date with the latest sustainability news and gain access to over 2000 case studies. These case studies demonstrate how companies are dealing responsibly with their most important impacts, building trust with their stakeholders (Identify > Measure > Manage > Change).

With this case study you will see:

• Which are the most important impacts (material issues) Target has identified;
• How Target proceeded with stakeholder engagement , and
• What actions were taken by Target to prevent forced labour in its supply chains

Already Subscribed? Type your email below and click submit

What are the material issues the company has identified?

In its 2018 Corporate Responsibility Report Target identified a range of material issues, such as diversity & inclusion, product safety, community development, responsible resource use, waste management. Among these, preventing forced labour in its supply chains stands out as a key material issue for Target.

Stakeholder engagement in accordance with the GRI Standards              

The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) defines the Principle of Stakeholder Inclusiveness when identifying material issues (or a company’s most important impacts) as follows:

“The reporting organization shall identify its stakeholders, and explain how it has responded to their reasonable expectations and interests.”

Stakeholders must be consulted in the process of identifying a company’s most important impacts and their reasonable expectations and interests must be taken into account. This is an important cornerstone for CSR / sustainability reporting done responsibly.

Key stakeholder groups Target engages with:

How stakeholder engagement was made to identify material issues

To identify and prioritise material topics Target worked closely with internal working groups to prioritise the environmental and social topics of concern and also carried out a survey among external stakeholders, to hear their feedback and expectations.

In its 2018 Corporate Responsibility Report Target reports that it took the following actions for preventing forced labour in its supply chains:

• Adopting a Resolution on Forced Labour
• Target’s CEO Brian Cornell sits on the Board of Directors of the Consumer Goods Forum, and Target has adopted the organisation’s Resolution on Forced Labour. The resolution is the first industry commitment of its kind and contains the adoption of three key principles: that every worker should have freedom of movement, that no worker should pay for a job, and that no worker should be indebted or coerced to work.
• Developing policies to protect workers in supply chains
• Target has developed policies for its suppliers to protect foreign contract workers in its supply chain. Target seeks to set clear expectations for suppliers and lay out procedures, standards and verification mechanisms that will support the adoption of the Employer Pays Principle.
• Promoting responsible recruitment
• In 2017, Target joined the Responsible Labour Initiative’s Steering Committee, to continue to develop cross-industry approaches for advancing labour practices, especially regarding responsible recruitment and the protection of foreign migrant workers.
• Preventing human trafficking
• In 2017, Target launched a pilot programme to prevent human trafficking in Northern India. Workers from eight factories and 10 communities participated in a survey that informed both digital informational messaging and local non-profit partners’ educational programmes. By carrying out awareness programming prior to migration, Target hopes to help address the needs of community members and reduce the likelihood of trafficking. In addition, Target entered into a partnership with the International Justice Mission (IJM), to implement the group’s Safe Migration Programme and Grassroots Prevention Campaign in India. These programmes aim to prevent labour trafficking and support trafficking survivors by engaging with vulnerable communities and local authorities.
• Monitoring child labour risks
• All handwoven rugs produced for Target in India are certified by GoodWeave, as child labour free. In 2017, Target continued partnering with GoodWeave to further develop a technology platform that will enable end-to-end supply chain mapping and monitoring for child labour risks in Target’s supply chain in North India.

Which GRI Standards and corresponding Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have been addressed?

The GRI Standard addressed in this case is:

Disclosure 409-1 Operations and suppliers at significant risk for incidents of forced or compulsory labor

Disclosure 409-1 Operations and suppliers at significant risk for incidents of forced or compulsory labor corresponds to:

• Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 8 : Promote sustained, inclusive and sustainable economic growth, full and productive employment and decent work for all
• Business theme: Elimination of forced or compulsory labor

78% of the world’s 250 largest companies report in accordance with the GRI Standards

SustainCase was primarily created to demonstrate, through case studies, the importance of dealing with a company’s most important impacts in a structured way, with use of the GRI Standards. To show how today’s best-run companies are achieving economic, social and environmental success – and how you can too.

Research by well-recognised institutions is clearly proving that responsible companies can look to the future with optimism .

7 GRI sustainability disclosures get you started

Any size business can start taking sustainability action

GRI, IEMA, CPD Certified Sustainability courses (2-5 days): Live Online or Classroom  (venue: London School of Economics)

• Exclusive FBRH template to begin reporting from day one
• Identify your most important impacts on the Environment, Economy and People
• Formulate in group exercises your plan for action. Begin taking solid, focused, all-round sustainability action ASAP. 
• Benchmarking methodology to set you on a path of continuous improvement

See upcoming training dates.

References:

1) This case study is based on published information by Target, located at the link below. For the sake of readability, we did not use brackets or ellipses. However, we made sure that the extra or missing words did not change the report’s meaning. If you would like to quote these written sources from the original, please revert to the original on the Global Reporting Initiative’s Sustainability Disclosure Database at the link:

http://database.globalreporting.org/

2) https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/gri-standards-download-center/

Note to Target: With each case study we send out an email requesting a comment on this case study. If you have not received such an email please contact us .

Privacy Overview

• IKEA Case: One Company’s Fight to End Child Labor
• Markkula Center for Applied Ethics
• Focus Areas
• Business Ethics
• Business Ethics Resources

IKEA Case: One Company’s Fight to End Child Labor

A business ethics case study.

In this business ethics case study, Swedish multinational company IKEA faced accusations relating to child labor abuses in the rug industry in Pakistan which posed a serious challenge for the company and its supply chain management goals.

Empty garage with a highlighted walking path in front of an IKEA.

Photo credit: mastrminda/Pixabay

Yuvraj Rao '23 , a 2022-23 Hackworth Fellow at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics graduated with a marketing major and entrepreneurship minor from Santa Clara University.

Introduction

IKEA is a Swedish multinational company that was founded in 1943 by Ingvar Kamprad. [1] The company mainly provides simple, affordable home furniture and furnishings, and it pioneered DIY, or do it yourself, furniture. Kamprad originally sold binders, fountain pens, and cigarette lighters, but eventually expanded to furniture in 1948. According to the Journal of International Management, in 1953, Kamprad offered products that came as “a self assembled furniture” for the lowest price, which ultimately became a key part of IKEA’s value proposition going forward. In 1961, IKEA started to contact furniture factories in Poland to order chairs from a factory in Radomsko. [2] Outsourcing to Poland was mainly due to other Swedish furniture stores pressuring Swedish manufacturers to stop selling to IKEA. In the mid 1960’s, IKEA continued its supplier expansion into Norway, largely because IKEA didn’t want to “own their own line of production,” [3] and Germany due to its ideal location (downtown, suburban area) to place an IKEA store. Given IKEA’s suppliers were now not just in Sweden, it led to an increased importance on developing strong relationships with its suppliers.

