art in context logo retina

Identity Art – Expressing Personal Authenticity Through Creativity

Avatar for Jordan Anthony

For centuries, creatives have used art as a tool for self-historicization and self-discovery that sheds light on the subjective experiences of individuals from diverse backgrounds in a way that communicates universal or specific cultural shared experiences. Seeking one’s true identity or finding a methodology to unpack one’s complete identity requires the artist to self-reflect, research, and create knowledge and versions of themselves through art that might seem self-serving at first, but inherently provides insight into the vast identities and human experiences shaped by the societies that we live in. In this article, we will delve into the history and definition of identity art, and even look at a few examples of identity artists who explore related themes in their professional practice. Keep reading to discover the different ways that identity has been explored in art!

Table of Contents

  • 1.1 Defining Identity Art
  • 1.2 Identity Politics in Art
  • 2.1 Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair (1940) by Frida Kahlo
  • 2.2 Dinner Party (1974 – 1979) by Judy Chicago
  • 2.3 Self-Portrait (1977) by Samuel Fosso
  • 2.4 Unveiling (Women of Allah series) (1993) by Shirin Neshat
  • 2.5 One Big Self: Prisoners of Louisiana (1998 – 2002) by Deborah Luster
  • 2.6 Napoleon Leading the Army Over the Alps (2005) by Kehinde Wiley
  • 3.1 What Is Identity Art?
  • 3.2 Which Three Famous Artists Address Identity Politics in Art?
  • 3.3 Why Is Identity Art Significant?

Exploring Identity Through Art Practice

You must have come across an artist who uses themes of identity or identity politics in art. After all, how can one produce an artwork that does not reflect an aspect of one’s identity in any way, shape, or form? Art is a powerful tool that can be used to provide new perspectives about the human condition, with themes like identity and self-discovery being part of the human experience, which is prevalent in art history. Identity has been a consistent topic of interest for creatives since life often presents us with twists and turns that beg for us to self-reflect on the histories that influence, shape, and change us.

Identity in Art

Defining Identity Art

Identity refers to who you are and sometimes encompasses an exploration of uncovering what aspects of the past have shaped your present state of existence. The beautiful part about identity is that it can be melded, broken apart, transformed, and exists as a continuous arrangement of internal and external stimuli that is always in a state of flux, and even resistance. While we cannot place a complete definition on identity, it boils down to who we think we are in the world and what informs our perception of such a conception.

In many ways, identity art is a creative form of actively philosophizing ourselves in the present, to record the versions of ourselves that emerge from the influences and desires of others and us.

Societally, identity is defined by perhaps the name and nationality on our identity or social security cards. Identity is often tied to a broadly recognized physical document and a form of proof or evidence of our existence that seeks validation from the world. Identity is often connected to what we can see, touch, and feel that communicates the unique or relatable parts of ourselves to each other. Fundamentally, identity is also tied to our species as humans, who seek additional forms of individuality for affirmation that our existence matters, such that we can be “identified”.

Identity Politics in Art

In art, the term “identity politics” appeared most prominently in the 1970s and 1980s American art scene and referred to art that addressed topics related to identity and what identity is societally understood as. These included topics of gender, race, and sexuality, which are all crucial aspects of each person’s individuality and identity. However, the term itself was also criticized for being essentialist toward the artist and was seen as a reductive term that tokenized artists as falling under one particular “identity”. An important discussion within the discourse of identity art is its complexity as a social construct and something that has been historically linked to artworks that reflect the experience of hetero-normative, white male gaze-centered expectations within the art world.

Identity Artwork

Another key development in identity art is the decolonization of how artworks produced by historically marginalized groups of artists are treated across galleries and museum spaces, and the importance attributed to identity art. Identity politics in this context refers to a means of cultural production that mirrors and pre-figures crucial conversation in art spaces. The term “identity politics” has been traced back to the 20 th century and describes the politics that revolve around identity, encompassing race, social background, religion, nationality, and other social phenomena that shape identity such as migration, nationalist agendas, or the exclusion of a group of people for example. A few prominent figures who discussed identity politics include the renowned Afro-Caribbean philosopher Franz Fanon and the British writer Mary Wollstonecraft.

Identity in art can thus encompass critical reflections on systems of oppression from the past and the current era, which largely impacts the development of identities, collective or individual, of a particular group of people or culture.

Examples of Identity in Art: Famous Identity Artists

One can easily find many examples of artists and writers incorporating identity and identity politics into their practice, whether the subjects revolve around historical exclusion, occupation, colonialism, the slave trade, or the impact of war. This can also include artists who hail from backgrounds where their culture has been exploited or disproportionately affected due to political actions by governments and disputes over geographic location. This brings us to the well-known statement that “the personal is political” to suggest that the identities of artists mirror the circumstances of their existence and offer insight into the broader socio-political state of the cumulative factors that shape their identity and worldview. Below, we will introduce you to a few identity artists who have shaped the genre of identity art by drawing attention to various important issues.

Famous Identity Artwork

Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair (1940) by Frida Kahlo

Frida Kahlo is an artist who you might remember by her colorful and symbolic self-portraits that explore not only her identity through her experiences with pain, love, and Mexican culture but also her physical body and appearance. Kahlo’s paintings such as Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair feature the artist dressed in an oversized suit with a short hairstyle and pieces of her hair scattered all around the floor. The most striking part about the work is her outward gaze which penetrates the viewer’s own eyes and is as sharp as the scissors in her lap.

Kahlo alters her appearance to take on a more traditionally and societally masculine appearance, which is believed to be a reference to her alter ego, possible bisexuality, or perhaps a personal statement on beauty ideals.

The text at the top of the composition was taken from a Mexican song and states “Look, if I loved you, it was because of your hair. Now that you are without hair, I don’t love you anymore”. Kahlo’s representation of herself is a symbol of her autonomy that followed her divorce from Diego Rivera in 1939. Kahlo’s confrontation with the viewer is a reminder of the violence of separation on an emotional level that has the power to transform one’s physical identity and sense of self. Her personal liberation speaks of strength in the face of pain and even isolation since Kahlo once stated that she painted self-portraits due to her being alone quite often.

