distance learning phd in pakistan

• Laws & Taxes
• Construction
• Real Estate Trends
• Zameen Product Updates
• Area Guides

Top 3 Universities Offering Distance Learning in Pakistan

Home » Lifestyle » Top 3 Universities Offering Distance Learning in Pakistan

Owing to its growing popularity around the world, a number of universities have begun to introduce special courses to facilitate distance learning in Pakistan.

From applied sciences to humanities, private and government institutes around the country are offering online degree programs in a number of disciplines at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels. 

Of course, the overall number of students opting for traditional learning is still higher than those enrolled in online degree programs in Pakistan. However, it is completely understandable as the latter is mostly preferred by working professionals and those who are unable to attend classes on a regular basis due to time or travel restrictions.

What is Distance Learning and How Does it Work?

By definition, distance learning or distance education is a way of studying remotely without being physically present in a classroom setup. There is also no regular face-to-face contact with a teacher, but that doesn’t mean students have to compromise on the quality of education.

Distance learning in Pakistan, or anywhere for that matter, largely depends on the online medium. Generally, universities offer online courses via: 

• Audio technology, which includes CDs, MP3 recordings and podcasts.
• Video technology, which includes DVDs, MP4 videos and interactive online sessions.
• Computer-delivered material, such as PDF files and eBooks.

Although the popularity of online courses in Pakistan has pretty much eliminated the demographic boundaries, students still need an active internet action to gain access to the study material.

Advantages of Distance Learning

The biggest advantage of distance education is that it allows you to modify your schedule, depending on your work hours and household responsibilities. Usually, people working 9 to 5 jobs are unable to opt for further studies as they are unable to quit their livelihood. However, thanks to online degree courses, you can study in your own time and at your own pace.

Secondly, distance education is cheaper than traditional learning. Not only do students can save money on fees, but they can also save money on travel by studying from the comfort of their homes.

Thirdly, you can pick and choose from a variety of subjects and programs, depending on your profession. In fact, even if you want to change careers after already being a part of the workforce for several years, you can simply opt for a higher degree in a related and switch jobs without having to start from the bottom of the food chain once again.

Of course, like everything else, there are a few disadvantages of distance learning. For instance, you won’t get a chance to regularly interact with your teacher or socialize with your peers. However, whether you enrol in an online course depends on your personal preference and circumstances. 

Top Universities Offering Online Degrees in Pakistan

Here are some of the best distance learning universities in Pakistan.

• Allama Iqbal Open University
• Virtual University of Pakistan
• COMSATS University

Let’s take a look at the courses, admission cycles and teaching methodologies at these universities.

Allama Iqbal Open University (AIOU)

Type : Public University

Considered one of the largest institutes of higher education in the world, Allama Iqbal Open University tops the list of online universities in Pakistan. Established in May 1974, it also has the honour of being the first Open University in Asia and second in the world.

AIOU has over a thousand study centres along with more than 40 regional centres and campuses offering remote study courses in Pakistan. Moreover, the university operates under the semester system and offers around 2000 different courses, providing educational opportunities to the masses across the country for a nominal fee.

Approximately 1.2 million students, most of whom are women, enrol at Allama Iqbal Open University every year, according to the institute’s official website. There is no age restriction for enrollment either.

Courses and Programs

These are the programs available at AIOU:

• PhD Programs
• MPhil Programs
• Master’s Program
• BEd Program
• Bachelors Program
• Post Graduate Diploma 
• Higher Secondary School Certificate (Intermediate)
• Secondary School Certificate (Matric)

The faculties operating under the Allama Iqbal Open University include: 

• Faculty of Arabic and Islamic Studies
• Faculty of Education
• Faculty of Science
• Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities

Teaching Methodology

Like most distance learning courses in Pakistan, AIOU uses a variety of methods to teach students. These include radio and television broadcasts, reading materials prepared on self-learning basis, special textbooks, study centres for practical experience as well as regular workshops and seminars for one-on-one interaction with teachers and peers. During these events, students are required to give presentations, which adds to their experience. 

The university’s study material can also be accessed online. Furthermore, students can also engage with part-time teachers and tutors associated with the university. Although distance education allows you to set your own schedule, the teaching methodology employed by Allama Iqbal Open University makes studying even easier for those who would have struggled with schoolwork their own.

Admission Cycle

AIOU has a semester-based system.

Admission Procedure

In order to enrol in AIOU’s distance learning courses, you first need to select the program you want to pursue and check if you fit the eligibility criteria. Then, purchases a prospectus from your nearest AIOU regional office or centre and fill the admission form as instructed. As for the course fee, you can submit it in the nearest branch of one of the banks mentioned in the prospectus. Get a stamped receipt from the bank officer and keep it with you until the admission list is confirmed.

For more information about admission requirements and fee structure at Allama Iqbal Open University, please contact the administration at the given number. You can also check their website for further clarification. 

Contact: 051-111-112-468

Address: Directorate of Students Advisory & Counselling Services, Gateway Block, Ground Floor, Allama Iqbal Open University, Sector H-8, Islamabad.

Virtual University of Pakistan (VU)

When it comes to distance learning courses in Pakistan, the first university that pops into mind is obviously the Virtual University of Pakistan. As a not-for-profit public sector university with over 190 campuses across the country, VU is certainly one of the most recognized government universities not just in Pakistan but also across the world. These campuses allow students to interact with each other and attend virtual lectures in a classroom-like setup. 

Established in 2012, Virtual University offers online degree courses at an affordable rate, making them accessible to those facing financial difficulties. As far as the academic cycle is concerned, the university offers a semester-based system. Moreover, with its tagline ‘World Class Education at Your Doorstep,’ VU provides students with various opportunities to interact with teachers and peers on a regular basis. 

If you’re looking for online universities in Pakistan offering quality education without putting much strain on your wallet, VU is probably your best bet. 

Moreover, overseas Pakistanis can also enrol at the Virtual University. 

The Higher Education Commission has developed the curricula for all the available programs at the Virtual University of Pakistan.

• Master’s Programs
• Bachelors Programs 
• Associate Degree Program
• Post Graduate Diploma

These are the faculties at Virtual University offering online courses in Pakistan. 

• Faculty of Arts
• Faculty of Computer Science and Information Technology
• Faculty of Management
• Faculty of Science and Technology

VU uses the latest technology to impart knowledge upon the students. Along with the interactive online classes, video lectures and tutorials, audio recording and reading material, the university also has an advanced Learning Management System (VULMS). It also broadcasts lectures on its own TV channels.

As of right now, Virtual University of Pakistan is operating four television channels, including VTV1, VTV2, VTV3 and VTV4. Although students can access these lectures at any time, the institute encourages them to follow a ‘Time Plan.’ Furthermore, students can easily speak with their teachers online. 

In addition to that, the virtual campuses located in nearly 100 cities across the country offer free internet facilities. Students can also purchase video lectures for a nominal fee via Virtual University’s online bookstore. 

The Virtual University of Pakistan offers two semesters per year.

Those wondering how to get an online degree in Pakistan can collect an admission form any of the VU campuses. You can either submit the duly filled form, along with the required documents, to the same campus or send it to the head office of the university.

You can also directly download the form from the university’s official website, which contains more instructions. However, if you have further any queries, you can directly contact the university as well.

Contact: 0800-880-88, 0304-111-0880

Address: MA Jinnah Campus, Defence Road, Off Raiwind Road, Lahore.

COMSATS University Islamabad (CUI)

Type: Public University

COMSATS University Islamabad, one of the top universities in Pakistan, also has a separate virtual campus along with seven physical ones. Established in 1998, COMSATS stands for the Commission on Science and Technology for Sustainable Development in the South, an international organization that aims to diminish the distance between the developed and developing countries via application of science and technology. It consists of 21 member countries in three continents. 

CUI was formerly known as COMSATS Institute of Information Technology (CII). However, it was upgraded to a Federally Chartered University in 2018.

The virtual campus of COMSATS has made it easier for students to pursue high-quality education and earn advanced degrees in disciplines such as computer science and information technology, among others, from the comfort of their home. 

These are the programs available at the virtual campus of CUI, also known as VCOMSATS. The total duration of each program may vary with the faculty or department. 

• Master’s Executive Programs
• Bachelor’s Programs
• Faculty of Management Sciences
• Faculty of Information & Technology
• Faculty of Sciences

Compared to other disciplines, computer science and IT subjects may seem a little hard to study via self-learning material. However, the advanced learning management software at the university, referred to as VCOMSATS LMS, provides students with a range of digitally recorded lectures, slideshows, quizzes, course content and information, glossary, FAQs, related web links and other course material. The LMS discussion boards and online forums also allow students to directly interact with teachers.

Apart from the official YouTube channel of VCOMSATS, students can also access digital lectures by buying CDs and DVDs from the university. Furthermore, the live video conferencing system offers students a chance to directly speak with their course head, which will undoubtedly improve their quality of learning.

COMSATS University Islamabad has a semester-based system for distance learning courses in Pakistan. 

Being one of the top online universities in Pakistan, CUI requires students to fill and submit a detailed admission form on its website. You don’t need to physically collect a form or travel to submit it anywhere.

For a better understanding of the admission requirement and fee structure for online degree courses, you can directly contact COMSATS at the number listed below. 

Contact: 051-9259406-8

Address: Main Campus, Park Road, Tarlai Kalan, Islamabad.

Meanwhile, if you are hoping to pursue a degree in medicine, pharmacy or one of the other related disciplines, don’t forget to check out our list of top medical universities in Karachi . These universities are renowned internationally and draw a large number of applications from all across the country.

For more information on educational institutes in different cities, stay tuned to Zameen Blog, the best lifestyle blog in Pakistan .

Your Guide to Investing in Bahria Town Rawalpindi and Islamabad

The latest LDA Avenue I update on rates and buying trends

Pakistan Beats India, Sri Lanka in the World Happiness Report 2021

Subscribe For Daily Blog Alert

Get the Zameen App

Sliding sidebar.

Introduction

This program, which spans a minimum of three years, provides an established and successful route to a professional doctorate. It is aimed at academics and professionals who wish to become effective members of the research community. This program is designed, structured and assessed in a way that supports distance and on-campus study, research and training. It utilizes evaluation criteria and guidelines that lead to achieving the PhD objectives.

Note: PhD Computer Science program is offered only once a year.

Program Objectives

• plan and carry out independent and original academic research,
• effectively document the research results in the form of research articles,
• present and defend their research at various national and international forums and among their peers,
• foresee and create exploitation plans for the research results,
• appreciate the existing knowledge,
• execute independent research in future.

PROGRAM STRUCTURE

Admission Eligibility Criteria

• 18-year education i.e., MS / M.Phil in Computer Science / Information Technology / Computer Engineering / Software Engineering or equivalent with thesis and minimum CGPA 3.0 out of 4.0 in the Semester System or 1st Division in the Annual System. For any other qualification, which corresponds to 18 years of education but does not fall under semester system or annual system or degree obtained from foreign country, then the student should obtain degree equivalence certificate from Higher Education Commission of Pakistan (HEC) to determine the academic eligibility for PhD.
• Each candidate is required to pass the VU Entry Test with minimum 70% marks OR 60% marks in GRE Subject Test along with interview and presentation.

Click here  to Download Entry Test Sample

COURSE EXEMPTION

Course(s) exemption is not allowed.  

Degree Completion Duration

COURSES OF STUDY

Click here to View Study Scheme

Assessment of Study Progress

The students’ study progress evaluation mechanism is based on continuous assessment throughout the semester by giving assignments, Quizzes, Graded Discussion Boards (GDBs), academic papers, seminars, mid-term and final term examinations.

Research Thesis

The students are required to submit a Research Thesis. Topic of the thesis must be decided after consultation with the supervisor.

Award of degree

For the award of PhD in Computer Science degree, a student is required to complete 18 credits hours of prescribed course work with minimum CGPA of 3.00 out of 4 along with Dissertation/Thesis of 12 credit hours. The student has also to:-

• Pass written and oral comprehensive examinations securing minimum 65% and 50% marks respectively, with maximum two attempts;
• Defend PhD research proposal;
• Get published at least one research paper in HEC recognized journal as first author;
• Get presented/read one research paper in a national/international conference as first author;
• Get approved dissertation from two foreign experts.

Fee Structure

Click here  to View Fee Structure

• The courses may be revised time to time as a result of continuous review to bring them at par with courses from being taught at top-class foreign universities. While reviewing the courses, needs of local industry and job market are also given full consideration.
• The University reserves the right to change fee structure from time to time.

Virtual University of Pakistan

Sir Syed Memorial Society Building, 19-Ataturk Avenue, G-5/1, Islamabad

(c) Virtual University of Pakistan

•  Help Desk 
•  [email protected] 
•  Screen Reader
•  051-111-112-468

Phd Programmes

Phd programmes.