In the following decades, IKEA continued its expansion and solidified its identity as a major retail outlet with parts being manufactured around the world. By the mid 90’s, IKEA was the “world’s largest specialized furniture retailer with their GDP reaching $4.5 billion in August of 1994.” [4] It also worked with 2,300 suppliers in 70 different countries, who supplied 11,200 products and had 24 “trading offices in nineteen countries that monitored production, tested product ideas, negotiated products, and checked quality.” [5] IKEA’s dependence on its suppliers ultimately led to problems in the mid 1990’s. At this time, IKEA was the largest furniture retailer in the world, and had nearly “100 stores in 17 countries.” [6] Also during this time, a Swedish documentary was released that highlighted the use of child labor in the rug industry in Pakistan, which impacted IKEA given it had production there. The rug industry in particular is extremely labor intensive and is one of the largest “export earners for India, Pakistan, Nepal and Morocco.” Here, children are forced to work long hours for very little pay (if there is any pay at all). In some cases, their wages are only enough to pay for food and lodging. In cases where children are not paid, the wages are used by the loom owner to pay the parents and agents who brought the children to the factories. Additionally, the work the children must do comes with a lot of risk. More specifically, children face risks of diminishing eyesight and damaged lungs from “the dust and fluff from the wool used in the carpets.” [7] As a result of these working conditions, many of these children are very sick when they grow up. Despite these terrible conditions, it isn’t that simple for families not to send children to work at these factories. A lot of the parents can’t afford food, water, education, or healthcare, so they are often left with no choice but to send their children to work for an additional source of income. [8]

 IKEA and Child Labor Accusations

The accusations of child labor in the rug industry in Pakistan posed a serious challenge for IKEA and its supply chain management goals. It would need to address the serious issues of alleged injustice for the sake of its reputation and brand image. Additionally, as IKEA also had suppliers in India, it would need to be in compliance with India’s “landmark legislation act against child labor, the Child Labor (Prohibition and Regulation) Act of 1986.” [9]

As a result of these accusations, IKEA ultimately ended its contracts with Pakistani rug manufacturers, but the problem of child labor in its supply chain still persisted in other countries that were supplying IKEA. Marianne Barner, the business area manager for rugs for IKEA at the time, stated that the film was a “real eye-opener…I myself had spent a couple of months in India for some supply chain training, but child labor was never mentioned.” [10] She also added that a key issue was that IKEA’s “buyers met suppliers at offices in the cities and rarely visited the actual production sites.” [11] The lack of visits to the actual production sites made it difficult for IKEA to identify the issue of child labor in these countries.

To make matters worse, in 1995, a German film “showed pictures of children working at an Indian rug supplier... ‘There was no doubt that they were rugs for IKEA,’ says business area manager for textiles at the time, Göran Ydstrand.” [12] In response to these accusations, Barner and her team went to talk to suppliers in Nepal, Bangladesh, and India. They also conducted surprise raids on rug factories and confirmed that there was child labor in these factories. The issue of child labor, along with the accusations of having formaldehyde (a harmful chemical) in IKEA’s best selling BILLY bookcases and the discovery of unsafe working conditions for adults (such as dipping hands in petrol without gloves), led to increased costs and a significantly damaged reputation for the company.

It was later discovered that the German film released in 1995 was fake, and the renowned German journalist who was responsible for this film was involved in “several fake reports about different subjects and companies.” [13] IKEA was now left with three options. First, some members of IKEA management wanted to permanently shut down production of their rugs in South Asia. Another option was to do nothing and proceed with its existing practices now that it was announced that the film was fake. The third option was that the company could attempt to tackle the issue of child labor that was clearly evident in its supply chain, regardless of whether the film was fake or not. IKEA ultimately decided to opt for the third option, and its recent discoveries would eventually help guide the policies the company implemented to address these issues, particularly child labor in India.

Steps Taken to Address Child Labor in the Supply Chain

IKEA took multiple steps to deal with its damaged reputation and issues of child labor in its supply chain. One way in which it did this was through institutional partnerships. One such partnership was with Save the Children, which began in 1994. According to Save the Children’s website, one of the main goals of their partnership is to realize children's “rights to a healthy and secure childhood, which includes a quality education. By listening to and learning from children, we develop long-term projects that empower communities to create a better everyday life for children.” [14] Furthermore, the partnership is intended to “drive sustainable business operations across the entire value chain.” [15] Together, IKEA and Save the Children are focused on addressing the main causes of child labor in India’s cotton-growing areas. [16] Save the Children also advised IKEA to bring in an independent consultant to ensure that suppliers were in compliance with their agreements, which further improved IKEA’s practices in its supply chain. IKEA also partnered with UNICEF to combat child labor in its supply chain. According to the IKEA Foundation, in 2014, IKEA provided UNICEF with six new grants totaling €24.9 million with a focus “on reaching the most marginalized and disadvantaged children living in poor communities and in strengthening UNICEF’s response in emergency and conflict situations.” Additionally, five of the six grants were given to help programs in “Afghanistan, China, India, Pakistan, and Rwanda,” with a “focus on early childhood development, child protection, education, and helping adolescents to improve their lives and strengthen their communities.” [17]

Next, IKEA and Save the Children worked together to develop IWAY, which was launched in 2000. [18] IWAY is the IKEA code of conduct for suppliers. According to the IKEA website, “IWAY is the IKEA way of responsibly sourcing products, services, materials and components. It sets clear expectations and ways of working for environmental, social and working conditions, as well as animal welfare, and is mandatory for all suppliers and service providers that work with IKEA.” [19] In addition, IWAY is meant to have an impact in the following four areas: “promoting positive impacts on the environment,” “securing decent and meaningful work for workers,” “respecting children’s rights”, and “improving the welfare of animals in the IKEA value chain.” [20] IWAY is used as a foundation to collaborate with IKEA’s suppliers and sub-contractors to ensure supply chain transparency.