Dinner Party (1974 – 1979) by Judy Chicago

Seating 39 individuals, this famous installation by feminist artist Judy Chicago is a classic example of identity art that attempted to revise art history in terms of its representation of women in art, specifically representing some of the world’s most important women. This is one such example where identity, which is tied to gender, has been linked to the success and recognition of women in the art world. While Chicago’s work is recognized as Feminist art , her installation is also regarded as a form of identity art that engages with the politics of representation and exclusion of women.

The Dinner Party set up is also reminiscent of Da Vinci’s Last Supper , which is biblically and largely patriarchal, however, her installation honors the contributions of 999 women, whose names are inscribed on the floor of the installation, on 2,304 triangular tiles.

The installation took Chicago and her team of artists and volunteers around five years to complete and was first displayed in 1979. Today, the piece can be viewed at the Elizabeth A. Sackler Center for Feminist Art in New York’s Brooklyn Museum. Chicago uses her art practice through the mediums of installation, embroidery, and ceramic art to explore women’s history. In the early 1970s, Chicago explored abstract iconographies to unpack her experiences as a woman, which led to her becoming a leading figure in the feminist movement.

Identity Artists

Self-Portrait (1977) by Samuel Fosso

Renowned Cameroonian photographer Samuel Fosso approaches the topic of identity in his photography practice through self-portraiture, as he dons different personas and looks. After fleeing from the hardships inflicted on his people during the Biafran War in 1967, Fosso became a refugee in Bangui at the age of 13, where he managed to open his own photography studio. His first experiments with photography were self-portraiture since he sent photos of himself to his grandmother in Nigeria. Fosso’s self-portraits imitated aspects of West African pop culture, from music to fashion as the young artist adopted multiple looks and characters in his project. His work also tackles self-representation, sexuality, and gender as one also spots his studio lights and performative elements in his 1977 Self-portrait , which is housed at the International Center of Photography in New York.

Fosso’s experimentation with different personas draws attention to the playful and perhaps performative ways that one can go about exploring one’s identity.

As an art practice, this adoption of culture reflects the popular tropes in fashion and music that play huge roles in shaping the identities of many people. The act of photographing and documenting these characters also speaks to the immortalization of identity, reminiscent of traditional portraiture, and the function of portraiture in helping people recognize themselves and others. Images thus communicate personal and perceived identities. Other famous artists who created identity artworks around the same time as Fosso include Cindy Sherman, Rosa Rolanda, George Passmore, and Gilbert Prousch among many more famous artists who work with identity as their medium.

Unveiling (Women of Allah series) (1993) by Shirin Neshat

Touching on subjects such as femininity drawing from her own experience and the shared experiences of Islamic women in Iran, Shirin Neshat is among the most famous contemporary artists whose use of photography captures the identity politics of women in connection to Islamic fundamentalism and Iranian militancy. Her work Unveiling was part of her series titled Women of Allah , which explores the complex politics of Islamic women through sculpture, photography, and film.

Her works also use texts by Furugh Farrukzad, whose expression of female sensuality is known to be the most “radical”.

In a society where most Islamic women face stereotypically informed experiences from the Western gaze, Neshat exposes the critical notion of the veil that poses new questions about the identities of Islamic women, caught between politics and the culture of Islamic tradition that is often stereotyped as repressed. Neshat’s exploration of identity thus speaks to a wide audience of cultural and traditional belonging that shares such experiences of trying to navigate identity and femininity within Islamic culture, religion, and geographic law. While not all countries follow set laws for women to wear their veils and adhere to Islamic customs, many other countries face similar complex questions around the choices that women have to express their femininity and understanding that women in certain societies do maintain their choice to express their femininity in different ways, through the veil and the body.

One Big Self: Prisoners of Louisiana (1998 – 2002) by Deborah Luster

One Big Self: Prisoners of Louisiana is a powerful identity artwork featuring the portraits of inmates from several prisons across Louisiana, as well as images of those in the maximum-security penitentiary at Angola. How is this exploration of identity significant? Created by Deborah Luster in 1998, the project was born from the artist’s experience with losing her mother after she was murdered and the case remained unsolved. As a result, the artist threw herself into examining the impact of crime and violence on society and families, which speaks to larger societal issues across the world since violence manifests in different forms. Luster started her portrait project in Louisiana and Angola, where many people were serving a life sentence.

Luster captured the portraits of those who were faced with little to no choice of being imprisoned in a dehumanizing environment and system, such that their images were the only tokens of personalization.

Many inmates lined up to get their picture taken and some even performed for the artist. Luster photographed 249 inmates and printed the images on aluminum plates to evoke the visuals of the 19 th -century tintype images. Luster’s installation included a black metal cabinet, which functioned as a space for her archive. This archive is now symbolic of the lives that get put on hold within the systems that intend to punish violence and quietly reminds one of the homely items such as the cabinet, which acknowledges the families who are left behind due to crime. Luster’s identity art stems from a very brutal, personal, and psychologically tense place, which makes her project one that must have seemed almost daunting to someone who lost a mother to a violent crime. One can quickly identify the significance of artists partaking in sharing their personal histories since many of the influences that shape our lives can also resonate with the identity politics of others.

Napoleon Leading the Army Over the Alps (2005) by Kehinde Wiley

American contemporary painter Kehinde Wiley is among the most famous artists of our time working with identity through references to traditional paintings and art history. Wiley plays with the heroic rhetoric often depicted in art history through the lens of the white Western gaze, however, his paintings insert people of color in such portraits to provide a re-oriented version of history that sparks conversations on the lack of representation of Black people in art history and its impact on Black identities. In 2018, the artist became the first African-American artist to paint an official presidential portrait in the United States. The portrait depicted former president Barack Obama and was created for the Smithsonian National Portrait Gallery. Wiley then established the Black Rock Senegal artist-in-residence program, which engaged with global artists and invited them to produce works in Dakar, Senegal. Wiley’s works are collected by many and are housed in over 50 museums across the world.