Allama Iqbal Open University offers the following PhD programmes:

PhD Islamic Studies (Quran & Tafseer)

Phd shariah, phd islamic studies (general), phd islamic studies, phd education (specialization in distance and non-formal education-dnfe), phd (education) with specialization in science education, phd teacher education, doctor of philosophy (phd) in special education, phd mass communication, phd iqbal studies, phd in pakistani languages and literature (mphil based), phd english (linguistics), phd (business administration), phd chemistry, phd physics, phd in agricultural extension, phd statistics, phd (food & nut), phd history, phd education (specialization elementary teacher education), ph.d. islamic studies (specialization in seerat studies), phd arabic (mphil/ms based), phd mathematics, phd library and information sciences, phd (computer science).

Contact info Address : Sector H-8, Islamabad [email protected] 051 111 112 468 Helpdesk --> Quick Links About Us Jobs Tender Notices Downloads Research ORIC AIOU Library For Query Email Us [email protected] (Admission) [email protected] (Examination) [email protected] (Regional Services) [email protected] (Student Advisory) [email protected] (Treasurer)

The Allama Iqbal Open University was established in May, 1974, with the main objectives of providing educational opportunities to masses and to those who cannot leave their homes and jobs. During all these past years, the University has more than fulfilled this promise.

Call: (9221) 9926 1300-7

• Campus News
• Convocation
• Our history
• Morning Test based
• Bachelors/Masters Evening
• Evening Program 2021
• Admissions Program 2024
• M.Phil./Ph.D. & M.S./M.D.
• Foreign Students' Policy
• Engineering
• Islamic Studies
• Management Sciences
• Arts & Social Sciences
• Institutes / Centers
• Digital Library
• Vice Chancellor
• Syndicate Members
• Former Vice Chancellors
• Directorates & Offices
• Annual System
• Downloadable Forms
• Common Questions
• Overseas Examination
• Semester System
• Semester Rules Book
• Semester Fee

Directorate of Distance Education

• Introduction
• Vision & Mission
• The Vice Chancellor
• The Director
• Program Goals
• Degree Programs
• M.A Course Details
• ADC/B.Com Course Details
• Certificate Courses Detail
• Advertisment
• Application Form
• Application Forms
• Fee Voucher
• University Initiative
• Staff Members

Introduction:

University of Karachi has been contributing towards educational improvement in Pakistan through its Graduate, Masters, MS, MPhil, PhD programs and multiple short courses and diplomas. Recently, University of Karachi has established the Directorate of Distance Education, a unit of University of Karachi which aims to deliver the current and new programs “Online” also, using an contemporary online interactive teaching mechanism and filliped learning concepts. The environment will enable and facilitate the distant students with meaningful and consistent engagement with highly-trained faculty through the transformation of electronically delivered interactive courses and degree programs.

• News & Events
• Picture Gallery
• Pension Form

Quick Links

• Affiliation Committee
• Postgraduate Students Portal Registration
• Directorates & offices
• Student Advisor Office
• Annual Convocation
• Physical Education
• Tenders and Quotations
• Scholarships
• Placements and Internships
• Karachi University Journal of Science
• Facebook-MCN
• Download Center HEC-Microsoft
• Higher Education Commission
• Quality Enhancement Cell
• Karachi University Press

© 2011 University of Karachi Use IE-8 or above

V.C. Office

Inquiry Direct: 99261300-07 Ext: 2219

Fax: 99261340, 99261330 (P.R.O.)

Email: [email protected]

University of the Punjab

• Staff A - Z

• Language en ur
• Quick Links
• Our History Our Pride
• Administration
• Picture Gallery
• Chancellor's Message
• Vice Chancellor's Message
• Departments
• Independent Centre
• All Programs
• Scholarships
• HEC Approved Supervisors
• Student Information
• Annual System
• Campus Life
• Apply Online
• Available Jobs
• Online Databases
• Publications
• Doctoral Programme Coordination Committee
• Video conferencing
• Research websites and free resources
• Conferences
• Apply Online (On-Campus Programs)
• Regulations
• Language Proficiency
• Merit Calculator
• Online Form Submission (Private / Regular & Late College (Affiliated Colleges)
• Date Sheets
• Examination News
• Download Roll No. Slip
• Statistical Analysis / Gazettes

Doctor of Philosophy in Education | IED, Pakistan | The Aga Khan University   //

• Our Leadership
• Our Faculty
• Areas of Focus
• Network of Professionals
• In the Media
• Work for Us
• Giving Opportunities
• Bachelor of Education
• MPhil in Education
• PhD in Education
• Financial Assistance
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Continuing Professional Education
• Publications
• Teaching License Policy
• Kazim Bacchus Research Seminars
• Pandemic Perspectives
• AKU-IED Libraries
• Development Projects
• ​Professional Development Centre, Karachi
• ​Professional Development Centre, North
• ​Professional Development Centre, Chitral
• Aanchal ECD Podcast
• AKU-IED Blogs
• Bite-sized Maths
• Climate Change & Environmental Sustainability
• Conversations with the Dean
• Doctoral Lecture Series
• Public Lecture Series
• Education in COVID-19

​​​PhD in Education​

The acute educational problems facing Pakistan and other developing countries need researchers who can ask critical questions, design innovative methods of inquiry and generate usable knowledge for scholars, education practitioners and policymakers. Our PhD in Education is designed for professionals who aspire to play such a role in improving the provision and quality of education.

The programme deepens students' understanding of educational problems and research needs in the developing world preparing them for leadership roles​. It enables students to conduct research to inform educational policies and practices in the developing world.

Learn more about Financial Assistance at AKU! ​

​Life beyond AKU-IED​​

Here's what our alumni have to say about their experience of being developed as teachers, researchers and leaders in the area of education .

"Along with academic guidance and support, what I found most empowering was that I grew and transformed professionally despite my personal challenges. The high quality, equitable and humane learning environment created by the leadership and faculty is what makes the IED a unique place for study."​

Dr Nasima Zainulabidin, Class of '18​ ​

"The PhD experience at IED immensely strengthened my profile as a researcher. Building on this experience, I have worked as a lead researcher and a consultant for different institutions in Afghanistan. Currently, I am an Assistant Professor at Kardan University, Kabul."

Hajee Parveen Roy, Class of ‘12​

Hajee parveen roy, class of ‘12.

"Following his PhD at IED,  Dr Haji Karim stepped into higher education to teach as an Assistant Professor at the University of Baltistan."

Dr Haji Karim​​ Khan, Class of '09

Read more ​

 Haji Karim shares his experience as ​a doctoral student and ​his journey since graduating from AKU-IED. ​​​

Dr Haji Karim​​ Khan, Class of '09​

​​ Read mo​re ​

Find out ​about eligibility criteria, English language requirements, fee structure details, scholarships and all forms of financial assistance available.​

• 0311-1222-685
• [email protected]
• Online Admission
• PhD International Relations
• Faculty of Social Sciences & Humanities
• International Relations

• Eligibility Criteria
• Scheme of Studies
• Fee Structure

Eligibility Criteria:

Semester no 1, semester no 2, semester no 3, semester no 4, semester no 5, semester no 6, features of the program, best teachers, low cost services, related programs.

• BS International Relations
• M.Phil International Relations

Latest News

Admissions Open Spring 2024

MUL Newsletter

Faculty Training Workshop

Minhaj University Lahore

Life at MUL

Students live with standards.

Fee & Scholarship

Facilities at MUL

Online Ph.D. Programs

Online Ph.D. Programs:

Ph.D. is a doctorate that comes after 18 years of education. A student gets eligible for admission after M.Phil. or MS degree programs. It is the last degree of one’s educational career. Students can, either way, get more education and do other courses and diplomas. Ph.D. degree holders get the title of a doctor.

Students Many renowned educational institutes provide online education facility for Ph.D. students. They also have scholarships for brilliant students. Various colleges placed abroad, enroll students in this degree program. Also, they provide scholarships to them based on their marks.

Ph.D. degree programs are harder but most worthy to achieve. Everyone desires to get this degree. People who have good marks in previous degrees, get admission in Ph.D. Students work harder to reach this level.

Either it is obtained online or regular, students are privileged to get this degree. Their respect, their place in the society has a unique place. They stand out among others. Their way of speaking and living life is different and full of wisdom.

Best Online Ph.D. Programs in Pakistan 2021:

There are plenty of universities that offer Ph.D. programs. Many have developed their educational levels to provide all types of education. Students choose a Ph.D. program that is relevant to their previous study. For example; many students who have done MS/M.Phil. in psychology.

They take admission in the same program for Ph.D. as well. Students must pursue their education in a similar course program. There are various Ph.D. Options for students. It typically requires 2 to 3 years in completion.

Students can do a Ph.D. in Arts, Business Administration, Law, Fine Arts, Engineering, Psychology, Education, Philosophy, Persian, Urdu Literature, English Literature, Medicine, Social Sciences, Chemistry, Economics, and many more.

Can You get a Ph.D. Degree Online in Pakistan?

Getting a Online Ph.D. Programs is easy in Pakistan. There is no such hard and fast restriction for students to get education in Pakistan. Students can freely get an education and get progression. It is the best way to develop and bring improvement in society. A person gets to develop his/her personality as well.

Online degrees are very much admired and getting common. Distance learning has eased one’s life and people get to multitask while getting an education. People are taking great benefits from this facility.

Is Getting a Ph.D. degree Online Worth it?

Yes! without any doubt, a Ph.D. degree online is also the best way to get educated. Its value and worth remain the same. It does not matter that person has studied regularly or online. They get to have some respect and privilege in society.

All Ph.D. students get jobs right after their education is completed. During the online degree programs, students do jobs and get better salaries. They afford their education based on their skills. They keep earning while studying.

What is the Easiest Ph.D. to get Online?

Arts degrees have been considered to be the easiest degrees so far. Getting a Ph.D. degree in any subject of your interest will make it easier for you. Students can also choose less time-consuming degrees. A few of them are Online Ph.D. programs in Persian, Urdu Literature, Fine Arts, Philosophy, and many others.

Anything done with great devotion and interest is easier. People must pursue their education in a fun way. They will get better marks and results.

Accredited Online Ph.D. Programs in Pakistan 2021:

All Ph.D. programs are accredited and worthy to get. Students struggle hard to reach this level. They put all their efforts and time in studies. Online Ph.D. programs are the best type of education.

Online and regular degree programs are accredited to get. People must attain this degree if they can do so. Online degrees are relatively cheaper and easy to attain.

Online Ph.D. Programs in the UK :

Ph.D. programs are offered all over the world. People get to pay the fee online and take online classes to get this doctorate. Students can get higher marks as well. In this way, they get scholarships and get free online education in UK bases universities.

Free  Ph.D. Programs Online in Lahore :

There is a wide range of scholarship programs that provide free education to students. Lahore based universities and many other institutions offer scholarships. It is given to students who have got the highest marks in the previous degree programs.

A huge number of students get free education every year and get privileged. Many other NGOs and different associations have followed this pattern. They make funded education easier for aspiring students.

1 Year  Ph.D. Programs Online :

Many Ph.D. degrees can be attained in one year. A few of them are Accounting, Business Administration, Education, Finance and many others.

Students can learn the best in one year and get online education without any hassle.

Attaining the degree also depends on how punctually the students complete their credit hours.

Cheapest  Online Ph.D. Programs in the World :

The cost of any degree depends on the university and college. Each university varies in fee structures. Online education is cheaper than the regular one.

Pakistan’s Ph.D. programs are comparatively cost-effective than other countries. Students get scholarships also and different discounts as well.

Fully Funded  Online Ph.D. Programs :

Pakistan and many other countries offer fully funded education. Many associations and other institutes have introduced funds. They provide free education to brilliant students. Pakistan’s government has also provided various free education options for students.

Online Ph.D. Programs Canada :

Education in Canada is the dream of every student. Canadian education is considered to be the best around the world. Students struggle hard and apply for student’s Canadian visa.

The education there is a bit expensive. But they provide the best online and regular courses to students. A student who gets an online Ph.D. degree from a Canadian university is valued the most.

Online Ph.D. Programs in Education :

Getting a Ph.D. degree in Education is comparatively easier. It’s worth equal to other Online Ph.D. degrees. It is a doctorate and provides better opportunities. Doing a Ph.D. is the best type of education indeed.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

British Council Pakistan

Connect: online and distance learning.

The Pak-UK Education Gateway is British Council’s joint programme with the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan (HEC). Launched in 2018, the aim of the programme is to allow the British Council to improve higher education links between Pakistan and the UK in specific areas such as innovative and collaborative research, higher education leadership, quality assurance and standard setting, distance learning, international mobility and transnational education.