As mentioned previously, one of the main goals of IKEA’s partnership with Save the Children was to address child labor in India’s cotton-growing areas. To do this, IKEA and Save the Children developed a program that would ultimately help more than 1,800 villages between 2009 and 2014. More specifically, the program moved nearly 150,000 children out of child labor and into classrooms. Also, as a result of this program, more than 10,000 migrant children “moved back into their home communities.” [21] Last but not least, the program trained almost 2,000 teachers and 1,866 Anganwadi workers (whose duties include teaching students and educating villagers on healthcare [22] ) in order to provide each village with a community leader. This was to ensure that the community had a skilled leader to assist in educating the villagers. In 2012, the IKEA Foundation and Save the Children announced that they would expand with new programs in Punjab, Haryana, and Rajasthan. This joint program illustrates IKEA’s commitment to improving communities in addition to helping children go to school.

Conclusion & Looking Ahead

IKEA has taken numerous steps to ensure that suppliers abide by the IWAY Code of Conduct. Companies around the world can learn from the policies IKEA has put in place to ensure that each company has control and complete oversight over their supply chains, which can lead to a more transparent and ethical supply chain. According to The IKEA WAY on Purchasing Products, Materials and Services, one way in which IKEA does this is by requiring all suppliers to share the content of the code to all co-workers and sub-suppliers, thus leading to more accountability among the company's suppliers. IKEA also believes in the importance of long term relationships with its suppliers. Therefore, if for some reason, a supplier is not meeting the standards set forth by the code, IKEA will continue to work with the supplier if the supplier shows a willingness to improve its practices with actionable steps to complete before a specified period of time. [23]

Additionally, during the IWAY implementation process, IKEA monitors its suppliers and service providers. To do this, IKEA has a team of auditors who conduct audits (both announced and unannounced) at supplier facilities. The auditors are also in charge of following up on action plans if suppliers are failing to meet the agreed upon standards specified by IWAY. Along with this, “IKEA…has the Compliance and Monitoring Group, an internal independent group that is responsible for independent verification of implementation and compliance activities related to IWAY and Sustainability.” [24] IKEA also has independent third party teams who conduct inspections on behalf of IKEA. [25] By conducting audits and putting together teams to ensure cooperation from suppliers throughout the supply chain, companies can be better equipped to prevent unethical practices in the production of goods and services. In Ximeng Han’s Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management, Han highlights IWAY’s importance in maintaining links with IKEA’s suppliers. [26] Therefore, IWAY plays a crucial role in ensuring supply chain transparency and in building a more ethical and sustainable supply chain.

In addition to all of the policies IKEA has put in place to address issues in its supply chain, the company has also donated a lot of money to combat child labor in India. More specifically, according to an IKEA Foundation article written in 2013, “Since 2000, the IKEA Foundation has committed €60 million to help fight child labour in India and Pakistan, aiming to prevent children from working in the cotton, metalware and carpet industries.” [27] Furthermore, in 2009, the company announced that it would donate $48 million to UNICEF to “help poor children in India.” [28]

IKEA’s goal to completely eliminate child labor from its supply chain is an ongoing battle, and it is still committed to ensuring that this is ultimately the case. More specifically, it is extremely difficult to completely eliminate child labor from a company’s supply chain because of the various aspects involved. According to a report published in 2018 by the International Labour Organization, these aspects include a legal commitment, building and “extending” social protection systems (including helping people find jobs), “expanding access to free, quality public education,” addressing supply chain issues, and providing more protection for children in general. [29] Furthermore, Han points out the potential downsides that could arise as a result of having a global supply chain like IKEA does. Given IKEA is an international retailer, the company “has to spend a lot of time, money and manpower to enter new markets due to the different cultures, laws and competitive markets in different regions, and there is also a significant risk of zero return.” [30] Han also argues that the COVID-19 pandemic showed IKEA’s and many other companies’ inability to respond to “fluctuations in supply and demand,” primarily due to inflexible supply chains. [31] This information points out the various aspects that need to align in order to completely end the issue of child labor throughout the world, as well as the difficulties of having a global supply chain, which is why child labor is so difficult to completely eliminate.

Specific to IKEA’s actions, in 2021, IKEA announced three key focus areas for its action pledge: “Further integrating children’s rights into the existing IKEA due diligence system (by reviewing IWAY from a child rights’ perspective in order to strengthen the code),” “accelerating the work to promote decent work for young workers,” and partnering “up to increase and scale efforts.” [32] IKEA’s fight to end child labor in India highlights the importance of supply chain transparency and putting policies in place that ensures cooperation from suppliers and all parties involved. Additionally, in a Forbes article written in 2021, “According to the data from the OpenText survey…When asked whether purchasing ethically sourced and/or produced products matters, 81 percent of respondents said yes.” [33] Steve Banker, who covers logistics and supply chain management, also adds, “What is interesting is that nearly 20 percent of these survey respondents said that it has only mattered to them within the last year, which indicates that the Covid pandemic, and some of the product shortages we have faced, has made consumers re-evaluate their stance on ethical sourcing.” [34] These results confirm that customers are now considering how a product was sourced in their purchasing decisions, which makes it even more important for IKEA to be transparent about its efforts to eliminate child labor from its supply chain. Furthermore, the company’s open commitment to eliminating child labor and helping communities in India is beneficial in maintaining a positive relationship with its stakeholders.

The increase in globalization has made it even more essential for companies to monitor their supply chains and have complete oversight over business practices. IKEA is one of the companies leading the way in building a more ethical and sustainable supply chain, but more companies need to follow suit and implement policies similar to IWAY that holds all parties in the supply chain accountable for their actions. Through supply chain transparency and accountability, companies will likely be better equipped to handle issues that arise throughout their respective supply chains. Furthermore, by implementing new policies, conducting audits, and maintaining close communication with suppliers, companies can work to eliminate child labor in their supply chains and put children where they belong: in school.

Reflection Questions:

• What does this case teach you about supply chain ethics?
• What are some of the ways in which management/leaders can ensure compliance of the standards set forth by a company in terms of supplier behavior and ethical sourcing?
• Who is primarily responsible for ensuring ethical behavior throughout the supply chain? Is it the company? The suppliers? Both?
• How can companies utilize the various platforms and technologies that exist today to better understand and oversee their supply chains? 
• IKEA has taken numerous steps to address child labor in its supply chain. Do you think every business working in a context that may involve child labor has a duty to act in a similar way? Why or why not?