In identity artworks like Napoleon Leading the Army Over the Alps , Wiley asks viewers to confront the art history canon and understand our role in enabling and disabling previous systems of exclusion and underrepresentation.

Through appropriation, Wiley strategically inserts key differences across the historical portrait of Napoleon Bonaparte and replaces his image with the figure of an African-American man whom he approached on the street while finding a model. The painting is also a subversion of the original 1801 painting by Jacques-Louis David , which was originally commissioned by King Charles IV of Spain to commemorate the victory against the Austrians. A few symbolic details one might spot in Wiley’s painting are the gold-encased sword and the royal blue coat, paired with modern attire such as Timberland work boots and the bandana, which is a reference to militarism. Through tiny details in the background such as the mini paintings of sperm, Wiley also draws attention to the very gendered traditions of portraiture in the West and its promotion of hypermasculinity. This also brings up critical questions about the impact of Western art history and its preferences, which ultimately shaped and influenced the identities of many non-Western nations. 

Numerous artists across the globe are working with multiple aspects of identity, human nature, and identity politics in innovative and conceptually profound ways. From culture to race and larger societal systems of oppression, war, and personal struggles, artists always manage to capture the complexities of identity. It is also important to celebrate identity and simultaneously recognize the structures that impact the evolution of ourselves, whether that be politically, socially, or behaviorally. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is identity art.

It is crucial to understand that since identity is not fixed to a particular style or look, the definition of identity art is therefore not set to a specific set of characteristics. However, identity art prioritizes the artist’s own self-exploration through a variety of themes and topics about the human condition, race, sexuality, gender, and identity politics. These can expand into critical themes revolving around world history and the historic displacement of various cultures and groups of people. Identity art emerges from the subjective experience and can offer insight into the artist’s heritage, worldview, and social identity. 

Which Three Famous Artists Address Identity Politics in Art?

Among the numerous famous artists who create identity artworks, the three most famous figures include Adrian Piper (1948 – Present), Coco Fusco (1960 – Present), and Kehinde Wiley (1970 – Present).

Why Is Identity Art Significant?

There are many reasons as to why identity art is important. It offers viewers insight into the personal histories of artists and the factors in their lived realities that influence the development of identity. A major feature of identity art is identity politics since it promotes reflection on the systemic and historical imbalances of the past in terms of representing disadvantaged and marginalized groups of people. Identity art is complex and unique to each artist’s experience, however, when engaged in broader socio-political issues, it can resonate with a wider audience. Themes such as nationality, race, sexuality, gender, political views, living habits, fashion, heritage, and stereotypes all contribute to identity art.

jordan anthony

Jordan Anthony is a film photographer, curator, and arts writer based in Cape Town, South Africa. Anthony schooled in Durban and graduated from the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, with a Bachelor of Art in Fine Arts. During her studies, she explored additional electives in archaeology and psychology, while focusing on themes such as healing, identity, dreams, and intuitive creation in her Contemporary art practice. She has since worked and collaborated with various professionals in the local art industry, including the KZNSA Gallery in Durban (with Strauss & Co.), Turbine Art Fair (via overheard in the gallery), and the Wits Art Museum.

Anthony’s interests include subjects and themes related to philosophy, memory, and esotericism. Her personal photography archive traces her exploration of film through abstract manipulations of color, portraiture, candid photography, and urban landscapes. Her favorite art movements include Surrealism and Fluxus, as well as art produced by ancient civilizations. Anthony’s earliest encounters with art began in childhood with a book on Salvador Dalí and imagery from old recipe books, medical books, and religious literature. She also enjoys the allure of found objects, brown noise, and constellations.

Learn more about Jordan Anthony and the Art in Context Team .

Cite this Article

Jordan, Anthony, “Identity Art – Expressing Personal Authenticity Through Creativity.” Art in Context. January 9, 2024. URL: https://artincontext.org/identity-art/

Anthony, J. (2024, 9 January). Identity Art – Expressing Personal Authenticity Through Creativity. Art in Context. https://artincontext.org/identity-art/

Anthony, Jordan. “Identity Art – Expressing Personal Authenticity Through Creativity.” Art in Context , January 9, 2024. https://artincontext.org/identity-art/ .

Similar Posts

Classical Art – Understanding this Highly Influential Style

Classical Art – Understanding this Highly Influential Style

Lithography – Understanding the Art of Lithography Printmaking

Lithography – Understanding the Art of Lithography Printmaking

Baroque Art – Exploring the Exuberance of Baroque Period Art

Baroque Art – Exploring the Exuberance of Baroque Period Art

Vietnamese Art – Traditional Vietnamese Art Styles

Vietnamese Art – Traditional Vietnamese Art Styles

Pre-Columbian Art – The History of Pre-Columbian Artifacts

Pre-Columbian Art – The History of Pre-Columbian Artifacts

Aboriginal Art – Preserving Indigenous Australian Culture in Art

Aboriginal Art – Preserving Indigenous Australian Culture in Art

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

The Most Famous Artists and Artworks

Discover the most famous artists, paintings, sculptors…in all of history! 

art and identity essay

MOST FAMOUS ARTISTS AND ARTWORKS

Discover the most famous artists, paintings, sculptors!

artincontext art history newsletter mobile

Identity Art & Identity Politics

Identity Art & Identity Politics Collage

Summary of Identity Art & Identity Politics

The twentieth and twenty-first centuries have seen many artists use art as a way to present their authentic life experiences, interrogate social perception of their identity, and critique systemic issues that marginalize them in society. These include women artists, artists of color, LGBTQ+ artists, disabled artists, and indigenous artists. Their art as well as activism have transformed the curatorial practices of the art world and made a profound contribution to the social and political spheres related to the rights of minority groups. While the term "identity politics" gained traction in the United States in the 1970s and 1980s to designate art that deals with issues of identity (especially race, gender, and sexuality), it has fallen out of favor since then, with many critics asserting that it has had a reductive effect, turning artists into tokenized representatives of one particular identity and further contributing to a view of identity as innate and fixed rather than socially constructed. Aware of this potential pitfall, many contemporary artists working with identity issues have instead worked to highlight the complexity of identity as an evolving lens of social analysis.