The spread of COVID-19 during the early months of 2020 forced all education providers in Pakistan to shift to online means, placing distance learning at the forefront of the Gateway agenda. Currently, the HEC is working on developing a national Open and Distance Learning (ODL) policy for the Pakistani higher education sector which the British Council is supporting through engagement of relevant local and UK expertise.

The higher education institutions (HEIs) that have shifted to distance learning are at various stages of ‘online readiness’ in terms of infrastructure, technology, capacity, experience and content. Although the HEC policy guidance issued to them addresses many quality related aspects, there is still a need for a more comprehensive policy on open and distance learning for Pakistan, covering issues of reach, inclusivity, quality and access.

To this end, British Council and HEC are working together to help develop a practical and workable ODL policy, which aims to reach around 2 million students across Pakistan. Through a series of nationwide consultations, British Council has drafted and submitted a report to the HEC, which will serve as a guide for development of the policy.

This policy itself will provide a quality assurance framework to HEIs looking to offer complete academic programs, or a portion of them, using open and distance learning methods.

Azteca Ph.D Courses

Ph.d courses. edulink global admitting you in affordable university azteca university bachelor degree courses, edulink global admit you in good university with minimum and affordable fee. note that pdri is not a university by itself and only facilitate you in admissions at various universities at affordable fee.

Ph.D level courses are the highest degrees and require rigorous study and research. Overseas Professionals, having masters in the respective areas are eligible for such courses.These courses can be awarded by Azteca University of Mexico, Which is World Higher Education Database & UNESCO listed. However as per SOPS of Pakistan Higher Education Commission only the On Campus Study is recognized. Azteca University also offers Dual Degree Courses in Collaboration with Central University of Nicaragua , which is IQAS registered. Those Pakistanis who want such courses only for Pakistan specific purposes are not encouraged to apply. Because some times international accredited qualification may not be acceptable by the higher education commission of Pakistan.

PDRi is working only as facilitation point for Admission & Research to the said University, under the Supervision of Chief Advisor of PDRi, Prof. Dr. Zshah, PhD.

Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) (Copy)

Doctor of philosophy, (phd) in management, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in business administration, doctor of philosophy in international law (phd), doctor of philosophy in law (phd), doctor of education (d.ed.), doctor of philosophy, (phd) in computer sciences, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in public health, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in psychology, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in computer science and engineering, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in information communication technology (ict), doctor of philosophy, (phd) in economics, doctor of philosophy in international relations (phd), doctor of philosophy, (phd) in social science, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in environmental science, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in health sciences, doctor of philosophy, (phd) in alternative & natural medicine.

DRI, is the first ever forum in Pakistan which came into being with the sole aim to focus on the Development Of Professionals- where professionals for us mean a person who is a cobbler or World Class Engineer in a local or multi national firm.

Useful Links

• Professional Diploma Courses
• Online Diploma Courses
• Health & Clinical Courses

Admission Details

• Our Students Review
• Admission Procesures
• Fee Structure Details
• Modes of Education
• Online Registration Form
• Online Verification Guide

Get In Touch

• [email protected] or [email protected]
• +92 347 9812089
• House No. 32 Main Toru Road Near Abdul Wali Khan Garden Campus Mardan

Copyright © 2004-2023 PDRi-Pakistan

How May I Help You?

15 Distance Learning Universities in Pakistani

In this article, I provided the distance learning universities in Pakistani which are also accessible by intentional students and citizens.

You might find it interesting to read my previous articles about well regarded online colleges in Georgia , the UK , and Australia .

Table of Contents

What is Distance Learning

Distance learning is when students learn by staying at home or somewhere else instead of going to a school or college. They don’t have to be in the same place as their teachers. Instead, the school sends them things to help them learn, like videos or other learning stuff, so they can study on their own.

Read Also: Free Online High School Diploma For Adults .

Overview of Distance Learning Universities in Pakistani

1. allama iqbal open university.

Allama Iqbal Open University is a really big university in Asia that teaches people from far away. They want to help anyone in the country learn things, no matter where they live or what time it is.

At this university, you can sign up for different programs and classes that focus on teaching from a distance. They have programs like MA Education, MEd, MPhil, and PhD in Education. They even offer short classes and training for teachers who don’t teach in regular schools. They help their teachers learn how to teach through distance methods too.

Because a lot of people want to learn, the university’s department for Distance, Non-Formal, Continuing Education has made classes for both students who are just starting their education and those who have finished college. These classes use things like videos where you can talk to the teacher, videos you can watch before class, and a special website to help you learn online.

The department also wants to help people from different countries learn, so they’re open to students from all over the world. They’re happy to have their students and hope they do well in their future adventures in learning.

2. Virtual University of Pakistan

The Virtual University of Pakistan is the country’s first online university. It doesn’t have physical classrooms, but instead uses modern technology to teach. The government of Pakistan started it as a public university that doesn’t aim to make money.

This university’s main goal is to provide education to people who are far away. They use computers, the internet, and TV to teach. Even if students are in different places, they can still take classes.

The Virtual University makes sure its students get really good education. They use fancy technology like computers that can talk to help students learn. Students can watch lectures on the university’s website and talk to teachers online.

At the end of each period, students have tests to see how well they’ve learned. These tests can be taken at certain university places. They also do other activities online like assignments and quizzes using the university’s special website.

3. University of the Punjab, Lahore

Panjab University is a college where you can study advanced subjects. It started way back in the 1800s and now it offers courses that are relevant for today’s world. They also have a special school called the University School of Open Learning that began in 1971.

This school was made for people who can’t come to regular classes. They wanted to make sure that education reaches all parts of society. They have a lot of different important courses that can help students get good jobs in big companies.

Really experienced teachers teach at this special school. They make sure learning is good for everyone. Panjab University has classes for different levels like bachelor’s and master’s degrees, and they even have certificate programs.

This university got permission from a group that oversees universities and its distance learning program is also approved. It’s known for giving really good education and it’s recognized for that by a quality assessment group.

Panjab University has many courses like Bachelor of Arts (BA), Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com), Bachelor of Education (B.Ed.), Bachelor of Information Science (B.LI.S.), Certificate Course in Corporate Security, Safety, and Fire Protection, certificate course in Vivekananda, certificate courses in women studies, Master’s of business administration, Masters of Business Administration (MBA), Master of Commerce, PG Diploma in Computer Applications (PGDCA), PG Diploma in Disaster Management and Corporate Security, PG Diploma in Health, Family Welfare, and Population Education, PG Diploma in Human Rights and Duties, PG Diploma in Library Automation and Networking, Pg Diploma in Mass Communication, PG Diploma in Statistics and PG Diploma in Guidance and Counselling.

4. University of Karachi

Karachi University, also known as the University of Karachi or UoK, is a public research university located in Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan. It started in June 1951.

The University of Karachi has a part called the Directorate of Distance Education. They provide online degree programs, which means you can study from a distance. These programs include videos to watch, things to read, and tutorials to help you understand. The way they teach and test you is just like regular classes, but it’s all done online.

To watch the videos, you can use a special website or the directorate’s own website.

The University of Karachi is known for providing good education in Pakistan. They offer different levels of programs like Graduate, Masters, and even PhDs. They also have short courses and diplomas. Recently, they started the Directorate of Distance Education to offer their programs online. They want to use modern ways of teaching and interactive learning to help students learn online.

For people who can’t go to regular classes, The University of Karachi provides degree programs for private students at the graduate level through the Directorate of Distance Education. These programs include B.A and B.Com. Additionally, at the Master’s level, private students can pursue M.A. in various subjects such as Arabic, Economics, General History, International Relations, Islamic History, Islamic Studies, Mathematics, Persian, Philosophy, Political Science, Sindhi, and Urdu, all offered under the Directorate of Distance Education.

5. University of Sargodha

The University of Sargodha (UOS) is a government-run university in Sargodha, Punjab, Pakistan. It has two branches in Mianwali and Bhakkar. The university has eight main subject areas, including Agriculture, Social and Behavioral Sciences, Islamic and Oriental studies, Management and Administrative Sciences, Science, Technology, Healthcare Sciences, Pharmacy, and Engineering. It’s officially approved to give degrees by HEC.

Moreover, the University of Sargodha has partnerships with a few Chinese universities like Lanzhou University and South China Agriculture University.

When the regular on-campus classes were stopped, a lot of students and staff from Sargodha University joined free courses provided by well-known universities’ teachers. To make this easier, the university took part in the ‘Coursera for Campus’ plan. This allowed their students, staff, and faculty to improve their online learning and finish certified courses without paying anything.

Also see: Best online degree programs for working adults .

6. University of Peshawar

The University of Peshawar, established in 1950, is a public university in the city of Peshawar in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

The Distance Education Directorate at the University of Peshawar is dedicated to helping various kinds of people. Its main aim is to offer really good learning experiences using new technologies, and to make sure that a lot of students who have difficulties with time, money, and where they live can also get an education.

The most important thing for the Distance Education Directorate is to always provide the right kind of education to people who are learning from far away. They do this using different ways of giving information, like printed books, audio and video lessons, online materials, teaching through computers, and digital libraries. They also want to help professionals in this field to grow and get better.

7. University of Azad Jammu and Kashmir

The University of Azad Jammu and Kashmir was created in 1980 in Muzaffarabad, Pakistan. It has various departments for subjects like science, arts, engineering, medicine, and health sciences. The university has two locations within the city.

For people who can’t come to campus, the University of Azad Jammu and Kashmir offers ways to learn from a distance. This involves online classes, study materials, and support for those who can’t be at the university in person.

8. Aga Khan University

Aga Khan University was established in 1983 as Pakistan’s first private university. It’s not a business-focused institution and is not under the control of the Pakistani government.

The university has also spread to different countries, like Afghanistan and the United Kingdom. It’s also a major provider of private healthcare in East Africa and Pakistan.

Aga Khan University has different sections including Professional Education, Anesthesiology, Health Sciences, Biological and Biomedical Sciences, Development, Educational Development, Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Medicine, Surgery, and Woman and Child Health.

9. University of Science and Technology, Bannu

USTB is a public university located in the rural area of Bannu district, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. It was started in 2005. The region of Bannu is known for its textile weaving, sugar mills, and making cotton fabric.

The University of Science and Technology Bannu wants to give really good education in different subjects like Life Sciences, Engineering and Technology, Social Sciences, Physical Sciences, Business Studies, and Humanities. Since it began, UST Bannu has been working hard to provide great education, hire qualified teachers, and let its students do research.

Right now, UST Bannu offers programs for bachelor’s, master’s, and doctoral degrees. More students are joining because they’re adding new subjects and teachers. UST works on its own, with a group of experts from education, religious scholars, business experts, and government representatives looking after it.

10. University of Gujrat

The University of Gujrat (UOG) is a public university located in Gujrat, Punjab, Pakistan. It started in 2004.

Gujarat Vidyapith is a university recognized by the UGC. They have bachelor’s programs like BSc, BS, BPES, and BP.Ed., and master’s programs like MA, MEd, M.P.Ed., M.Lib.I.Sc., MSW, MSc, MCA, and MBA. They also offer courses for MPhil, Ph.D., PGD, and certificates, but not through distance learning right now.

Vidyapith Distance Education, which is part of the University of Gujarat, has various postgraduate programs including MPEd, MA, MLibISc, MSW, MCA, MSc, MBA, MPhil, Ph.D., and certificates. To join, students should have completed a relevant Bachelor’s degree.

11. Pakistan Institute of Modern Studies

The Pakistan Institute of Modern Studies is part of the Pakistan Educational Network and was created 24 years ago in 1997 by a skilled group of people in fields like planning for society and development.

The main goal of the institute is to give really good education and training to students. They have centers where they teach about Information Technology, which helps students learn more and contribute to the society’s growth. Also, they are doing new and creative things in the world of technology.

They provide programs in things like Software Engineering, Supply Chain Management, Educational Planning and Management, Dermatology, Chemical Technology, Laboratory Technician, Electrical Technology, Public Health, Criminology, Project Management, Civil Technology, Education (Health and Physical), Mechanical Technology, Finance and Accounting, Telecommunication, Information Technology, and Human Resources Management.

12. COMATAS University Islamabad

COMSATS University Islamabad is one of the best universities in Pakistan and has both real and online campuses. It was started in 1998 as part of a group called COMSATS, which wants to use science and technology to help developing countries. This group has 21 countries in Asia, Africa, and South America. The university used to be called COMSATS Institute of Information Technology (CII), and in 2018, it became an official university.

The online part of COMSATS lets students get a good education and degrees in different subjects, like computer science and information technology, without leaving their homes.

If you go to the online campus of CUI, you can see the different programs they offer. The time it takes to finish a program might be different for each subject or department.