Works Cited 

“ About Ikea – Our Heritage .” IKEA.

“Anganwadi Workers.” Journals Of India , 16 June 2020. 

Banker, Steve. “ Do Consumers Care about Ethical Sourcing? ” Forbes , 9 Nov. 2022.

Bharadwaj , Prashant, et al. Perverse Consequences of Well-Intentioned Regulation ... - World Bank Group .

“ Child Labor in the Carpet Industry Rugmark: Carpets: Rugs: Pakistan .” Child Labor in the Carpet Industry RugMark |Carpets | Rugs | Pakistan .

“ Creating a Sustainable IKEA Value Chain with Iway. ” Sustainability Is Key in Our Supplier Code of Conduct .

“ Ending Child Labour by 2025 - International Labour Organization .” International Labour Organization .

“ Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA .” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

Foundation , ECLT. “ Why Does Child Labour Happen? Here Are Some of the Root Causes. ” ECLT Foundation , 17 May 2023.

Han, Ximeng. “ Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management. ” Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management | Atlantis Press , 27 Dec. 2022.

“ Human Rights and Global Sourcing: IKEA in India. ” Journal of International Management , 13 May 2011.

“ IKEA and IKEA Foundation .” Save the Children International .

“ IKEA Foundation Contributes €24.9 Million to UNICEF to Help Advance Children’s Rights. ” IKEA Foundation , 26 May 2020.

“ IKEA Foundation Helps Fight the Roots Causes of Child Labour in Pakistan .” IKEA Foundation , 18 Feb. 2013.

“ Ikea Gives $48 Million to Fight India Child Labor .” NBC News , 23 Feb. 2009.

“ IKEA Supports 2021 as the UN International Year for the Elimination of Child Labour. ” About IKEA.

The Ikea Way on Purchasing Products , Materials and Services .

Jasińska, Joanna, et al. “ Flat-Pack Success: IKEA Turns to Poland for Its Furniture. ” – The First News .

Thomas , Susan. “ IKEA Foundation Tackles Child Labor in India’s Cotton Communities .” Boston College Center for Corporate Citizenship , 15 July 2014.

[1] “About Ikea – Our Heritage.” IKEA .

[2] Jasińska, Joanna, et al. “Flat-Pack Success: IKEA Turns to Poland for Its Furniture.” – The First News .

[3] “Human Rights and Global Sourcing: IKEA in India.” Journal of International Management , 13 May 2011.

[4] “Human Rights and Global Sourcing: IKEA in India.” Journal of International Management , 13 May 2011.

[5] “Human Rights and Global Sourcing: IKEA in India.” Journal of International Management , 13 May 2011.

[6] “Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA.” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

[7] “Child Labor in the Carpet Industry Rugmark: Carpets: Rugs: Pakistan.” Child Labor in the Carpet Industry RugMark |Carpets | Rugs | Pakistan .

[8] Foundation , ECLT. “Why Does Child Labour Happen? Here Are Some of the Root Causes.” ECLT Foundation , 17 May 2023.

[9] Bharadwaj , Prashant, et al. Perverse Consequences of Well-Intentioned Regulation ... - World Bank Group .

[10] “Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA.” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

[11] “Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA.” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

[12] “Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA.” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

[13] “Film on Child Labour Is Eye-Opener for IKEA.” IKEA Museum , 31 Mar. 2022.

[14] “IKEA and IKEA Foundation.” Save the Children International .

[15] “IKEA and IKEA Foundation.” Save the Children International .

[16] “IKEA and IKEA Foundation.” Save the Children International .

[17] “IKEA Foundation Contributes €24.9 Million to UNICEF to Help Advance Children’s Rights.” IKEA Foundation , 26 May 2020.

[18] “IKEA and IKEA Foundation.” Save the Children International .

[19] “Creating a Sustainable IKEA Value Chain with Iway.” Sustainability Is Key in Our Supplier Code of Conduct .

[20] “Creating a Sustainable IKEA Value Chain with Iway.” Sustainability Is Key in Our Supplier Code of Conduct .

[21] Thomas, Susan. “IKEA Foundation Tackles Child Labor in India’s Cotton Communities.” Boston College Center for Corporate Citizenship , 15 July 2014.

[22] “Anganwadi Workers.” Journals Of India , 16 June 2020.

[23] The Ikea Way on Purchasing Products, Materials and Services .

[24] The Ikea Way on Purchasing Products, Materials and Services .

[25] The Ikea Way on Purchasing Products, Materials and Services .

[26] Han, Ximeng. “Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management.” Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management | Atlantis Press , 27 Dec. 2022.

[27] “IKEA Foundation Helps Fight the Roots Causes of Child Labour in Pakistan.” IKEA Foundation , 18 Feb. 2013.

[28] “Ikea Gives $48 Million to Fight India Child Labor.” NBC News , 23 Feb. 2009.

[29] “Ending Child Labour by 2025 - International Labour Organization.” International Labour Organization .

[30] Han, Ximeng. “Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management.” Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management | Atlantis Press , 27 Dec. 2022.

[31] Han, Ximeng. “Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management.” Analysis and Reflection of IKEA’s Supply Chain Management | Atlantis Press , 27 Dec. 2022.

[32] “IKEA Supports 2021 as the UN International Year for the Elimination of Child Labour.” About IKEA .

[33] Banker, Steve. “Do Consumers Care about Ethical Sourcing?” Forbes , 9 Nov. 2022.

[34] Banker, Steve. “Do Consumers Care about Ethical Sourcing?” Forbes , 9 Nov. 2022.