Key Ideas & Accomplishments

  • There is no one type or style of Identity Art, but the term can be a useful umbrella for understanding artistic practices that prioritize questions of artists' identities and the art world's reception of their works. Many artists have argued that the default expectations of the art market and curatorial establishment are rooted in white, male, and hetero-normative experience. Identity Art can be seen as an attempt to redress this imbalance, and to encourage reflection on operations of art history that have systematically disadvantaged those whose artworks did not conform to these expectations or address similar concerns.
  • Despite an often poorly-framed debate around its importance, art engaging with identity has led to greater awareness and major changes in the way museums, galleries, and critics treat work by historically marginalized groups. Decolonization initiatives, diversity programs, and critically reflexive curation are all legacies of Identity Art and Identity Politics.
  • A risk for artists engaged in Identity Art is the potential to have their work read only in relation to one issue or social struggle, so many artists today deal with issues of identity through the lens of "intersectionality," which views different facets of identity (such as race, sexuality, age, etc.) as intertwined. Relatedly, the concept of "performativity" (the theory of identity as fluid yet enforced by social conditioning) complements this view.
  • Identity Politics is a concept which has far-reaching implications in both the art world and other mediums of cultural production. In the 21st century debates around its influence on the production of film, television, and video games have been robust, and in many cases mirror or pre-figure critical and curatorial controversies in museums, galleries, and the art market.

Key Artists

Judy Chicago Biography, Art & Analysis

Overview of Identity Art & Identity Politics

art and identity essay

African-American artist Kehinde Wiley stages encounters between the white past of art history with his present by inserting a black subject into his re-creations of Western masterpieces. The insertion invites reflection on history, exclusion, and marginalization of non-white peoples. The models for his paintings are usually everyday people he asked to pose for him; he calls it his "street-casting process." Here the neoclassical painter Jacques-Louis David 's painting of a triumphant Napoleon ( Napoleon Crossing the Alps , oil on canvas, 1803) gets a remake with a black man taking place of the Emperor, his camouflage gear, Timberland boots, and bandana wrapped around his head bringing the work to the contemporary.

Artworks and Artists of Identity Art & Identity Politics

Judy Chicago: Dinner Party (1974-79)

Dinner Party

Artist: Judy Chicago

This installation is comprised of a large triangular ceremonial banquet table set with 39 place settings, each of which commemorates a significant woman from history. Each of the three sides (or "wings") of the triangle represent a different period from history. Wing I includes women from Prehistory to the Roman Empire, such as Primordial Goddess, Fertile Goddess, Ishtar, Kali. Wing II includes women from the beginnings of Christianity to the Reformation (for example, Marcella, Saint Bridget, Theodora), and Wing III includes women from the American Revolution to more contemporary feminist thinkers, including Anne Hutchinson, Sacajawea, Caroline Herschel, Mary Wollstonecraft, Sojourner Truth, among others). Each place setting features elaborately embroidered runners, featuring a variety of needlework styles and techniques, gold chalices and flatware, napkin with gold edges, and hand-painted china porcelain plates that contain raised vulva and butterfly forms (each of which was created in a style that represents the individual woman the place setting was made for). Chicago completed this work over the course of five years with the assistance of over a hundred volunteers and artisans (male and female). It was first exhibited in 1979 and is now permanently located at the Elizabeth A. Sackler Center for Feminist Art at the Brooklyn Museum, New York. Chicago's goal with the work was to "end the ongoing cycle of omission in which women were written out of the historical record." She came up with the idea while attending a dinner party in 1974, at which, she recalls, "The men at the table were all professors, and the women all had doctorates but weren't professors. The women had all the talent, and they sat there silent while the men held forth. I started thinking that women have never had a Last Supper, but they have had dinner parties." Women were selected for inclusion based upon the following criteria: making a worthwhile contribution to society, striving to improve the situations of other women, making an impact on women's history, and serving as a role model for a "more egalitarian future". Dinner Party was a watershed moment for the centralization of female stories within an artworld context. It also provoked significant discussion around the correct way to represent women and their experiences. Although not universally praised by feminist critics (due to what some view as its essentialism), the piece asserted powerfully the necessity of engaging with female stories and brought into sharp relief the politics behind their previous exclusion. The work serves as an example of how women/feminist artists attempted to revise the (art) historical canon, calling attention to the historical accomplishments of women as a way to challenge the male-dominated nature of history writing. Such questioning provided a seed for other ways of dismantling assumptions around "talent" and artistic greatness that had been used to hinder the visibility of other minority groups in the art world, such as artists of color. Widely recognized as a classic of Feminist Art , Dinner Party can also be understood as an important precursor to Identity Art.