Available Programs: Master’s Programs, Master’s Executive Programs and Bachelor’s Programs

Faculties: Faculty of Management Sciences, Faculty of Information & Technology and Faculty of Sciences.

13. University of Sindh

The University of Sindh was started in 1947 and is a public university in Jamshoro, Sindh. It’s in a city and also has campuses in Mirpur Khas, Badin, and Dadu. The university is allowed by the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan.

The University of Sindh offers different courses and programs that lead to official degrees. These degrees include things like certificates, diplomas, associate degrees, foundation programs, bachelor’s degrees, master’s degrees, and doctorate degrees. These degrees cover many different subjects you can study.

14. Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur

Shah Abdul Latif University is in Khairpur, Pakistan. It’s a public research school named after Shah Abdul Latif Bhittai, who was an important poet and spiritual leader.

The university has different parts, like Arts, Commerce & Business Administration, Law, Science, Student Affairs, Education, and Physical Science. There are 31 groups in these parts that study and research different things in science and arts.

People can learn from Shah Abdul Latif University in Khairpur even if they’re far away. They have classes you can do from home. This is good for people who can’t go to the school because of their job or family.

You can get all the class stuff online, like lessons and tasks. This helps people who want to keep learning but have other things to do too.

15. Islamia University, Bahawalpur

The Islamia University of Bahawalpur (IUB), once known as Jamia Abbasia, is a government-funded school located in Bahawalpur, Punjab, Pakistan. It’s the only university in the area and provides a mix of practical and theoretical education.

There’s a group of skilled teachers in the Faculty of Online and Distance Education. They want to help students learn in a fun way, building knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values. These teachers are really smart, and students can get really good education, training, and research chances that are always good.

Right now, the university has programs where you can learn a bit in person and a bit online. You can study Arts & Languages, Islamic Studies & Social Sciences, and Computer Science.

FAQ’s

Which documents do I need to submit for admission to a university in Pakistan?

You need certain papers to apply. These papers are your Intermediate Secondary School Certificate (ISSC) or Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) and a paper showing your grades. You can also use other official school records. It’s really important that each paper is checked and approved by the Inter Board Committee of Chairmen (IBCC).

Do I need a domicile certificate for university admission in Pakistan?

The domicile certificate is an important paper that proves you live or belong in a certain city for a long time. You can only get this paper from one city. Sometimes, you might need this paper if you want to get a job or go to a university.

What does PRC certificate mean in Pakistan?

Author Profile

Latest entries

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Recent Posts

• 10 Best Online Universities In The World
• 7 Nursing Schools In USA With Scholarships
• Top 8 Film Acting Schools in Los Angeles
• Scholarships For African Students In Germany
• Requirements to Study Medicine in Canada for International Students

• Visitor Information
• Contact Information

Current Students

• CUI Course Catalogue
• Student Handbook
• Academic Calendar
• Important Contacts
• University Email
• HEC Digital Library
• Free Software

Faculty/Staff

Master of science in project management (mspm), program overview.

Projects are ubiquitous and have shaped the face of human civilization since antiquity. The 21st century has been dubbed by some as the "century of projects". As developmental challenges, science and technology and knowledge relentlessly advance, projects - and a profound insight into how to manage them effectively and efficiently - will become all the more relevant with the passage of time. This is especially true for developing countries like Pakistan, where a huge chunk of public-sector resources are spent on projects every year, and the need to properly handle projects given acute and chronic resource constraints is the need of the hour. Projects are the key to Pakistan's economic and social development.

Keeping in mind its mission of imparting quality education in Pakistan, and also because of its obligation as a public-sector university to contribute to the development and prosperity of Pakistan to the maximum extent possible within the framework of its resource limitations, CIIT is successfully executing a two year Master of Science Program in Project Management (MSPM).

Special features and objectives

MSPM will assist in imparting quality formal education towards project management profession in Pakistan. It is a well known fact that vast sums of public resources are wasted due to mismanagement of projects, particularly in the social sector. Project failures - as measured with respect to the non-attainment of its goal, and/or cost or schedule overruns - are common in Pakistan. This problem is attributable in part to the lack of basic project management knowledge of the initiators, planners and implementers of projects. Successful project management requires insight into several knowledge areas, for instance, communication management, risk management, cost and time management etc. Yet comparatively few project managers in Pakistan can claim that they have an adequate insight into all these areas. The dearth of project management education opportunities in Pakistan is the principal cause of this problem.

The Master of Science in Project Management (MSPM) program being offered by the Department of Management Sciences of the COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad campus, is designed as a two year full-time evening program which has the main objective of providing students with a comprehensive, in-depth and practical knowledge of this exciting, challenging and increasingly important subject area of management. As the pioneer in offering formal project management education, CIIT 's MSPM program will help overcome the acute and chronic knowledge deficiency in project management which plagues most private, public and non-governmental organizations operating in Pakistan.

Admission and Eligibility

Session: The programs are offered in Fall (September) and Spring (February) Session

Qualification:

• 16-years degree (or equivalent) in a relevant subject: Business Administration, Computer Science, IT, Economics, Engineering, Natural Sciences, Public Administration and Policy, and Development Studies, with minimum 2.5/4.00 CGPA (or 60% marks in annual system).
• No third division or D grade throughout the academic career.

Test and Score: GAT (General) with 50% marks minimum.

For Scheme of Studies, please visit CIIT Course Catalogue Portal

• Departments
• Online Programs
• Undergraduate Programs
• Graduate Programs
• System Requirements
• CUI Course Catalog

An official website of the United States government

The .gov means it’s official. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

The site is secure. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

• Publications
• Account settings

Preview improvements coming to the PMC website in October 2024. Learn More or Try it out now .

• Advanced Search
• Journal List
• Springer Nature - PMC COVID-19 Collection

Online Teaching Experience during the COVID-19 in Pakistan: Pedagogy–Technology Balance and Student Engagement

Tayyaba abid.

1 Applied and Behavioral Training Institute, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Gulnaz Zahid

2 School of Social Sciences and Humanities, National University of Sciences and Technology. H-12 Campus, Islamabad, Pakistan

Naseem Shahid

Maham bukhari.

3 Centre for Creative Economy, National University of Sciences and Technology. H-12 Campus, Islamabad, Pakistan

Associated Data

Data and analyses reports prepared by researchers are available for review. Thematic maps developed at various stages and reflexive notes can be shared along with the data.

This study aimed to explore the lived experiences of university teachers who participated in online teaching for the first time during the COVID-19 pandemic. A qualitative method of data collection and inductive thematic analysis were used. The data were collected through a semistructured interview from 11 faculty members who teach in various universities in Pakistan. The analysis presented five themes of the online teaching experience: culture and gender-related issues, teaching effectiveness, challenges in online teaching, coping strategies, and faculty’s’ post-COVID-19 perceptions. The findings reflect that the faculty prioritized to focus on immediate online instructional matters in the wake of the pandemic with a lack of emphasis on global practices for online learning. Experienced and young faculty reported disparities in striking a balance between pedagogy and technology. Moreover, despite the limitations, the experience itself prepared the faculty for a blended learning approach and increased their awareness of global and future challenges. The implications were reported based on the findings.

Introduction

A global change in the mode of work was witnessed during the COVID-19 pandemic with an increased reliance on online services along with new norms. This shift to online mode of work decreased the disparity between countries and increased the possibilities of global connectedness and learning. In the developed countries such as Australia, Europe and the USA, digital mode of education has been rehearsed since decades. Despite this trend, some of the higher education teachers perceived this sudden shift as a challenge or threat due to obliviousness with online teaching system (Daumiller et al. 2021 ). Unlike these countries, in developing countries where online learning is a new phenomenon, exploration of teachers’ perception is more pertinent especially during an emergency. This research approach may offer a model of preparation for online teaching in similar situations in other countries.

Pakistan is a developing country where a systematic and nationwide infrastructure for online teaching with facilities such as virtual classrooms is yet to be established. Distance education is primarily conducted through one large government university that has not completely adopted the online mode of teaching. The preparations to operate online programs during an emergency remained meager due to the greater prevalence of the face-to-face mode of education.

In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, Pakistani universities were forced to adopt online learning, and existing courses were modified for an online mode of delivery. This study focuses on Pakistan and, to draw meaningful insights, utilizes a qualitative analysis of the data collected from faculty members working in higher education. The significance of this study lies in providing insight into planning first-time online teaching especially in the developing countries.

The available literature focuses on the impact of the pandemic on the education sector in many parts of the world, especially in developing countries, and their challenges, constraints, and coping mechanisms (Judd et al. 2020 ; and Huber and Helm 2020 ). The studies focus on innovative strategies adopted by educational institutes for distance learning during this crisis (Bao 2020 ; Moorhouse 2020 ). Most of the literature available on online learning, educational challenges, and instructors’ experiences are based on regular situations and contexts wherein educational institutes were not compelled to shift to online learning and teaching (Ali and Ahmad 2011 ; Farid et al. 2015 ). Moreover, most of these studies focus on experiences that are collected from developed countries. Therefore, this paper attempts to shed light on the pedagogical knowledge and experience gained by teachers who are new to online teaching in a developing country like Pakistan during the COVID-19 pandemic (Conrad 2004 ; Rapanta et al. 2020 ).

Literature Review

The review of the literature covers studies that provide information about the response to the pandemic, primarily from China (Anderson 2020 ), comparative analysis from the universities of Hong Kong (Crawford et al. 2020 ), studies on the digital divide of schools in Europe (Verma et al. 2020 ), COVID-19-related studies, and other studies on policy development and curriculum during the pandemic (Sasot et al. 2020 ). In this backdrop, quality research focusing on the experiences of first-time online teachers in higher education is lacking. This section presents a review of the research on the experience and challenges of online pedagogy while providing a rationale for the present study. The interplay between the variables has provided the basis for the exploration of the online pedagogy of novice teachers.

Online Teaching and Learning Environment in Contrast to the Traditional Learning Environment

Online education focuses on providing a stimulating environment that is different from traditional education (Holly et al. 2008 ). Online pedagogical practices involve instant messaging platforms besides utilizing Learning Management Systems (LMS) (Moorhouse 2018 ).

It has unique challenges, such as lack of experience and preparation and institutional as well as technological challenges (Bao 2020 ). When Guskey’s ( 2000 ) perspective is applied, the shift to online learning requires the consideration of learner skills, including self-regulation, IT skills, workload management, blended learning awareness, gender, and age. Learners who are frustrated with technology often abandon the learning process (Hofmann 2014 ). The failure of learners in continuing their online education is linked to lack of family support and extensive workload (Park and Choi 2009 ). The learner satisfaction, among other factors, primarily determines the success of blended or online learning, and dissatisfaction can be a result of the learner’s inability to effectively utilize online modes. The lack of prompt feedback from instructors and poor student–teacher interaction is critical for learning (Islam 2014 ). Therefore, this experience is unlike live interaction, which facilitates and incorporates the exchange of feedback through dialog and positive gestures (Kelley and Gorham 1988 ).

Online Pedagogy and Relevant Domains

Online teaching is reported to increase the levels of work intensity that demands an instructor to have additional multiple roles like that of a facilitator, mentor, and a co-learner (De Gagne and Welters 2009 ). A study indicated that asynchronous communication was found to have links with in-depth communication, helping students move at their own pace and help them fulfill the learning outcomes (Tallent-Runnels et al. 2006 ). Another study has shown that teachers who have a minimum of two years of online teaching experience in nursing academia with a doctoral degree viewed teaching effectiveness, students’ success, quality indicators, and a dynamic role of the instructor as important domains, which led to the concept of dance within the online learning environment. Another concept, the intensive online learning environment , is also differentiated from the online learning environment based on the notion that it has increased dependency upon effective communication, technology, and its use for increased communication, and learning and feedback strategies in which the instructor’s importance is central (Roddy et al. 2017 ). Additionally, a concept known as integration in online teaching has a fundamental value in predicting the quality of learning outcomes as a result of preparation (Cosmas-Quinn 2011 ). Integration refers to the alignment of online tools with the requirements of the course. Notably, little attention has been directed toward the efforts of understanding online pedagogy in an emergency.

Correlates of the Effectiveness of Online Teaching

All the educational institutes were not reported to be technologically equipped for the online mode of teaching, and this led to learning setbacks (Binkley 2021 ). This also indicated the institution’s role in the effective implementation of online teaching model. The instructor’s role in adapting content for online learning is important, and the possibilities of success are lowered when instructors are habituated to face-to-face teaching (Kim et al. 2014 ). Course redesigning is a major challenge in online teaching, and this often becomes an intimidating experience for the untrained (Vitale 2010 ). Despite these challenges, the purpose of online teaching is to fulfill its goals without compromising on the quality of education (Conroy et al. 2020 ).