• --> Login or Sign Up

Shop by Author

• Sabrineh Ardalan
• Robert Bordone
• Robert Clark
• John Coates
• Susan Crawford
• Alonzo Emery
• Heidi Gardner
• Philip B. Heymann
• Howell E. Jackson
• Wendy Jacobs
• Adriaan Lanni
• Jeremy McClane
• Naz Modirzadeh
• Catherine Mondell
• Ashish Nanda
• Charles R. Nesson
• John Palfrey
• Bruce Patton
• Todd D. Rakoff
• Lisa Rohrer
• Jeswald W. Salacuse
• James Sebenius

Joseph William Singer

• Holger Spamann
• Carol Steiker
• Guhan Subramanian
• Lawrence Susskind
• David B. Wilkins
• Jonathan Zittrain

Shop by Brand

• Howell Jackson
• Ashish Nanda and Nicholas Semi Haas
• Chad M. Carr
• John Coates, Clayton Rose, and David Lane
• Ashish Nanda and Lauren Prusiner
• Ashish Nanda and Lisa Rohrer
• Ashish Nanda and Monet Brewerton
• View all Brands
• $0.00 - $2.00
• $2.00 - $4.00
• $4.00 - $6.00
• $6.00 - $8.00
• $8.00 - $10.00

Employment Law

• Published Old-New
• Published New-Old

OUR Walmart

Sharon Block, Lisa Brem, and Brittany Deitch

Worker Centers

The Case of the Unpaid Interns

Duncan Farthing-Nichol, with Todd Rakoff

Workers' Rights in the Hudson Valley (B)

John Coates and Sara Del Nido

Workers' Rights in the Hudson Valley (A)

Sheila Heen

The Case of the Encumbered Employee

An Italian Case Study: Labour Inspectors Dealing with Labour Exploitation

• First Online: 15 August 2023

Cite this chapter

• Rebecca Paraciani 2  

43 Accesses

This chapter centres on the Italian context. The regulatory ambiguity surrounding the phenomenon of labour exploitation in Italy is presented. After this, the ways in which the exploitation is classified as “severe,” which falls under criminal jurisdiction, or “non-severe,” which is considered part of labour law jurisdiction, are discussed. The reference legislation is so vague that it is difficult to apply. Therefore, labour inspectors’ discretion is a fundamental work tool. Through documentary analysis, the inspectors’ powers and professional duties as well as the ways in which they have changed over time are detailed. The last section uses a purely neo-institutionalist perspective to reinterpret labour inspectors’ main organisational and professional transformations that occur through coercive, mimetic, and normative isomorphic pressures.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this chapter

• Available as PDF
• Read on any device
• Instant download
• Own it forever
• Available as EPUB and PDF
• Durable hardcover edition
• Dispatched in 3 to 5 business days
• Free shipping worldwide - see info

Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout

Purchases are for personal use only

Institutional subscriptions

Italian Criminal Code, Book II, Title XII, Chapter III, Section I, Article 603a, “Illegal intermediation and exploitation of labour.”

Berger, P. L., & Luckmann, T. (1967). The social construction of reality. A treatise in the sociology of knowledge . Anchor Books Edition.

Google Scholar  

Buffa, F., Gadaleta, L., & Riverso, R. (2017). Sfruttamento lavorativo . Key Editore.

Carchedi, F. (Ed.). (2010). Schiavitù di ritorno: il fenomeno del lavoro gravemente sfruttato: le vittime, i servizi di protezione, i percorsi di uscita, il quadro normativo . Maggioli editore.

Chuang, J. A. (2014). Exploitation creep and the unmaking of human trafficking law. American Journal of International Law, 108 (4), 609–649.

Article   Google Scholar  

Ciconte, E., & Romani, P. (2002). Le nuove schiavitù: il traffico degli esseri umani nell’Italia del XXI secolo . Editori riuniti.

Del Bò, C. (2004). Un reddito per tutti: un’introduzione al basic income . Ibis.

DiMaggio, P., & Powell, W. (1983). The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48 , 147–160.

Dragoni, C. (1904). Sull’istituzione di un ispettorato del lavoro. Giornale degli Economisti, 19 (15), 309–317.

Fatemi, M., & Behmanesh, M. R. (2012). New public management approach and accountability. International Journal of Management, Economics and Social Sciences (IJMESS), 1 (2), 42–49.

FRA. (2015), Severe labour exploitation: Workers moving within or into the European Union: States’ obligations and victims’ rights. Vienna.

Gualmini, E., & Rizza, R. (2013). Le politiche del lavoro . Il Mulino.

Hood, C. (1991). A public management for all seasons? Public Administration, 69 (1), 3–19.

Leogrande, A. (2016). Il caporalato e le nuove schiavitù. Parolechiave, 24 (1), 103–108.

McLaughlin, E., Muncie, J., & Hughes, G. (2001). The permanent revolution: New Labour, new public management and the modernization of criminal justice. Criminal Justice, 1 (3), 301–318.

Moini, G. (Ed.) (2015), Neoliberismi e azione pubblica: Il caso italiano , Roma: Ediesse.

Nocifora, E. (2014). Quasi schiavi . Maggioli Editore.

Osborne, D., & Gaebler, T. (1993). Reinventing government: The five strategies for reinventing government . Plume.

Book   Google Scholar  

Perrotta, D. (2014). Vecchi e nuovi mediatori. Storia, geografia ed etnografia del caporalato in agricoltura. Meridiana , 193–220.

Piro, V. (2021). Migrant farmworkers in ‘plastic factories’: Investigating work-life struggles . Palgrave Macmillan.

Piva, D. (2017). I limiti dell'intervento penale sul caporalato come sistema (e non condotta) di produzione: brevi note a margine della legge n. 199/2016 , 184–196.

Pollitt, C. (2007). The new public management: An overview of its current status. Administratie Si Management Public, 8 , 110.

Power, M. (2010). La società dei controlli . Edizioni di comunità.

Rizza, R., & Sansavini, M. (2013). Pragmatiche della sicurezza sul lavoro fra pratiche organizzative e discorsi. Sociologia del Lavoro, 130 , 103–120.

Rovelli, C. (2008). Loop quantum gravity. Living Reviews in Relativity, 11 (1), 5.

Sacchetto, D. (2009). Fabbriche galleggianti: solitudine e sfruttamento dei nuovi marinai . Editoriale Jaca Book.

Scott, W. R. (2008). Lords of the dance: Professionals as institutional agents. Organization Studies, 29 (2), 219–238.

Sensat, J. (1984). Exploitation . Nous, 21–38.

Steiner, J. R., Briggs, T. L., & Gross, G. M. (1984). Emerging social work traditions, profession building, and curriculum policy statements. Journal of Education for Social Work, 20 (1), 23–31.

Wertheimer, A. (1996). Remarks on coercion and exploitation. Denv. UL Rev, 74 , 889.

Wood, A. W. (1995). Exploitation. Social Philosophy And Policy, 12 (2), 136–158.

Zagrebelsky, G. (2013). Fondata sul lavoro. La solitudine dell’articolo 1 . Einaudi.