Ceramic, porcelain, and textile installation - Brooklyn Museum, New York

Pope.L: The Black Factory Archive (2004 - ongoing)

The Black Factory Archive

Artist: Pope.L

A traveling caravan, a community engagement initiative, a catalyst for conversation, Pope.L's The Black Factory Archive invites participation wherever his white truck stops with a deceptively simple proposition: Passers-by are asked to contribute an object that represents "blackness" to them. This process opens up space for reflection about which objects are associated with blackness (and why?) and what kind of history, social construction, and stereotyping are involved in the inscription of identity onto objects. Nearby, a gift shop is set up with everyday consumables and objects such as canned foods, bottled waters, t-shirts, and the ubiquitous yellow rubber duckies labeled The Black Factory. His truck always travels with a group of "staff"/performers, who "operate" the Factory, act out skits, and interact with the public. "The idea," the artist reflected, "is to maybe bring back some sense of a public square kind of atmosphere....You want people to feel that they can enter the discussion. At the same time, I don't want them to get the idea that the discussion is going to be easy." While racial identity is often seen as inherent based on biological markers such as skin color, historians and theorists have shown how the category of "race" itself was a social construct that only emerged from the eighteenth century onward, with the confluence of Enlightenment classification thinking and the white subjugation of peoples racialized as Other and therefore "savage" and inferior. The history - and continuing reverberations--of slavery in America is inextricably tied with this theory of race. Born in 1955, African-American Pope.L makes provocative works drawing on performance, public intervention, and other mediums that confront viewers with America's slavery past and the present experience of blackness today. By asking an open-ended question about identity, the Black Factory Archive demonstrates the multiple viewpoints that can be brought to bear on an identity. It also highlights how, in addition to individual and collective histories, material culture, too, plays a crucial role in the shaping of identity and vice versa.

Performance and moving installation - Museum of Modern Art

James Luna: Artifact Piece (1986)

Artifact Piece

Artist: James Luna

In this performance, Luna lay in an exhibition case in the section on the Kumeyaay Indians in San Diego's Museum of Man wearing only a leather loincloth. Around his body, he placed labels describing the origins of his various scars (for instance, "excessive fighting" and "drinking"), as well as several personal effects, including ritual objects used currently on the La Jolla reservation, where Luna lived. Also included were Rolling Stones and Jimi Hendrix records, shoes, political buttons, college diplomas, and divorce papers. Luna lay in the case for several days during the opening hours of the museum, occasionally surprising visitors by moving or opening his eyes to look at them. Luna (1950-2018) was a Payómkawichum, Ipi, and Mexican-American artist, born in Orange, California, who moved to the La Jolla Indian Reservation in California at the age of 25. The following year, he earned a Bachelor of Fine Arts degree at the University of California, Irvine, and seven years later a Master of Science degree in counselling from San Diego State University. His goal with this work was to bring attention to how cultural institutions tended to romanticize or present indigenous culture as extinct, lost, or pure and untouched by change. As art critic Jean Fisher writes, Luna was thus exposing "the necrophilous codes of the museum," that is, the way that cultural institutions make corpses out of living Indigenous peoples and cultures. Luna remarked: "I had long looked at representation of our peoples in museums and they all dwelled in the past. They were one-sided. We were simply objects among bones, bones among objects, and then signed and sealed with a date." By directly confronting museum-goers with his own living, breathing body, he forced them into a jarring moment in which they had to confront their own ethnographic assumptions and prejudices. He recalled that many of the visitors spoke about him as if he weren't there, even after they realized he was, in fact, alive. The array of ritual and secular objects with which he surrounded himself served to further emphasize the hybrid reality of contemporary indigenous life and culture. He said of the work, "In the United States, we Indians have been forced, by various means, to live up to the ideals of what 'Being an Indian' is to the general public: In art, it means the work 'Looked Indian', and that look was controlled by the market. If the market said that it (my work) did not look 'Indian,' then it did not sell. If it did not sell, then it wasn't Indian. I think somewhere in the mass, many Indian artists forgot who they were by doing work that had nothing to do with their tribe, by doing work that did not tell about their existence in the world today, and by doing work for others and not for themselves." Luna went on to explain that "It is my feeling that artwork in the medias of Performance and Installation offers an opportunity like no other for Indian people to express themselves in traditional art forms of ceremony, dance, oral, traditions and contemporary thought, without compromise. Within these (nontraditional) spaces, one can use a variety of media, such as found/made objects, sounds, video and slides so that there is no limit to how and what is expressed." In this way, he challenged the white gaze that objectifies others, such as Native Americans. As Fisher writes, Luna aimed to "disarm the voyeuristic gaze and deny it its structuring power," by placing himself in a position of power (as he was in control of when and to whom he chose to reveal his 'aliveness,' thereby implicating museum-goers in the performance without their previous knowledge or consent). This strategy has also been undertaken by other indigenous artists and artists of color, most notably Guillermo Gomez-Pena, Coco Fusco, and the performance group La Pocha Nostra.

Performance - San Diego Museum of Man

Candice Breitz: Rainbow Series # 14 (1996)