The socio-economic divide creates another educational challenge because a vast majority of students belong to technologically challenged areas and many of them come from low-income backgrounds which affirms that education is influenced by the digital divide (Strauss 2020 ). The universities have realized that they need to implement changes to support the instructional continuity by aiding online learning (Krishnamurthy 2020 ). Amidst all this, the role of the faculty is instrumental in using this online mode for the attainment of educational outcomes.

Global Research on Online Education During COVID-19

Numerous studies have explored the impacts of COVID-19 on the education sector. A meta-analysis of 20 countries presented diverse results depending on geographical location, technological availability, and adaptability to this challenging situation. The findings indicated that developing countries faced greater challenges majorly due to unfamiliarity with online teaching and the lack of resources. Good practices such as online training for staff and students were reported in Hong Kong (Crawford et al. 2020 ). Peking University proposed instructional strategies to fulfill course objectives, such as making emergency plans to reach students with no or low internet connectivity, dividing the curriculum into smaller units, providing online assistance for workload management, improving student learning abilities outside the class; lastly, merging online and offline self-learning effectively (Bao 2020 ). A survey finding reported that about 172 executives from American universities expressed an increased concern on the mental health of students, faculty, and an accelerated trend of physical health issues of faculty, and a higher rate of students’ attrition linked to online teaching (Krishnamurthy 2020 ).

The findings of a study indicated the importance of social, cognitive, and facilitatory aspects in online teaching and the need to adapt the assessment modes when conducted by teachers with 10 years of online teaching experience (Rapanta et al. 2020 ). Furthermore, considering the novel emergency situation, the necessity of self-regulatory activities such as self-reflection and portfolios was emphasized.

Another study analyzed the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and challenges of online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic (Dhawan 2020 ). In addition to the strengths, such as location, flexibility, the availability of a wide range of content for different audiences, and opportunities to adopt innovative pedagogical approaches, weaknesses such as learners’ capabilities and confidence level, challenges related to digital literacy, unequal distribution of IT infrastructure, digital divide, and quality education were also reported. A study from the USA has also identified the pre-requisites for online teaching of student teachers in an early childhood practicum during the crisis brought about by COVID-19 (Kim 2020 ). Their experiences indicated three phases of online learning, i.e. preparation for teaching online, implementation including communication, teaching, supervision, and reflection on children and distance learning while instructing children.

Research on Online Teaching and Learning in Pakistan During COVID-19

Digital learning in Pakistan faces multi-faceted challenges. The biggest challenge includes internet accessibility, which seems to discriminate against students from marginalized communities and remote areas. Inclusivity is another challenge, as hearing-impaired students have reported difficulties in online learning (Manzoor 2020 ).

In Pakistan, educational institutes commonly use platforms such as Google Meet or Classroom, Learning Management Systems, Zoom, and YouTube as a part of the Distance Mode of Learning (Mukhtar et al. 2020 ). Certain issues, including privacy issues, lack of online technology, financial and technical issues, and most importantly, lack of family support and effective feedback, affect the curriculum implementation (Adnan and Anwar 2020 ; Bao 2020 ).

The Higher Education Commission (HEC), Pakistan formed aCOVID-19 Technology Support Committee to assist universities in creating distance learning guidelines (Mukhtar et al. 2020 ), but a strategic plan is still required.

Recent studies will contribute to enhancing the quality of online teaching. A qualitative study developed themes around the advantages, limitations, and recommendations of online teaching and learning by conducting interviews during the COVID-19 pandemic. The study reported academic inefficiency as a limitation, teaching as a major area of focus, and assessment and quality as recommendations along with other advantages (Mukhtar et al. 2020 ). Similarly, another study showed the lack of preparedness and previous experience and the dissatisfaction of teachers with online learning as opposed to face-to-face teaching in the case of medical education, primarily due to the difficulty of teaching anatomy and clinical skills online (Aziz et al. 2020 ). According to the perspectives lack of face-to-face interaction with the instructor, response time, and the absence of a traditional method of education along with the lack of internet access made online education challenging (Adnan and Anwar 2020 ). This review indicated a dire need to explore the perceptions of the faculty teaching in various higher educational intuitions of Pakistan so that pedagogical methods for online teaching can be proposed for novice faculty and crises and emergencies and the scope of online teaching can be expanded beyond medical education or a single institution.

Online Teaching, Challenges, and Coping

The closing of educational institutes with poor adaptability to a new mode of education and lack of organization is likely to result in considerable stressful challenges. Students are reported to face multiple problems related to stress, depression, anxiety, unsupportive family, and poor connectivity issues. It was reported that 42% of the selected population in West Bengal suffered from stress, depression, and anxiety. The students from low-income backgrounds faced learning setbacks and stress due to financial and technological challenges (Kapasia et al. 2020 ), adding to the responsibility of the teacher to monitor online learning engagement (Manzoor 2020 ).

Additionally, online teaching is mainly instructor-centered, and this is more likely to cause increased psychological stress among the faculty (Murphy et al. 2011 ). The significant role of the teaching faculty and counselors in emotionally supporting students during times of crisis has been reported (James et al. 2011 ) along with the teachers’ impact on the effective learning of students (Snelling and Fingal 2020 ).

Owing to social isolation, students and teachers were reported to be at risk of developing mental health issues, including depression and suicidal behaviors. Stress coping mechanisms may help create a healthy teaching and learning environment. Filipino teachers channeled their anxiety into spending quality time with their family; using social media to interact with friends, office colleagues, and students; reading e-papers; and researching effective distance learning practices (Talidong, 2020 ). The resilience and the use of humor by individuals lowered anxiety, while mental disengagement served as the coping mechanism (Savitsky et al. 2020 ). Other coping strategies may include the improvement of online modes of education, implementation of a uniform policy, and better infrastructure. The creation of alternative approaches for a positive space that supports marginalized sections such as disabled individuals is also important (Kapasia et al. 2020 ; Manzoor 2020 ).

Theoretical Basis of Research

The approaches of instructional design (ID) and learning design (LD) are usually implicit in the process of face-to-face teaching as compared to online teaching where the use is quite explicit (Carr-Chellman 2015 ; Dijkstra et al. 1997 ; Kaburise 2014 ). For online learning design, approaches are different and rely on the techno-pedagogical design with an increased emphasis on learner’s engagement through creative solutions and interaction (Winters and Mor 2008 ) to meet the requirements of the learners (Partlow and Gibbs 2003 ; Parchoma et al. 2019 ). This makes the paradigm of constructivism applicable to online pedagogy (Taber 2011 ; Shah 2019 ). Notably, this online learner engagement is co-constructed within the larger socio-cultural influences and therefore provides a basis for exploration of lived experiences.

This study is qualitative and exploratory. It attempts to analyze the lived experiences of the higher education institutes HEI faculty members in Pakistan who were engaged in online teaching for the first time during the COVID-19 pandemic. The lack of information on this topic guided the utilization of the descriptive phenomenology (Creswell 2007 ). The descriptive phenomenology assisted the participants in articulating their observations, viewpoints, and the “lived experience” that were pertinent to online teaching (Creswell 2007 ; Colaizzi 1978 ).

Participants

Criterion-based sampling was used to select the participants for the study (Anjum et al. 2018 ). Eleven participants (HEI’s faculty) were interviewed for the study. The recruitment of participants continued until no novel themes in the data were identified, i.e. the data reached its point of saturation (Javadi and Zarea 2016 ).

Criteria for Inclusion

The criteria for the inclusion of the participants in the study were limited to university faculty engaging in online teaching for the first time in their teaching career during the COVID-19 pandemic. A minimum teaching experience of one year was considered important so that the participants had experience in face-to-face pedagogy. The participants were recruited through convenient sampling from 5 higher education institutes in Pakistan that fulfilled the aforementioned criteria. Table ​ Table1 1 shows the socio-demographic characteristics of the 11 participants.

Demographics of participants in the Study

Data Collection and Analysis

Interview procedure.

A semistructured interview was used to explore the strengths and challenges of online teaching, the opportunities arising from online teaching, and the threats and risks involved based on the experience of the faculty. The study also examined the prevailing conditions of stress due to the transition to online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Research ethics were ensured. Written informed consent of the participants was taken after explaining the purpose of the study to them via text and e-mails. The confidentiality of the identities of the participants was maintained, and verbal consent was taken before recording. The interviews were conducted and recorded via telephone calls and Zoom. The questions were modified according to the flow of the conversation. The participants responded to questions such as the following:

What is your experience of online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic?

How would you describe the strengths and challenges of online teaching?

Which resources helped you to overcome the challenges?

What opportunity does the transition to online teaching generate?

How have teaching practices evolved with the transition to online teaching?

At the end of each interview, the main points were summarized. Additional comments and feedback were incorporated. Each interview took around 40–60 min. Later, the audio recordings were transcribed, and the participants’ personal or university identity was excluded from the transcription.

To increase the credibility of the data collection process, a pilot interview was conducted (Forero et al. 2018 ). A stage-wise approach was taken for data collection and analysis. In the first stage, the participants were recruited and the mode and time of the interview were decided. In the second phase, the researcher explained the purpose of the interview to establish rapport with the participants. In the third phase, the interview was conducted.

The Procedure of Data Analysis

Braun and Clarke’s ( 2006 ) six-step model of thematic analysis was employed to gain deeper insight into the participants’ experience with the online teaching process. The thematic analysis was initiated shortly after the earlier interviews were conducted. In the first stage, the data were transcribed line by line and read at least twice to promote familiarity with it. Further, a reflective log was maintained. In the second stage, the data were coded using MS Word. Two researchers coded each transcribed interview to increase the credibility of the coding process (investigators triangulation). Further, an expert in the field assessed the coded transcripts (10% of the data) to exterminate researcher reflexivity and biases.

In the third stage, similar codes were grouped, and initial themes and mind maps were created through inductive thematic analysis (Thomas 2006 ). In the fourth stage, the themes formed were checked against the coded extracts to ensure a coherent pattern of themes with identifiable distinctions. A fellow researcher, who was blind of literature, independently developed a thematic map. The thematic map was finalized after extensive discussion (Gani et al. 2020 ).

In the fifth stage, peer debriefing sessions were conducted. In the final stage, the final write-up was completed while considering logical rationalities and the direct quotes from the participants to ensure the credibility of the findings. All these steps ensure the credibility, conformability, dependability, and transferability of the research (Nowell et al. 2017 ).

The findings indicated the impact of the transition to online education in Pakistan during the COVID-19 pandemic. The cultural-contextual and experiential issues provided a unique blend that engaged students at a certain level and in a certain way to execute the business with a short-term approach at the outset, with the long-term impacts deeply ingrained in the faculty’s mindset. Several areas indicate that content development and technology pose a challenge in online pedagogy for novice teachers in unique ways.

Emergent Themes

The inductive analysis of data led to five major emerging themes, including (a) culture and gender-related issues, (b) teaching effectiveness, (c) challenges in online teaching, (d) coping strategies, and (e) faculty’s post-COVID-19 perceptions. Each theme is significant, as it reflects the lived experience of the faculty teaching online during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Theme 1: Culture and Gender-Related Issues

Under this theme, the subthemes that emerge include support , privacy and protection , parents’ exposure and apprehension , and gender roles and expectations .

As a subtheme, support from family, colleagues, and peers was one of the significant social factors contributing to the mitigation of stress arising because of uncertainties during the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, P4 explained that “On WhatsApp group, all the colleagues were supporting…helping with work-related things is essential.” P1, P7, P10, and P11 explained that active peer support was also advised among students for their mental wellbeing. For this purpose, students formed virtual groups and committees for interaction. P3 experienced a sense of teamwork and strong bond among students as they were more connected besides being in isolation.

The participants shared that the privacy and protection of data are beyond the responsibility of the institution. For instance, P2 expressed that: “it is overwhelming to share personal WhatsApp numbers and information about social media accounts…giving access to these mediums intrudes privacy.” As instructional channels are presently being digitized, privacy and protection are one of the leading concerns. P3 shared that using non-educational applications without knowing their privacy settings are dangerous. For instance, P6 reported security concerns: “cybersecurity……the glitches with the use of various apps are annoying…sudden popping up of inappropriate content and ads is problematic.” Participants (P1, P5, P6, and P10) expressed that privacy concerns are not only limited to the sharing of personal information online. In fact, many students find it inconvenient to share videos because the sessions are being recorded, and they keep their audios muted. Students, especially those from underprivileged areas where the families have no concept of online teaching, are reluctant to show their study space at home. Not sharing videos or minimum participation in the discussion makes the class less interactive.