Zucchetti, R., Capone, M., & Carra, A. (2001). Manuale di ispezione sulla sicurezza del lavoro . Maggioli.

Download references

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

Department of Sociology and Business Law, University of Bologna, Strada Maggiore 45, Bologna, Italy

Rebecca Paraciani

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

Copyright information

© 2023 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG

About this chapter

Paraciani, R. (2023). An Italian Case Study: Labour Inspectors Dealing with Labour Exploitation. In: Labour Inspectors in Italy. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-37997-0_3

Download citation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-37997-0_3

Published : 15 August 2023

Publisher Name : Palgrave Macmillan, Cham

Print ISBN : 978-3-031-37996-3

Online ISBN : 978-3-031-37997-0

eBook Packages : Social Sciences Social Sciences (R0)

Share this chapter

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

• Publish with us

Policies and ethics

• Find a journal
• Track your research

Labor Progression Case Study (45 min)

Watch More! Unlock the full videos with a FREE trial

Included In This Lesson

Access More! View the full outline and transcript with a FREE trial

A 27-year-old female who is 40 weeks and 2 days pregnant, with contractions occurring once every 10 minutes. The patient is checked in, vital signs are normal, fetal heart tones are normal and the mother and father to-be are settled into their room for the night. It is 4 am and the call light goes off. The patient reports she is feeling contractions every 2 minutes now and she thinks her water may have broken.

How can the nurse find out if the patients water has broken?

• Check for fluid exiting the vagina, use a Nitrazine test to evaluate if it is amniotic fluid or urine or vaginal discharge

What color should the test be if the membranes have ruptured?

• Blue/purple

The nurse prepares to test the fluid that has leaked down the patients’ leg. The test comes back positive for amniotic fluid. The nurse informs the doctor and prepares the patient to deliver.

What is the most important thing to have ready at this time?

• An infant warmer, if delivery happens the infant needs to be cleaned and placed under the infant warmer while an APGAR test is performed.

The nurse is prepared for the delivery and is talking the mother through her breathing, the cervix is dilated to 7 cm and the contractions are now 1 minute apart.

Vital signs are as follows:

BP 110/67 mmHg

Fetal HR 133 bpm

The nurse checks the presentation of the baby and notes the baby head is in the vertex position, the bottom is in the frank position and baby is in the -1 station.

What station number means the baby is starting to come out?

• Positive numbers indicate the baby is starting to exit the pelvis.

What cardinal movement is the baby currently in?

• Engagement, also called lighting or dropping.

The nurse monitors mom and baby for another hour and upon re-checking the position of the baby the nurse notes that the baby is now +1 station and the cardinal movement is descent and flexion.

What does the nurse need to make sure has happened?

• The doctor has been brought to bedside and staff is ready for delivery

As the baby is delivered the occiput is facing the right side of the pelvis and towards the front.

What position is the newborn in at delivery?

• Right Occiput Anterior (ROA)

View the FULL Outline

When you start a FREE trial you gain access to the full outline as well as:

• SIMCLEX (NCLEX Simulator)
• 6,500+ Practice NCLEX Questions
• 2,000+ HD Videos
• 300+ Nursing Cheatsheets

“Would suggest to all nursing students . . . Guaranteed to ease the stress!”

Nursing Case Studies

This nursing case study course is designed to help nursing students build critical thinking.  Each case study was written by experienced nurses with first hand knowledge of the “real-world” disease process.  To help you increase your nursing clinical judgement (critical thinking), each unfolding nursing case study includes answers laid out by Blooms Taxonomy  to help you see that you are progressing to clinical analysis.We encourage you to read the case study and really through the “critical thinking checks” as this is where the real learning occurs.  If you get tripped up by a specific question, no worries, just dig into an associated lesson on the topic and reinforce your understanding.  In the end, that is what nursing case studies are all about – growing in your clinical judgement.

Nursing Case Studies Introduction

Cardiac nursing case studies.

• 6 Questions
• 7 Questions
• 5 Questions
• 4 Questions

GI/GU Nursing Case Studies

• 2 Questions
• 8 Questions

Obstetrics Nursing Case Studies

Respiratory nursing case studies.

• 10 Questions

Pediatrics Nursing Case Studies

• 3 Questions
• 12 Questions

Neuro Nursing Case Studies

Mental health nursing case studies.

• 9 Questions

Metabolic/Endocrine Nursing Case Studies

Other nursing case studies.

Inter-Agency Toolkit | Child Labour Case Studies

Find ALL 34 Case Studies  in the Inter-Agency Toolkit on Preventing and Responding to Child Protection in Humanitarian Action! 

Data Analytics Case Study Guide 2024

by Sam McKay, CFA | Data Analytics

Data analytics case studies reveal how businesses harness data for informed decisions and growth.

For aspiring data professionals, mastering the case study process will enhance your skills and increase your career prospects.

So, how do you approach a case study?

Use these steps to process a data analytics case study:

Understand the Problem: Grasp the core problem or question addressed in the case study.

Collect Relevant Data: Gather data from diverse sources, ensuring accuracy and completeness.

Apply Analytical Techniques: Use appropriate methods aligned with the problem statement.

Visualize Insights: Utilize visual aids to showcase patterns and key findings.

Derive Actionable Insights: Focus on deriving meaningful actions from the analysis.

This article will give you detailed steps to navigate a case study effectively and understand how it works in real-world situations.

By the end of the article, you will be better equipped to approach a data analytics case study, strengthening your analytical prowess and practical application skills.

Let’s dive in!

Table of Contents

What is a Data Analytics Case Study?

A data analytics case study is a real or hypothetical scenario where analytics techniques are applied to solve a specific problem or explore a particular question.

It’s a practical approach that uses data analytics methods, assisting in deciphering data for meaningful insights. This structured method helps individuals or organizations make sense of data effectively.

Additionally, it’s a way to learn by doing, where there’s no single right or wrong answer in how you analyze the data.

So, what are the components of a case study?

Key Components of a Data Analytics Case Study

A data analytics case study comprises essential elements that structure the analytical journey:

Problem Context: A case study begins with a defined problem or question. It provides the context for the data analysis , setting the stage for exploration and investigation.

Data Collection and Sources: It involves gathering relevant data from various sources , ensuring data accuracy, completeness, and relevance to the problem at hand.