Rainbow Series # 14

Artist: Candice Breitz

This image uses collage to splice together images taken from postcard photographs produced in South Africa in the 1990s and Western pornography. A bizarre hybrid creature is thus created, comprised of a Black African topless female from the waist up, and a white naked female from the waist down, wearing knee-high red leather boots and thigh-high red fishnet stockings. The white female hand, with red painted fingernails, provocatively reaches around her buttocks to hold open her vagina to the viewer. South African artist Candice Breitz was born in Johannesburg in 1972, and currently lives and works in Berlin, Germany where she also works as a professor at the Braunschweig University of Art. In Rainbow Series , Breitz explored and critiqued the competing cultural representations of, and influences on, post-Apartheid South Africa. In the wake of Apartheid, South Africa sought to re-negotiate its identity as the "Rainbow nation" (a national slogan adopted for a time in the 1990s), that is, a country in which individuals and communities of various ethnic and cultural backgrounds co-existed peacefully. Part of this project involved the production of tourist postcards, many of which presented indigenous-looking Black Africans in rural settings. The images, however, were carefully constructed, and used models rather than "real" people. At the same time, South Africa was beginning to open its doors to foreign media, which led to the importation of a significant amount of Western pornography. Thus, during the 1990s, South Africans were flooded with highly sexualized images that almost exclusively featured white women. Breitz stated that the images in the Rainbow Series "were my response to the contagious post-Apartheid metaphor of a South African 'Rainbow Nation,' a metaphor which tends to elide significant cultural differences amongst South Africans in favour of the construction of a homogeneous and somehow cohesive national subject." The photomontage technique used by Breitz in this series is anything but polished, with her cuts between the images harsh and crude. For Breitz, this method served as a metaphor for the violence that continues to be carried out against women, as well as the ongoing, tumultuous process of identity negotiation in South Africa. As Brietz said, "It probably has something to do with my constant awareness of just how many women are getting cut up out there, literally or otherwise. [...] The Rainbow People are reconstituted as violently sutured exquisite corpses, fragmented and scarred by their multiple identities. They are far from the romanticised hybrid imagined by certain postmodern writers; or the seamless, slick, computer-generated images which some artists produce. Rather, at a time when porn is (at least for the moment) freely available in South Africa for the first time in decades, and when inner Johannesburg maintains the dubious distinction of having one of the highest rape and murder rates in the world, this series is, specifically, a perverse take on the composite subject making up the imaginary tribe which is said to populate the "New" South Africa." This use of photomontage is an example détournement, a Situationist strategy that re-uses preexisting media in a way that is critical of or oppositional to the original. With The Rainbow Series , Breitz calls attention to intersectionality, or the multiple, overlapping, inextricable aspects of identity that complicate one another, such as the way that gender identity is further complicated by racial identity. In a 1996 interview she reflected that "Although we're focusing our conversation on gender here, I think the discussion must be extended to other struggles around identity, for example race or class or ethnicity. A feminism that does not take these struggles into account is not going to have any real power. We all experience multiple forms of identification, and our identity position is never exclusively 'male' or 'female' or 'black' or 'white.'"

Cibachrome print

Mary Duffy: Stories of a Body (1990-2000)

Stories of a Body

Artist: Mary Duffy

This performance begins in a pitch-black room, and as the darkness and silence begin to grow uncomfortable for the audience, Duffy emerges, naked and harshly spot-lit from the front. Audience members are confronted by Duffy's "severely disabled" body, which bears a considerable likeness to the Venus de Milo, raising the ironic observation that one of art history's most iconic representations of feminine beauty is, in fact, armless. Mary Duffy (born 1961) was one of the key figures in the development of Disability Arts in the UK. She is an Irish painter and performance artist who graduated from the National College of Art and Design in 1983 and went on to complete a Master's degree in Equality Studies from University College Dublin. In 2003, she was awarded an Honorary Doctorate of Laws by the National University of Ireland in recognition of her contributions to the international Disability Arts movement. Duffy was born without arms as a result of thalidomide poisoning. Thalidomide was frequently prescribed in the 1950s and early 1960s for the treatment of nausea during pregnancy. It was later discovered that the use of thalidomide during pregnancy frequently resulted in severe birth defects. From a young age, Duffy became adept at using her feet and toes to perform many of the tasks typically performed with hands, including drawing and painting. Duffy recognized that the vast majority of representations of disability had not only been created by non-disabled individuals, but that they also had contributed to widespread and overwhelmingly deleterious attitudes toward understandings of disability. She writes, "In 1980, while at art college, I began to look at, and to question, my own fragile identity as someone who was very definitely different, disabled, and therefore, without any relevant cultural reference points. There were disability reference points all right, but they had been created by non-disabled people and regarded disabled people as tragic, pathetic, or brave. These images were so far removed from my own experience, I had to search for an image of disability I could be proud of, an image that did not reek of emotion or pity, an image that reflected disability as being a part of being human and all the richness and diversity that that entails." Duffy performed this work at numerous venues between 1990-2000. Writing about the motivations and intentions behind Stories of a Body , she states "...in doing this performance, by standing here, naked in front of you, I am trying to hold up a mirror for you, I am making you question the nature of your voyeurism." In this way, Duffy's performance sought to challenge the particular mode of looking, or rather "staring" that historically characterized, and continues to characterize, visual encounters between the able-bodied and the visibly disabled. Duffy thus challenged viewers to recognize identity, disability, and difference as constituted through processes of looking and staring. According to Critical Disability Studies scholar Rosemarie Garland-Thomson, "staring" is an "intense form of looking [that] constitutes disability identity by manifesting the power relations between the subject positions of disabled and able-bodied." Garland-Thomson notes that "Staring at disability choreographs a visual relation between a spectator and a spectacle [...] By intensely telescoping looking toward the physical signifier for disability, staring creates an awkward partnership that estranges and discomforts both viewer and viewed [...] Because staring at disability is considered illicit looking, the disabled body is at once the to-be-looked-at and not-to-be-looked-at, further dramatizing the staring encounter by making viewers furtive and the viewed defensive. Staring thus creates disability as a state of absolute difference rather than simply one more variation in human form."

Performance - International Touring from 1990

Cassils: Becoming an Image (2012)

Becoming an Image

Artist: Cassils

In this performance originally carried out at the ONE National Gay and Lesbian Archives in Los Angeles, a 1500-lb block of clay sat in the center of a pitch-black room. Canadian, gender non-conforming and transmasculine artist Cassils proceeded to physically modify the block using the force of their own body, kicking and punching the clay in order to alter its form for 24 minutes. Photographs of the performance, which went on to be shown in other exhibitions of Cassils' work (alongside the modified blocks of clay), present the artist in the throes of this strenuous activity, grimacing and dripping sweat. Audio of the performance was also recorded and presented at subsequent exhibitions, with the sound of Cassils' physical exertion presented as an integral part of the work. Cassils trained with a professional Muay Thai boxer to prepare for the performance in which they physically attacked the block of clay. Through the intense effort it required to physically re-shape the clay, Cassils offered a commentary on the amount of work it takes to develop and maintain one's body, and simultaneously, one's identity. The violence of their activity also alludes to the violence experienced by trans individuals around the world. Indeed, Cassils understands the modified block of clay as a monument to trans people's perseverance and fortitude. The performance was carefully constructed to withhold full visibility from the viewer. Sporadic camera flashes from collaborator Manuel Vason illuminated Cassils for only brief moments, providing viewers with mere glimpses of the intense performance. This setting may be understood as a metaphor for the difficulty of seeing the work and endurance of trans people for cisgender individuals.