In this context, parents' exposure and apprehension play a pivotal role. About 70% of the participants reported that the parents discussed openly how online teaching will meet the standards of education provided in the university. P3, P7, and P9 reported that parents are apprehensive about the jobs their children will get after distance education. P9 expressed this issue in detail: “the presence of the teacher in the class gives a direction to the students. Parents were satisfied that their children are going to the university, and now, the university is closed, so parents do not know where their children are heading in their practical life, … parents were found to be worried about their children’s jobs after getting this kind of online learning.”

Gender roles and expectations are amplified when teachers work from home. All the female participants reported that household chores and family expectations increased massively during the lockdown. They reported that while working from home, they are supposed to look after their kids and the adults at home during working hours. Other cultural and gendered stereotypes such as household chores being taken care of mostly by female teachers along with their online classes created additional responsibilities during working hours. One of the female participants said that she would “finish household work before online class time…still; children come up for petty things…” The study revealed that male participants did not experience any dual roles or responsibilities while working from home.

Theme 2: Teaching Effectiveness

The participants stated that teaching effectiveness served as the core function of online teaching. Various factors contributed to making online teaching efficient, which is reflected through three subthemes: teacher characteristics (sensitivity, flexibility, and self-efficacy), establishing differentiated instructions , and instructional continuity .

All the participants shared teacher characteristics and reported that teacher sensitivity was integral for the continuation of education and learning after the emergency closing of institutes. The teacher’s sensitivity was exhibited in their understanding that they would need to work beyond the regular hours and typical work patterns. They demonstrated a flexible attitude to learning technology, readiness to adapt to changes, and a feeling of self-efficacy. In terms of flexibility, all the participants reported the convenience of preparing and recording lectures at any time of the day. Participant 1 shared that they “make videos during the free time…more hours to prepare lectures, upload lectures even late at night.” Likewise, participant P6 believed that “online teaching helps in planning and delivering lectures more conveniently.”

Participant 8 emphasized that in addition to flexibility in preparing lectures, the faculty should be able to plan the assessment modes for the courses they teach, which indicates their increased sensitivity to the online mode of assessments. Some participants, especially P9 and P11, expressed “how difficult it is to manage a number of courses…more flexibility is needed in giving deadlines.” According to the participants, although their readiness to learn technology was evident, it depended on their faith in their self-efficacy, which was linked to their previous experience. For example, a participant shared that it took him 10 days to successfully identify and select the appropriate apps and virtual tools for use in online lectures. Later, however, he was confidently able to create links and integrate course pages and materials. Some senior faculty members, such as participant 8, showed their reservations: “not ready…university is not ready… students are also not ready.”

In response to the transition to online teaching due to COVID-19, the data suggested that the faculty successfully customized and differentiated their modes of instructions. For example, P1, P2, P4, and P11 shared that they formed groups of students for their online classes. The purpose was to have an open, interactive, connected, and communicative learning process. Participant 9 also shared her experience with online teaching by using differentiated instruction techniques . She managed to sift through all the study resources based on the academic level of the students. The faculty members who were engaged in teaching different levels of students had a clear general understanding of how to align the instructions and teaching techniques with different needs at different levels. The understanding of the suitability of instructions to the student needs was more evident in the case of faculty members who were teaching only undergraduate courses. For example, this is apparent from the narrative of one of the participants: “teaching to a graduating batch …uploaded a lot of articles to read before coming to the class. However, for a junior class, just uploaded the PowerPoint slide.”

For instructional continuity , the role of both the university and the faculty was reported to be on the same grid. All the participants appreciated the role of the university in the continuation of education even during the global emergency. The general feeling of instructional continuity was satisfactory, and they perceived that the shift to online teaching was helpful for the instructional continuity. For example, P5 explained that the students were “now becoming more independent learners…adequate timeline, guidelines, and planning will yield effective results for the transition to virtual teaching.” Likewise, P3 expressed that: “universities in Pakistan have officially decided to proceed with their learning via online teaching…this transition was successfully addressed with institutional support.” By realizing their responsibility and support, they offered great support for the instructional continuity. Three participants shared that they are primarily responsible for addressing their students’ issues while seeking support from the university and innovatively using all available resources. According to participant 10: “for students having connectivity issues, ‘Taleem Bundle’ was created under departmental supervision. Offline Mode of content delivery was made possible to ensure accessibility for every student.” Similar views were reported by P11 who stated that it was decided that lectures would be recorded and uploaded different platforms, such as YouTube and Zoom. It was further decided that CDs should be made for those who do not have access to these platforms.

Theme 3: Challenges in Online Teaching

Under this theme, the subthemes that emerge are training needs, teaching stress, and student engagement .

All the participants emphasized that the appropriate training needs of the faculty should be met to transfer knowledge efficiently. Few participants perceived accessibility to various resources as a challenge. For instance, P7 reported that the “sharing of psychological tests and its manual is against the rules of the department. There is no access to it online as well. The sharing of similar material is a big challenge, and it causes a great hindrance in completing the course work.” Additionally, P11 highlighted that the concerned universities should formulate policies with the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan to ensure unlimited access to the digital library for both teachers and students. Similarly, the teacher should have access to multiple cost-effective training and teaching tools. This is mandatory for transitioning to online teaching smoothly. Another integral challenge related to this was the limited accessibility of students to online teaching due to weak internet connectivity across the country and the limited availability of gadgets due to affordability. P1, P2, P8, and P9 expressed that lack of resources in the remote areas has created a major hindrance in initiating online education.

An important factor related to the delivery of online lectures is teaching stress . The faculty reported some key factors that contributed to their stress during online teaching, including challenges in managing content, records, and time; engaging students in the learning process; and maintaining work–life balance. For instance, P3 shared that using different apps and devices and combining multiple apps for content preparation and delivery was stressful at the beginning. It was hard for him to make many videos and select the content. Teaching stress was also found to be linked with time management and work–life balance. For instance, P5 clearly expressed that most of the time, his household chores and online classes overlapped, and due to lockdown, it was difficult to manage both simultaneously. Another challenge was the presence of too many students in a class. P4 shared that “it is difficult to schedule an online class with a large number of students…to convey time and date, etc.” P6 shared similar concerns regarding evaluation: “whether the content is being shared with all the students and the lecture is being comprehended by all…it is difficult to follow up with everyone due to a large group.” Only about 20% of the faculty showed serious concern for the uncertainty related to social grooming and acquiring skills for employability. For instance, P4 expressed that through online teaching, some important aspects cannot be met: “inculcating social skills, networking, and relevant employability skills appear to be difficult now…students do not give presentations in online teaching, they do not liaise with different people from the industry, and these important soft skills cannot be taught online.”

Regarding student engagement , the participants shared that the students’ attention decreases with time, making it difficult to get them involved in the lecture. Participant 6 reported that his basic interest remains in adapting and designing his online course to motivate and generate interest among students. Similarly, P11 explained that in online pedagogy, teachers have to ensure that the lessons are more interactive and interesting to the students and convince them to remain glued to the screen. Finally, the participants also highlighted that a lack of prior experience contributed to online teaching stress. Moreover, the faculty was new to this experience. Participants P1, P6, and P7 particularly pointed out that due to little exposure to online lecture delivery, several complexities emerged in terms of designing, structuring, and organizing the course modules, making sessions interactive, and identifying augmented resources and tools. In this regard, previous experiences were perceived to be helpful. Some faculty members, such as P3 and P11, shared that they delivered online lectures on a trial-and-error basis. Internet accessibility issues contributed further to this challenge.

Theme 4: Coping Strategies

The subthemes that emerge under coping strategies include cognitive connections and pedagogical and technological adaptation .

In terms of cognitive connections , instead of developing a major cognitive shift, the ongoing teaching methodology was shifted online. However, the transition to online teaching created some doubts about the shift from the instructional designs practiced in the traditional classroom. P3 explained that the faculty members were mindful of not bringing drastic changes into their teaching practices so that they and their students could cope with the new teaching instructions. In this regard, the comments of P7 and P11 were very convincing. P7 mentioned that “having a cognitive understanding of my students’ learning approach, it was not required of me to go for a major cognitive shift by introducing an entirely different way of teaching…a familiar teaching method with some modification was required to meet the needs for synchronous and asynchronous learning.” Likewise, P11 expressed: “the lecture format and teaching method should be familiar to all students, like what they have already experienced during regular classes in the university.”

Another important aspect of pedagogical and technological adaptation that P7 figured out was the adoption of synchronous and asynchronous modes of instruction. P3 further added that emails and WhatsApp groups were more efficient platforms for the asynchronous mode of instruction: “WhatsApp and emails require less data and are user friendly…can be accessed at any time. This asynchronous mode has helped a lot….”For case studies as course content, P3 and P11 adopted pedagogical methods, such as providing prompts, focused discussions, identifying misunderstandings, reaching consensus in discussions, summarizing the topics, and validating the understanding of the content via immediate and quick assessments and feedbacks. Other participants (for example, P4 and P6) reported the reinforcement of students’ roles through group discussions and by practicing chunks of the flipped classroom by uploading the study materials on LMS in advance for discussion purposes. About 20% of the participants reported that MS Teams assisted them by providing technological support. P10 highlighted the importance of learning different technologies and learned advanced technologies appropriate for his courses. For example, he used YouTube’s open transcript option to read and copy the lecture transcript. Similarly, P11 also reported that he focused on using Zoom classrooms innovatively, such as the locking of the Zoom classroom once the discussion has started, screen sharing, polls, question and answer session, optimized light, reduced sounds, and the display of all the relevant links and materials in the chat section, etc.

Theme 5: Faculty’s Post-COVID-19 Perceptions

The subthemes that emerge in this theme include increased collaboration , enhanced professional development, and the opportunity for blended learning .

The most important aspect was the increased collaboration among faculty members. The faculty reported that online teaching showed an increased collaboration among different schools and universities at both the national and international levels, among researchers, and so on. P3 stated: “online teaching provides potential prospects to connect the online knowledge hub…irrespective of the community’s geographical locations.” Likewise, P5 explained that online teaching facilitates intellectual relationships at the national and international levels, assists teachers in developing new modules based on those already developed by the virtual campuses of other institutions. P11 highlighted the importance of collaboration among community schools and universities. He reported that they developed an entirely new education system and implemented it effectively by collaborating with existing small networks such as jazz smart schools.

The importance of enhanced professional development should also be highlighted. Some participants (P1, P4, P5, P6, and P10) believed the post-COVID-19 educational system has opened avenues for professional development in terms of the enhancement of research skills; the adoption of modern, creative, and innovative pedagogical practices; the use of modern technology and accurate tools; the integration of technology with traditional teaching styles; and the acquiring of skills essential for digital literacy and the online education system. Additionally, P3 explained that they use podcasts, webinars, and lectures from international professionals and the industry. In post-COVID-19 perceptions, the potential for blended learning was clear. As reported by P6, the participants anticipate a rapid growth in blended education as a mode of instruction in higher education. Other participants foresee the transition to online teaching as an opportunity to introduce a blended mode of education in Pakistan. P10 expressed that blended learning is a good option and the physical classroom must be replaced with online classrooms, and a mix of learning tools can be used by keeping online classes and sharing lecture details via emails. Within the model of blended learning, the importance of educational apps such as YouTube to reach students in remote areas was also emphasized (Fig.  1 ).

Thematic map displaying themes and subthemes of first-time online teaching experience of university teachers during COVID-19 pandemic

The findings identified that the psychological, educational, and socio-cultural aspects are related to the realm of the psychological, educational, and socio-cultural aspects in times of global emergency. The data are unique, as it was solicited during the peak of the COVID-19 crisis. The mitigation of the stress caused by COVID-19 was noted at the time of interviews taken (June and July 2020), and this may be one of the reasons that the faculty could talk in detail the about psycho-social and educational experiences of online teaching with a little focus on direct stress caused by COVID-19.

The intricate analysis of the data shows that online teaching effectiveness is linked to the faculty member’s characteristics. They were challenged by the content and technology management, lack of previous online teaching experience, lack of systematic approaches, and cultural and gender-related issues, and consequently, low student engagement was experienced which was of a temporary or a superficial nature.

Adaptation and adjustment have been observed both on part of the teachers and students, especially in cases where the emphasis was laid on online teaching. They provided a perspective that resonates with the differentiated instruction for using online mode for the post-COVID-19 era. During the interviews, the faculty showed motivation for online teaching. They participated fully and this indicates the lack of resistance, openness, and flexibility to adapt to this new model. These generic findings will be discussed in detail along with a comparison with the previous literature.