Analysis Techniques: Case studies employ different analytical methods, such as statistical analysis, machine learning algorithms, or visualization tools, to derive meaningful conclusions from the collected data.

Insights and Recommendations: The ultimate goal is to extract actionable insights from the analyzed data, offering recommendations or solutions that address the initial problem or question.

Now that you have a better understanding of what a data analytics case study is, let’s talk about why we need and use them.

Why Case Studies are Integral to Data Analytics

Case studies serve as invaluable tools in the realm of data analytics, offering multifaceted benefits that bolster an analyst’s proficiency and impact:

Real-Life Insights and Skill Enhancement: Examining case studies provides practical, real-life examples that expand knowledge and refine skills. These examples offer insights into diverse scenarios, aiding in a data analyst’s growth and expertise development.

Validation and Refinement of Analyses: Case studies demonstrate the effectiveness of data-driven decisions across industries, providing validation for analytical approaches. They showcase how organizations benefit from data analytics. Also, this helps in refining one’s own methodologies

Showcasing Data Impact on Business Outcomes: These studies show how data analytics directly affects business results, like increasing revenue, reducing costs, or delivering other measurable advantages. Understanding these impacts helps articulate the value of data analytics to stakeholders and decision-makers.

Learning from Successes and Failures: By exploring a case study, analysts glean insights from others’ successes and failures, acquiring new strategies and best practices. This learning experience facilitates professional growth and the adoption of innovative approaches within their own data analytics work.

Including case studies in a data analyst’s toolkit helps gain more knowledge, improve skills, and understand how data analytics affects different industries.

Using these real-life examples boosts confidence and success, guiding analysts to make better and more impactful decisions in their organizations.

But not all case studies are the same.

Let’s talk about the different types.

Types of Data Analytics Case Studies

Data analytics encompasses various approaches tailored to different analytical goals:

Exploratory Case Study: These involve delving into new datasets to uncover hidden patterns and relationships, often without a predefined hypothesis. They aim to gain insights and generate hypotheses for further investigation.

Predictive Case Study: These utilize historical data to forecast future trends, behaviors, or outcomes. By applying predictive models, they help anticipate potential scenarios or developments.

Diagnostic Case Study: This type focuses on understanding the root causes or reasons behind specific events or trends observed in the data. It digs deep into the data to provide explanations for occurrences.

Prescriptive Case Study: This case study goes beyond analytics; it provides actionable recommendations or strategies derived from the analyzed data. They guide decision-making processes by suggesting optimal courses of action based on insights gained.

Each type has a specific role in using data to find important insights, helping in decision-making, and solving problems in various situations.

Regardless of the type of case study you encounter, here are some steps to help you process them.

Roadmap to Handling a Data Analysis Case Study

Embarking on a data analytics case study requires a systematic approach, step-by-step, to derive valuable insights effectively.

Here are the steps to help you through the process:

Step 1: Understanding the Case Study Context: Immerse yourself in the intricacies of the case study. Delve into the industry context, understanding its nuances, challenges, and opportunities.

Identify the central problem or question the study aims to address. Clarify the objectives and expected outcomes, ensuring a clear understanding before diving into data analytics.

Step 2: Data Collection and Validation: Gather data from diverse sources relevant to the case study. Prioritize accuracy, completeness, and reliability during data collection. Conduct thorough validation processes to rectify inconsistencies, ensuring high-quality and trustworthy data for subsequent analysis.

Step 3: Problem Definition and Scope: Define the problem statement precisely. Articulate the objectives and limitations that shape the scope of your analysis. Identify influential variables and constraints, providing a focused framework to guide your exploration.

Step 4: Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA): Leverage exploratory techniques to gain initial insights. Visualize data distributions, patterns, and correlations, fostering a deeper understanding of the dataset. These explorations serve as a foundation for more nuanced analysis.

Step 5: Data Preprocessing and Transformation: Cleanse and preprocess the data to eliminate noise, handle missing values, and ensure consistency. Transform data formats or scales as required, preparing the dataset for further analysis.

Step 6: Data Modeling and Method Selection: Select analytical models aligning with the case study’s problem, employing statistical techniques, machine learning algorithms, or tailored predictive models.

In this phase, it’s important to develop data modeling skills. This helps create visuals of complex systems using organized data, which helps solve business problems more effectively.

Understand key data modeling concepts, utilize essential tools like SQL for database interaction, and practice building models from real-world scenarios.

Furthermore, strengthen data cleaning skills for accurate datasets, and stay updated with industry trends to ensure relevance.

Step 7: Model Evaluation and Refinement: Evaluate the performance of applied models rigorously. Iterate and refine models to enhance accuracy and reliability, ensuring alignment with the objectives and expected outcomes.

Step 8: Deriving Insights and Recommendations: Extract actionable insights from the analyzed data. Develop well-structured recommendations or solutions based on the insights uncovered, addressing the core problem or question effectively.

Step 9: Communicating Results Effectively: Present findings, insights, and recommendations clearly and concisely. Utilize visualizations and storytelling techniques to convey complex information compellingly, ensuring comprehension by stakeholders.

Step 10: Reflection and Iteration: Reflect on the entire analysis process and outcomes. Identify potential improvements and lessons learned. Embrace an iterative approach, refining methodologies for continuous enhancement and future analyses.

This step-by-step roadmap provides a structured framework for thorough and effective handling of a data analytics case study.

Now, after handling data analytics comes a crucial step; presenting the case study.

Presenting Your Data Analytics Case Study

Presenting a data analytics case study is a vital part of the process. When presenting your case study, clarity and organization are paramount.

To achieve this, follow these key steps:

Structuring Your Case Study: Start by outlining relevant and accurate main points. Ensure these points align with the problem addressed and the methodologies used in your analysis.

Crafting a Narrative with Data: Start with a brief overview of the issue, then explain your method and steps, covering data collection, cleaning, stats, and advanced modeling.

Visual Representation for Clarity: Utilize various visual aids—tables, graphs, and charts—to illustrate patterns, trends, and insights. Ensure these visuals are easy to comprehend and seamlessly support your narrative.

Highlighting Key Information: Use bullet points to emphasize essential information, maintaining clarity and allowing the audience to grasp key takeaways effortlessly. Bold key terms or phrases to draw attention and reinforce important points.

Addressing Audience Queries: Anticipate and be ready to answer audience questions regarding methods, assumptions, and results. Demonstrating a profound understanding of your analysis instills confidence in your work.