Performance - ONE Archives, LA / International Touring

Beginnings of Identity Art

While many artistic traditions and practices can be understood as an expression of identity, whether individual or collective, Identity Art in the twentieth century had its starting point in the questioning of the art world's gate-keeping that had excluded non-dominant groups from participation. In the 1960s, both second-wave feminism and the civil rights movement exposed how discrimination and prejudices based on gender and race worked in upholding the dominance of white, male, heterosexual artists, curators, and arts patrons. Although operating rather like parallel tracks at first, both movements created ripple effects that would converge in later decades.

Second-Wave of Feminism

The first wave of feminism, in the first half of the twentieth century, focused largely on legal issues such as women's right to vote. Building on this social activism, second-wave feminists in the 1960s and 70s drew attention to the broader relegation of women to the domestic sphere, and the way that Western society perpetuates stereotypes about "essential" female qualities and the "proper" role of women: a patriarchal hierarchy in which women are seen as inferior and subservient to men. Feminist artists during this period also aimed to draw attention to these issues in their work. Some sought to revise the art historical canon, as well as historical reflection more broadly, both of which had tended to exclude the accomplishments of women and focus only on the achievements of great men. Linda Nochlin 's 1971 essay "Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?" was a foundational text in the call to address the imbalance within the art historical canon. Others sought to question stereotypes and the idea of gender essentialism, or the notion that gender (although the theory can also be extended to sexuality, race, ethnicity, etc.) is fixed, static, and unchanging, defined by innate/inherent traits. An essentialist view of gender states that women are inherently bad at math and science, for example, and this view has historically been used as justification for limiting educational and employment opportunities for women in these fields, further perpetuating the stereotype.

In 1975, British film theorist Laura Mulvey published an essay titled "Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema," in which she argued that narrative film (as well as other popular media formats) generally presents women as the object of a male scopophilic gaze, and, moreover, that female viewers participate in narcissistic identification, meaning that they receive pleasure from being objectified in this way. Mulvey's arguments echoed those of English art critic John Berger, who critiqued men's visual dominance in his 1972 TV series Ways of Seeing , stating that "Men act and women appear. Men look at women. Women watch themselves being looked at. This determines not only most relations between men and women but also the relation of women to themselves. " Many female artists around this time sought to challenge this hegemonic norm in their art.

Civil Rights Movement and Push for Racial Equality

Concurrent with the second wave of feminism was the Civil Rights movement, during which African-Americans fought not only to gain equal legal rights, but also to combat racist stereotypes and to define their own identity and culture. This latter aim had its beginning in several arts scenes in the early twentieth century, particularly the New Negro movement and the Harlem Renaissance. By the middle of the century, African-Americans, as well as other racial minority groups (such as Native Americans and Latinx communities) were creating art with the aim of calling attention to ongoing prejudice and injustices against their communities, and with the intent of calling into question the supposed superiority of art made by white artists. Key thinkers who contributed to this critique include Frantz Fanon (a psychiatrist, writer, and philosopher from the French colony of Martinique), who wrote about the experience of being an oppressed black person living in a white-dominated society; Edward Said (a Palestinian-American professor of literature), who developed the field of postcolonial studies and is best known for his book Orientalism (1978) in which he critiqued the Western world's cultural representations of the "Orient" (historically meaning what is now northern Africa and the Middle East); and Homi K. Bhabha (an Indian critical theorist) who further developed Said's theories pertaining to postcolonialism. The Civil Rights movement and critical theories of race, ethnicity, and postcolonialism all have greatly informed artists working on various aspects of identity to the present day.

“Primitivism” at MoMA, “The Decade Show,” and the 1993 Whitney Biennial

In 1984, the Museum of Modern Art in New York hosted an exhibition titled "'Primitivism' in 20th Century Art: Affinity of the Tribal and the Modern," in which masterpieces of modern Western art were shown alongside "artifacts" from non-Western (mainly African and East Asian) cultures. Many critics of the show (and of the concept Primitivist Art) argued that the exhibition presented non-Western works as inferior to those of European and American artists rather than examining critical and historical dialogue between them. In response, curators from The New Museum of Contemporary Art, The Studio Museum in Harlem, and The Museum of Contemporary Hispanic Art, organized an exhibition in 1990, "The Decade Show: Frameworks of Identity in the 1980s", which featured over 200 works by 94 artists from various countries and cultures who wanted to highlight and challenge the systemic exclusion of non-White, non-Western artists in major art institutions. Lisa Phillips, current director of the New Museum, said of "The Decade Show": "It took up homosexuality, gay sensibility, gender issues, and issues of race and identity. These were firsts in the museum world."

"The Decade Show" prompted many other institutions to address their treatment of non-white artists. One of the most significant outcomes of this shift was the organization of the 1993 Biennial exhibition at the Whitney Museum of American Art, which took as its main theme "the construction of identity." Then-director of the Whitney, David Ross, explained that contemporary artists "insist[ed] on reinscribing the personal, political, and social back into the practice and history of art." Ever since, artists like Kehinde Wiley , Renée Green, Byron Kim, Glenn Ligon , Pepón Osorio, and Lorna Simpson have continued to create art that provides a counter-narrative to the whiteness of Western art institutions.

Intersex, Queer, and Trans Rights Movements

Queer theory, first discussed by scholar Teresa de Laurentis in 1991, as well as the gay-, queer-, and transgender-rights movements (which gained momentum throughout the twentieth century), has been accompanied by many artists who have worked to foreground pressing issues within the queer community, such as HIV/AIDS (particularly in the 1980s), as well as ongoing struggles against violence and stigmatization. Here, "queer" is used to reclaim the formerly pejorative term which has been used to designate non-normative (non-heterosexual) sexual identities. This usage derives from the work of de Lauretis, and has been further developed in recent decades by later queer theorists. Overall, queer theorists and artists work to question and critique essentialist notions of sexuality, the widespread view in culture-at-large of sexual identities as fixed and biologically determined, as well as the heteronormative ideals of family life and forms of kinship that are historically and culturally conditioned yet often seen as "natural."