Teaching Effectiveness

The findings indicate that the faculty have realized their role in online teaching effectiveness. Through their rigorous online teaching experience two months before the interview, they developed stronger self-efficacy and showed readiness to teach online. However, for the senior faculty, pedagogy was more important than utilizing multiple modern technological tools. The faculty with over 10 years of teaching experience focused on translating traditional teaching methods to online teaching so that students do not struggle with major cognitive shifts. They also emphasized the role of the institute or university in making this experience a continuous learning experience for the students. They valued the importance of training for both faculty and students and the differentiated use of technology for senior and junior students.

However, their first-time use of online teaching seems to have had limitations when their perspective of teaching effectiveness was viewed in connection with the previous literature. The focus of the faculty remained upon immediate teaching and learning issues, and they demonstrated a lack of focus on student learning as an outcome of the online teaching, which has been previously investigated in different contexts. Our findings on the factors leading to teaching effectiveness were similar to a previous study that reported the importance of teachers in connecting, leading, and working in congruence with students in online classes, but in our study, the connection was seldom made with a view of student success (Ni 2013 ).

There may be several reasons for this deviation. First, this study was conducted in a real-time situation rather than taking an experimental design on online teaching, which might be more appropriate for investigating the relation of online teaching with student learning outcomes. Second, the faculty’s sensitivity to the situation might be a factor that decreases their focus on outcomes while increasing their focus on the process of learning. Third, their cultural understanding of lack of internet access for all the students as a major challenge might have prevented them from focusing on outcomes more than learning processes. Fourth, the process of learning was only considered to be an indicator of effective learning. However, this can only be considered as speculation. A study on online teaching experience in a non-pandemic situation with faculty having extensive relevant experience may be conducted to validate these findings.

Stress and Coping Methods in Online Teaching

The findings of this study reveal a few sources of stress in online teaching which are common to those already reported in face-to-face teaching. A previous study has identified huge workloads and lack of resources as causes of stress even among the high school teachers (Austin et al. 2005 ). This high workload is indicative of a disruptive work-life balance and issues in time management.

The management of content and records as well as student engagement were also reported as key sources of stress. Several factors are at play here. The first-time online teaching experience itself could be a reason for low student engagement. The cultural context with internet accessibility issues and the lack of previous exposure/experience with the online world of teaching and learning could be another reason for the low student engagement. In addition to the peripheral variables that contribute to the low student engagement, the faculty noticed that the students had low motivation because of a lack of exposure to the self-paced learning model.

A sudden shift from face-to-face teaching to the online mode with a lack of content preparation could have led to a lack of focus on increasing student engagement by taking into consideration the established practices in the online world of teaching and learning. The focus of the entire learning environment to train teachers for increasing student engagement also remained low as the focus seemed to be on creating a system of online teaching and learning. However, the data shows that private universities invested in streamlining online education in an emergency, and this was perceived as systemic support.

Previous studies indicate that there are certain methods of engaging students in an online teaching and learning process which might be learned and adapted for online pedagogy. A study has shown that online undergraduate student engagement can be the result of a peer support community, engaging teachers, and factors such as workload and course design (Farrell and Bruton 2020 ). It is noteworthy that the online engagement experiences in these studies have been recorded for a longer duration, such as a maximum period of around one year. In the Pakistani context, two months of online teaching experience before the conducting of interviews may not be sufficient for the faculty to help them assimilate and contemplate fully on strategies for increasing student engagement in online learning. Similarly, a previous study has also supported the importance of meaningful and multiple ways of interacting with students (Dixson 2010 ), which could not be very well planned because of the unexpected change of teaching mode, lack of previous experience, and internet accessibility issues.

A review of the stress coping techniques on the part of the faculty indicates that they responded by acknowledging the change and the dire need to engage technologically in meaningful ways. They incorporated technology into their teaching, adapted the content, and offered or received support. However, their focus on strategic and research-based plans for enhancing student engagement was meager, and they focused only on resolving immediate sources of stress.

The faculty linked the issues of online teaching with cultural issues and the conversion of all kinds of course content to the online mode, despite the fact the course demanded practical work, e.g., laboratory work, hands on activities, and group activities. Therefore, our findings are close to the previous online teaching experience which is reported to have faced content development issues. Content development can be a great challenge for online teaching but the modification of the existing curriculum to the online mode seems to be challenged by the access to the digital resource, limited accessibility of students, and large classes. Therefore, rather than content development (Kebritchi et al. 2017 ), the ability to reach all the students was perceived as a challenge.

Instead of developing suitable content for the online mode, it was adapted and therefore, the long-term development of content was considered as another challenge. It is interesting to note that the development of the skills for employability and the labor market, rather than student learning outcomes, were perceived as challenging by the teachers. Their focus remained on skill development which indicates their long-term perspective.

Additionally, content accessibility was influenced by systemic issues. The sharing of materials such as manuals and tests was not possible either due to organizational permissions required or the extensive procedure of issuing such tests, and it was possible only in the face-to-face mode. The teachers were found to be unable to resolve this matter on their own. Therefore, it can be inferred from the data that all subjects and all kinds of content cannot be satisfactorily adapted for the online mode. This is also in line with the previous study that revealed the importance of socio-cultural methods for the creation of a culture that facilitates understanding and sharing (Hunt and Tickner 2015 ). Our findings also corroborate the previous study that emphasized culturally sensitive enhanced communication and increased efforts to accommodate cultural differences (Parrish and Linder-VanBerschot 2010 ), which might be observed less in a context where online teaching was implemented for the first time and at a large scale.

Faculty’s’ Post-COVID-19 Perceptions

The faculty showed their eagerness to quickly adapt to the online mode of teaching. Moreover, they realized the global demands of the era. Their adaptability, flexibility, and sensitivity to the importance of the online mode of teaching for the future were evident through their perspectives on the importance of blended mode of teaching in the post-COVID-19 era. The faculty showed willingness to adopt an online mode of teaching and learning despite the huge workloads and restricted resources as source of stress. These findings are unique in a context where online teaching was not a trend before the pandemic, and despite psychological, educational, and cultural challenges, teachers were prepared to utilize this mode in the future strategically. During these earlier stages of such conceptions, training opportunities for online teaching were perceived to be a factor that is crucial for the success of this endeavor.

A Comparison to COVID-19 Literature

The findings of this study go beyond the previous research on first-time online personal teaching experience (Conrad 2004 ; Qamar 2020 ) by bringing developing online teaching pedagogy for a faculty that is new to this technology by connecting variables such as content adaptation/development, student engagement, cultural issues, and the interplay of these within the socio-cultural context.

General Observations

It was observed that senior teachers focused more on content adaptation while younger teachers focused heavily on the adaptation of technology. For female teachers, the work-life balance was a greater challenge when compared to their male counterparts. This might be due to the multiple demanding roles of female teachers and a greater number of household responsibilities when they work from home. The trial-and-error method of teaching and the online teaching experience itself made the faculty aware of the importance of online teaching, associated challenges, and the role of larger socio-cultural variables that carry a heavy influence.

Conclusions and Implications

There is a congruence between the psycho-educational and contextual issues faced by the Pakistani faculty engaged in online teaching. The findings support the Community of Inquiry Model of online education theories, which bring the learning experience to the center of social presence, cognitive presence, and teaching presence—an awareness necessary for effective teaching (Picciano 2017 ). Additionally, a unique experience was construed under the given circumstances. However, the faculty found the experience to be deeply challenging in areas such as developing content technology, maintaining the pedagogy balance, and engaging students. The results explicitly demonstrate the relation between teaching experience and the perceptions of online pedagogy. The first-time experience of online teaching in a crisis has obvious limitations in reaching its true pedagogical spirits, where the theoretical notions of dance in online teaching , online intensive environment , and integration could not be achieved to engage students meaningfully in the learning process.

The findings provide a direction toward further exploration of online teaching pedagogy to enhance students’ engagement, academic effectiveness, and personal development with the enhanced data. Despite the limited sample and data collected only with qualitative approach in a minimal time frame during the first wave of pandemic; the findings may contribute to the enhancement of online teaching theories of effectiveness during catastrophe and may also support the design of training modules for faculty who would undertake online teaching initiatives in emergencies. Researching on first online teaching experiences by including a larger and more diverse sample may help in developing sound models of work ready to tackle emergencies. A policy on online teaching methods to enhance student engagement can also be drafted at the HEI level to support a smooth transition.

Author Contributions

All authors made significant contribution to the manuscript, reviewed, and approved before the submission. Final version of paper was reviewed and approved for submission by all the authors.

Funding is not applicable to this study.

Data Availability

Declarations.

There is no conflict of interest for publishing this study.

Consent to participate in this study was taken from the participants before data collection and their consent was also taken for recording the interviews. Their data anonymity was ensured. Their consent for publication was also taken.

Contributor Information

Tayyaba Abid, Email: [email protected] .

Gulnaz Zahid, Email: [email protected] .

Naseem Shahid, Email: moc.liamg@49dihahsmeesan .

Maham Bukhari, Email: moc.liamg@h3sirahkubmaham .