Integrity and Confidence in Delivery: Maintain a neutral tone and avoid exaggerated claims about findings. Present your case study with integrity, clarity, and confidence to ensure the audience appreciates and comprehends the significance of your work.

By organizing your presentation well, telling a clear story through your analysis, and using visuals wisely, you can effectively share your data analytics case study.

This method helps people understand better, stay engaged, and draw valuable conclusions from your work.

We hope by now, you are feeling very confident processing a case study. But with any process, there are challenges you may encounter.

Key Challenges in Data Analytics Case Studies

A data analytics case study can present various hurdles that necessitate strategic approaches for successful navigation:

Challenge 1: Data Quality and Consistency

Challenge: Inconsistent or poor-quality data can impede analysis, leading to erroneous insights and flawed conclusions.

Solution: Implement rigorous data validation processes, ensuring accuracy, completeness, and reliability. Employ data cleansing techniques to rectify inconsistencies and enhance overall data quality.

Challenge 2: Complexity and Scale of Data

Challenge: Managing vast volumes of data with diverse formats and complexities poses analytical challenges.

Solution: Utilize scalable data processing frameworks and tools capable of handling diverse data types. Implement efficient data storage and retrieval systems to manage large-scale datasets effectively.

Challenge 3: Interpretation and Contextual Understanding

Challenge: Interpreting data without contextual understanding or domain expertise can lead to misinterpretations.

Solution: Collaborate with domain experts to contextualize data and derive relevant insights. Invest in understanding the nuances of the industry or domain under analysis to ensure accurate interpretations.

Challenge 4: Privacy and Ethical Concerns

Challenge: Balancing data access for analysis while respecting privacy and ethical boundaries poses a challenge.

Solution: Implement robust data governance frameworks that prioritize data privacy and ethical considerations. Ensure compliance with regulatory standards and ethical guidelines throughout the analysis process.

Challenge 5: Resource Limitations and Time Constraints

Challenge: Limited resources and time constraints hinder comprehensive analysis and exhaustive data exploration.

Solution: Prioritize key objectives and allocate resources efficiently. Employ agile methodologies to iteratively analyze and derive insights, focusing on the most impactful aspects within the given timeframe.

Recognizing these challenges is key; it helps data analysts adopt proactive strategies to mitigate obstacles. This enhances the effectiveness and reliability of insights derived from a data analytics case study.

Now, let’s talk about the best software tools you should use when working with case studies.

Top 5 Software Tools for Case Studies

In the realm of case studies within data analytics, leveraging the right software tools is essential.

Here are some top-notch options:

Tableau : Renowned for its data visualization prowess, Tableau transforms raw data into interactive, visually compelling representations, ideal for presenting insights within a case study.

Python and R Libraries: These flexible programming languages provide many tools for handling data, doing statistics, and working with machine learning, meeting various needs in case studies.

Microsoft Excel : A staple tool for data analytics, Excel provides a user-friendly interface for basic analytics, making it useful for initial data exploration in a case study.

SQL Databases : Structured Query Language (SQL) databases assist in managing and querying large datasets, essential for organizing case study data effectively.

Statistical Software (e.g., SPSS , SAS ): Specialized statistical software enables in-depth statistical analysis, aiding in deriving precise insights from case study data.

Choosing the best mix of these tools, tailored to each case study’s needs, greatly boosts analytical abilities and results in data analytics.

Final Thoughts

Case studies in data analytics are helpful guides. They give real-world insights, improve skills, and show how data-driven decisions work.

Using case studies helps analysts learn, be creative, and make essential decisions confidently in their data work.

Check out our latest clip below to further your learning!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key steps to analyzing a data analytics case study.

When analyzing a case study, you should follow these steps:

Clarify the problem : Ensure you thoroughly understand the problem statement and the scope of the analysis.

Make assumptions : Define your assumptions to establish a feasible framework for analyzing the case.

Gather context : Acquire relevant information and context to support your analysis.

Analyze the data : Perform calculations, create visualizations, and conduct statistical analysis on the data.

Provide insights : Draw conclusions and develop actionable insights based on your analysis.

How can you effectively interpret results during a data scientist case study job interview?

During your next data science interview, interpret case study results succinctly and clearly. Utilize visual aids and numerical data to bolster your explanations, ensuring comprehension.

Frame the results in an audience-friendly manner, emphasizing relevance. Concentrate on deriving insights and actionable steps from the outcomes.

How do you showcase your data analyst skills in a project?

To demonstrate your skills effectively, consider these essential steps. Begin by selecting a problem that allows you to exhibit your capacity to handle real-world challenges through analysis.

Methodically document each phase, encompassing data cleaning, visualization, statistical analysis, and the interpretation of findings.

Utilize descriptive analysis techniques and effectively communicate your insights using clear visual aids and straightforward language. Ensure your project code is well-structured, with detailed comments and documentation, showcasing your proficiency in handling data in an organized manner.

Lastly, emphasize your expertise in SQL queries, programming languages, and various analytics tools throughout the project. These steps collectively highlight your competence and proficiency as a skilled data analyst, demonstrating your capabilities within the project.

Can you provide an example of a successful data analytics project using key metrics?

A prime illustration is utilizing analytics in healthcare to forecast hospital readmissions. Analysts leverage electronic health records, patient demographics, and clinical data to identify high-risk individuals.

Implementing preventive measures based on these key metrics helps curtail readmission rates, enhancing patient outcomes and cutting healthcare expenses.

This demonstrates how data analytics, driven by metrics, effectively tackles real-world challenges, yielding impactful solutions.

Why would a company invest in data analytics?

Companies invest in data analytics to gain valuable insights, enabling informed decision-making and strategic planning. This investment helps optimize operations, understand customer behavior, and stay competitive in their industry.

Ultimately, leveraging data analytics empowers companies to make smarter, data-driven choices, leading to enhanced efficiency, innovation, and growth.

Related Posts

4 Types of Data Analytics: Explained

Data Analytics

In a world full of data, data analytics is the heart and soul of an operation. It's what transforms raw...

Data Analytics Outsourcing: Pros and Cons Explained

In today's data-driven world, businesses are constantly swimming in a sea of information, seeking the...

What Does a Data Analyst Do on a Daily Basis?

In the digital age, data plays a significant role in helping organizations make informed decisions and...