• Adnan, Muhammad, and Kainat, Anwar. 2020. Online learning amid the COVID-19 pandemic: Students’ perspectives. Journal of Pedagogical Sociology and Psychology 2(1):45–51. 10.33902/JPSP.2020261309
• Ali Afzaal, Ahmad Israr. Key Factors for determining student satisfaction in distance learning courses: A study of Allama Iqbal Open University. Contemporary Educational Technology. 2011; 2 (2):118–134. doi: 10.30935/cedtech/6047. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Anderson, Leland. 2020. ‘ Smiles are infectious ’ : What a school principal in China learned from going remote. EdSurge archive. https://www.edsurge.com/news/2020-03-20-smiles-are-infectious-what-a-school-principal-in-china-learned-from-going-remote . Accessed 5 Dec 2020.
• Anjum Gulnaz, Kamal Anila, Bilwani Sania. Antecedents of gender gap in workforce participation: A phenomenology of psychologists and medical doctors in urban Pakistan. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment. 2018; 29 (2):282–299. doi: 10.1080/10911359.2018.1536576. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Austin Vickey, Shah Surya, Muncer Steven. Teacher stress and coping strategies used to reduce stress. Occupational Therapy International. 2005; 12 (2):63–80. doi: 10.1002/oti.16. [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Aziz Anbreen, Aamer Sidra, Khan AsmaMunir, MashaalSabqat MariumSohail, Majeed Farzana. A bumpy road to online teaching: Impact of COVID-19 on medical education. Annals of King Edward Medical University: AKEMU. 2020; 26 :181–186. [ Google Scholar ]
• Bao, Wei. 2020. COVID‐19 and online teaching in higher education: A case study of Peking University. Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies 2 (2):113–115. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/hbe2.191 . [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ]
• Binkley, Collin. 2020. U.S. schools are planning for possible spread of coronavirus. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-us-news-ap-top-news-wa-state-wire-virus-outbreak-40804eed4cae5b12baf8ec41875f4e54 . Accessed 20 May 2021.
• Braun Virginia, Clarke Victoria. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology. 2006; 3 (2):77–101. doi: 10.1191/1478088706qp063oa. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Carr-Chellman Alison A. Instructional design for teachers: Improving classroom practice. 2. New York: Routledge; 2015. [ Google Scholar ]
• Colaizzi Paul F. Psychological research as the phenomenologist views it: Existential-phenomenological alternative for psychology. New York NY: Oxford University Press; 1978. [ Google Scholar ]
• Comas-Quinn Anna. Learning to teach online or learning to become an online teacher: An exploration of teachers’ experience in a blended learning course. ReCALL. 2011; 23 (3):218–232. doi: 10.1017/S0958344011000152. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Conrad, Dianne. 2004. University instructors’ reflections on their first online teaching experiences. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks 8(2):31–44. 10.24059/olj.v8i2.1826.
• Conroy Michelle L, Garcia-Pittman Erica C, Ali Hana, Lehmann Susan W, Yarns Brandon C. The COVID-19 AAGP online trainee curriculum: Development and method of initial evaluation. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry. 2020; 28 (9):1004–1008. doi: 10.1016/j.jagp.2020.06.003. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Crawford, Joseph A., Kerryn A. Butler-Henderson, Rudolph, Jurgen, Bashar H. Malkawi, Mattt, Glowatz, Robert L., Burton, Paola A., Magni, and Sophia, Lam. 2020. COVID-19: 20 countries' higher education intra-period digital pedagogy responses. Journal of Applied Teaching and Learning (JALT) 3 (1):1–20. 10.37074/jalt.2020.3.1.7.
• Creswell, John W. 2007. Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches 2nd ed. Sage publications.
• Daumiller Martin, Rinas Raven, Hein Julia, Janke Stefan, Dickhäuser Oliver, Dresel Markus. Shifting from face-to-face to online teaching during COVID-19: The role of university faculty achievement goals for attitudes towards this sudden change, and their relevance for burnout/engagement and student evaluations of teaching quality. Computers in Human Behavior. 2021; 118 :1–10. doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2020.106677. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• De Gagne, Jennie C. De, and Kelly, Walters. 2009. Online teaching experience: A qualitative metasynthesis (QMS). MERLOT Journal of Online Learning and Teaching 5(4):577–589.
• Dhawan Shivangi. Online learning: A panacea in the time of COVID-19 crisis. Journal of Educational Technology Systems. 2020; 49 (1):5–22. doi: 10.1177/0047239520934018. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Dijkstra Sanne, Schott Franz, Seel Norbert, Tennyson Robert D, Seel Norbert M. Instructional design: International perspectives, theory, research, and models. New York: Routledge; 1997. [ Google Scholar ]
• Dixson, Marcia D. 2010. Creating effective student engagement in online courses: What do students find engaging? Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 10(2):1–13. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ890707.pdf .
• Farid Shahid, Ahmad Rodina, Niaz Iftikhar Azim, Arif Muhammad, Shamshirband Shahaboddin, Khattak Muhammad Daud. Identification and prioritization of critical issues for the promotion of e-learning in Pakistan. Computers in Human Behavior. 2015; 51 :161–171. doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2015.04.037. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Farrell Orna, Brunton James. A balancing act: A window into online student engagement experiences. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education. 2020; 17 (1):1–19. doi: 10.1186/s41239-020-00199-x. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Forero Roberto, Nahidi Shizar, De Costa Josephine, Mohsin Mohammed, Fitzgerald Gerry, Gibson Nick, McCarthy Sally, Aboagye-Sarfo Patrick. Application of four-dimension criteria to assess rigour of qualitative research in emergency medicine. BMC Health Services Research. 2018; 18 (120):1–11. doi: 10.1186/s12913-018-2915-2. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Gani, Nurul Imtiaz Abd, Mohan, Rathakrishnan, and Hariharan N., Krishnasamy. 2020. A pilot test for establishing validity and reliability of qualitative interview in the blended learning English proficiency course. Journal of Critical Reviews 7(5):140–143. 10.31838/jcr.07.05.23.
• Guskey, Thomas R. 2000. Evaluating professional development . Corwin press.
• Hofmann, Jennifer. 2014. Solutions to the top 10 challenges of blended learning. United States: InSync Training, LLC . https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5c2e89bcf407b45dcc793138/t/5c881dedc83025bffb532832/1552424432575/SolutionstotheTop10ChallengesofBlendedLearning+%281%29.pdf . Accessed 22 April 2020.
• Holly Cheryl, Legg Timothy J, Mueller Dale, Adelman Deborah S. Online teaching: Challenges for a new faculty role. Journal of Professional Nursing. 2008; 24 (4):254–258. doi: 10.1016/j.profnurs.2007.07.003. [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Huber Stephan Gerhard, Helm Christoph. COVID-19 and schooling: Evaluation, assessment, and accountability in times of crises—reacting quickly to explore key issues for policy, practice, and research with the school barometer. Educational Assessment, Evaluation and Accountability. 2020; 32 :237–270. doi: 10.1007/s11092-020-09322-y. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Hunt Antony, Tickner Sue. Cultural dimensions of learning in online teacher education courses. Journal of Open, Flexible and Distance Learning. 2015; 19 (2):25–47. [ Google Scholar ]
• Islam A. K. M. Najmul. Sources of satisfaction and dissatisfaction with a learning management system in post-adoption stage: A critical incident technique approach. Computers in Human Behavior. 2014; 30 :249–261. doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2013.09.010. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• James Richard K, Logan Joan, Davis Scott A. Including school resource officers in school-based crisis intervention: Strengthening student support. School Psychology International. 2011; 32 (2):210–224. doi: 10.1177/0143034311400828. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Javadi, Mostafa, and Koroush. Zarea. 2016. Understanding thematic analysis and its pitfall. Journal of Client Care 1(1): 34–40. 10.15412/J.JCC.02010107.
• Judd, Joel, Betty Ann, Rember, Tony, Pellegrini, Brian, Ludlow, and John, Meisner. 2020. This is not teaching: The effects of COVID-19 on teachers. https://www.socialpublishersfoundation.org/knowledge_base/this-is-not-teaching-the-effects-of-covid-19-on-teachers/ . Accessed 30 March 2021.
• Kaburise Phyllis. Using explicit and implicit instruction to develop pragmatic ability in non-urban classrooms in South Africa. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences. 2014; 5 (23):1235–1241. doi: 10.5901/mjss.2014.v5n23p1235. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kapasia Nanigopal, Paul Pintu, Roy Avijit, Saha Jay, Zaveri Ankita, Mallick Rahul, Barman Bikash, Das Prabir, Chouhan Pradip. Impact of lockdown on learning status of undergraduate and postgraduate students during COVID-19 pandemic in West Bengal, Indai. Children and Youth Services Review. 2020 doi: 10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.105194. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kebritchi Mansureh, Lipschuetz Angie, Santiague Lilia. Issues and challenges for teaching successful online courses in higher education: A literature review. Journal of Educational Technology Systems. 2017; 46 (1):4–29. doi: 10.1177/0047239516661713. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kelley Derek H, Gorham Joan. Effects of immediacy on recall of information. Communication Education. 1988; 37 (3):198–207. doi: 10.1080/03634528809378719. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kim Jinyoung. Learning and teaching online during Covid-19: Experiences of student teachers in an early childhood education practicum. International Journal of Early Childhood. 2020; 52 (2):145–158. doi: 10.1007/s13158-020-00272-6. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kim Min Kyu, Kim So Mi, Khera Otto, Getman Joan. The experience of three flipped classrooms in an urban university: An exploration of design principles. The Internet and Higher Education. 2014; 22 :37–50. doi: 10.1016/j.iheduc.2014.04.003. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Krishnamurthy Sandeep. The future of business education: A commentary in the shadow of the covid-19 pandemic. Journal of Business Research. 2020; 117 :1–5. doi: 10.1016/j.jbusres.2020.05.034. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Manzoor, Afaf. 2020 April Wednesday. Online teaching and challenges of COVID-19 for inclusion of PWDs in higher education. Daily times archive. https://dailytimes.com.pk/595888/online-teaching-and-challenges-of-covid-19-for-inclusion-of-pwds-in-higher-education/ . Accessed 30 Nov 2020.
• Moorhouse Benjamin Luke. Adaptations to a face-to-face initial teacher education course ‘forced’ online due the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Education for Training. 2020; 46 (4):609–611. doi: 10.1080/02607476.2020.1755205. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Moorhouse Benjamin Luke. Using Whatsapp to improve out-of-class communication. The Teacher Trainer Journal. 2018; 32 (3):22–23. [ Google Scholar ]
• Mukhtar, Khadijah, Kainat, Javed, Mahwish, Arooj, and Ahsan, Sethi. 2020. Advantages, limitations and recommendations for online learning during COVID-19 pandemic era. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences. 36(COVID19–54): 27–31. 10.12669/pjms.36.COVID19-S4.2785. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ]
• Murphy, Elizabeth, Maria A., Rodríguez-Manzanares, and Micheal, Barbour. 2011. Asynchronous and synchronous online teaching: Perspectives of Canadian high school distance education teachers. British Journal of Educational Technology 42(4): 583–591. 10.1111/j.1467-8535.2010.01112.x.
• Ni, Anna Ya. 2013. Comparing the effectiveness of classroom and online learning: Teaching research methods. Journal of Public Affairs Education 19(2): 199–215.10.1080/15236803.2013.12001730.
• Nowell Lorelli S, Norris Jill M, White Deborah E, Moules Nancy J. Thematic analysis: Striving to meet the trustworthiness criteria. International Journal of Qualitative Methods. 2017; 16 :1–13. doi: 10.1177/1609406917733847. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Parchoma Gale, Koole Marguerite, Morrison Dirk, Nelson Dorothea, Dreaver-Charles Kristine. Designing for learning in the Yellow House: A comparison of instructional and learning design origins and practices. Higher Education Research and Development. 2019; 39 (5):997–1012. doi: 10.1080/07294360.2019.1704693. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Park Ji-Hye, Choi Hee Jun. Factors influencing adult learners' decision to drop out or persist in online learning. Journal of Educational Technology and Society. 2009; 12 (4):207–217. [ Google Scholar ]
• Parrish, Patrick, and Jennifer, Linder-VanBerschot. 2010. Cultural dimensions of learning: Addressing the challenges of multicultural instruction. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning 112(1): 1–19. 10.19173/irrodl.v11i2.809.
• Partlow Karen M, Gibbs William J. Indicators of constructivist principles in internet-based courses. Journal of Computing in Higher Education. 2003; 14 (2):68–97. doi: 10.1007/BF02940939. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Picciano, Anthony G. 2017. Theories and frameworks for online education: seeking an integrated model. Online Learning , 21(3): 166–190. 10.24059/olj.v21i3.1225.
• Qamar, Azher Hameed. 2020. Quarantined-at-home teaching experience: my e-learning plan and implementation. Journal of Teaching and Learning, Special Issue: Digital Learning in Higher Education 14(1): 120–132. 10.22329/jtl.v14i1.6250.
• Rapanta Chrysi, Botturi Luca, Goodyear Peter, Guàrdia Lourdes, Koole Marguerite. Online university teaching during and after the Covid-19 crisis: Refocusing teacher presence and learning activity. Postdigital Science and Education. 2020; 2 :923–945. doi: 10.1007/s42438-020-00155-y. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Roddy Chantal, Amiet Danielle Lalaine, Chung Jennifer, Holt Christopher, Shaw Lauren, McKenzie Stephen, Garivaldis Filia, Lodge Jason M, Mundy Matthew Edward. Applying best practice online learning, teaching, and support to intensive online environments: An integrative review. Frontiers in Education. 2017; 2 (59):1–10. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2017.00059. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Sasot, Christopher F., Christain Jasper, Nicomedes, Rolf Gian, Marcos, Ar-Jay D., Perez, Jonathan B., Aganan, and Mary May M., Fernando. 2020. A discourse analysis on class cancellations during the COVID-19 pandemic. 10.13140/RG.2.2.34571.03364.
• Savitsky Bella, Findling Yifat, Ereli Anat, Hendel Tova. Anxiety and coping strategies among nursing students during the covid-19 pandemic. Nurse Education in Practice. 2020; 46 :1–7. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2020.102809. [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Shah, Rajendra Kumar. 2019. Effective constructivist teaching in the classroom. Shanlax International Journal of Education 7(4):1–13. 10.34293/education.v7i4.600.
• Snelling, Jennifer, and Diana, Fingal. 2020. 10 strategies for online learning during a coronavirus outbreak. International Society for Technology Education. https://www.iste.org/explore/10-strategies-online-learning-during-coronavirus-outbreak . Accessed 30 Nov 2020.
• Strauss, Valerie. 2020 July 25. Why covid-19 will ‘explode’ existing academic achievement gaps. The Washington post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2020/04/17/why-covid-19-will-explode-existing-academic-achievement-gaps/ . Accessed 30 Nov 2020.
• Taber, Keith S. 2011. Constructivism as educational theory: contingency in learning, and optimally guided instruction. In Educational theory , ed. J. Hassaskhah, 39–61. New York: Nova Science Publishers. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/285872531_Constructivism_as_educational_theory_Contingency_in_learning_and_optimally_guided_instruction . Accessed 30 Jul 2020.
• Talidong, Karen Joy B, and Cathy Mae D. Toquero. 2020. Philippine teachers’ practices to deal with anxiety amid COVID-19. Journal of Loss and Trauma 25(6-7): 573-579. 10.1080/15325024.2020.1759225.
• Tallent-Runnels Mary K, Thomas Julie A, Lan William Y, Cooper Sandi, Ahern Terence C, Shaw Shana M, Liu Xiaoming. Teaching courses online: A review of the research. Review of Educational Research. 2006; 76 (1):93–135. doi: 10.3102/00346543076001093. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Thomas David R. A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. American Journal of Evaluation. 2006; 27 (2):237–246. doi: 10.1177/1098214005283748. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Verma Geeta, Campbell Todd, Melville Wayne, Byung-Yeol Park. Science teacher education in the times of the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Science Teacher Education. 2020; 31 (5):1–8. doi: 10.1080/1046560X.2020.1771514. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Vitale Anne T. Faculty development and mentorship using selected online asynchronous teaching strategies. The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing. 2010; 41 (12):549–556. doi: 10.3928/00220124-20100802-02. [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Winters Niall, Mor Yishay. IDR: A participatory methodology for interdisciplinary design in technology enhanced learning. Computers and Education. 2008; 50 (2):579–600. doi: 10.1016/j.compedu.2007.09.015. [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]