An important theoretical underpinning of queer theory is Judith Butler's concept of performativity. First theorized in 1988 in her work on gender, performativity dictates that gender is tenuously constituted in time through stylized repetition of acts. These acts constitute the illusion of an abiding gendered self, rather than a stable identity from which various acts proceed. Gender is thus distinct from sex, which corresponds to the biological or medical differentiations between men and women (although the instability of this binary sexual division is now also widely acknowledged by medical and scientific professionals). Queer theory has prompted revisionist accounts of art history and re-readings of major artworks through a queer lens. In turn, artworks by queer artists such as Andy Warhol have provided a productive testing ground for new ideas in queer theory, such as in the writing of art historian and queer theorist Douglas Crimp.

Disability Arts

Canadian disability researcher Jihan Abbas writes that, "The emergence of disability culture, and the importance of art forms and representations in this culture, must be seen as a natural extension of the disability rights movement, as the disability arts movement is essentially about the growing political power of disabled people over their images and narratives." Artists working within Disability Arts create and disseminate representations of their lived experiences of disability, challenging the problematic ways in which the vast majority of representations of disability have been constructed in popular culture. An artist or work may be classified as being a part of Disability Arts based on the artists' personal identification, their medical diagnosis, the experiences they encounter in their day-to-day life, the subject matter of their artwork, or any combination of the above. As disabled writer Allan Sutherland notes, "The movement that we describe as 'disability arts' has developed [since the 1980s] as disabled people have rejected negative assumptions about their lives, defined their own identities, expressed pride in a common disabled identity and worked together to create work that reflects the individual and collective experience of being disabled." Many proponents of Disability Arts firmly oppose conflating Disability Arts with art therapy, as they view art therapy as a biomedical tool that focuses on healing and repairing "broken" bodies. In the confusion between the two, the agency, identity, and the aesthetic value of disabled artist's works are diminished.

Identity Art & Identity Politics: Concepts, Styles, and Trends

Identity politics.

It may be useful to differentiate between Identity Art as a broad category of art that explores issues of identity, on the one hand, and Identity Politics, which was a more historically specific term that became common in the art world (and public discourse) in the 1970s-1980s. Identity Politics was used to designate art that addressed race, gender, and sexuality, especially in the US context. Amidst the rise of Reaganism and right-wing politics in the 1980s, Identity Politics became a derogatory term used by critics as a way to dismiss the artistic contributions and boundary-pushing artists of color and queer artists (by framing them as "merely" about identity, and thus not fitting in with the skewed standards of the white-dominated art world). On the other hand, such dismissals furthered the argument of supporters of Identity Politics in showing the headwinds faced by minority artists who wished to make art by drawing on their life experiences.

Since then, there has been more acceptance of identity-focused art, even as "identity" can become both an entry-point and a limiting condition. Curators Anders Kreuger and Nav Haq point out that "Artists are allowed access to the art system on the condition that they have to act, or be framed, as socio-cultural representatives of the place/people they 'are from.'" The rise of Identity Politics in the art world, they argue, resulted in a transition "from marginalization (on the outside) to ghettoization (on the inside)."

Many contemporary artists are fully aware of the pitfalls of engaging with identity. Some would argue, however, that they don't have a choice but to address it: As the contemporary African-American artist Tschabalala Self noted, "All artists create identity-based work, but only some artists are asked about their identity [...] If some artists seem to make work that is ostensibly unconcerned with these realities, it's because they are not made to feel marginalized by them." So long as systemic marginalization and violence against groups based on perceived identity remain, questions of identity will continue to be part of many artists' reality. The terms of the debates may shift, just as our understanding of identity has evolved, but until parity and equal access to opportunity in the art world is truly achieved (not only for artists but also among museum professionals and staff), the critical reckoning of the art world's system of critical and monetary valuation will continue to be urgent for many.

Identity and Politics through Art: Interventions

While identity-related concerns were slow to be taken up by many Western art galleries and museums, a great deal of progress occurred outside the confines of institutions. Artists have often taken their work outside of traditional gallery spaces, or used the space of the gallery itself in ways that "intervene" in their usual function. Artists may create work that is unable to be viewed in a conventional manner, or situate their work within a more politically or socially charged context. They may even intervene in everyday life, inserting their art and politics into normal conversations or social interactions.

Feminist Performance artists, in particular, have been taking to the streets for decades, such as Austrian artist Valie Export , who between 1968-1971 enacted a public performance titled Tap and Touch Cinema in ten European cities. For this performance, the artist wore a miniature "movie theatre" around her naked upper body, covered by a curtain at the front, so that passers-by could not see her, but were invited to reach in and touch. Her aim with this work was to confront the public, in a tactile manner, with a living, breathing female body, attached to a face which responds and looks back, rather than a simple (yet highly constructed) passive visual image on a page or screen, to which they were more accustomed.

art and identity essay

A later example is intersectional feminist group Guerrilla Girls, who have taken to the streets, putting up stickers, posters, and street projects in cities all over the world since 1985. The Guerrilla Girls' street interventions aim to highlight issues of injustice and inequality (both on the basis of gender and race) in the art world. For instance, in 1989, the group rented advertising spaces on buses in New York City, in which they inserted posters they had made calling attention to the fact that at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, "less than 5% of the artists in the Modern Art sections are women, but 85% of the nudes are female."

Indeed, Street Art in its myriad forms has proven to be an ideal medium for artists who seek to address Identity Politics in their work, as it allows for uncensored expression in public locations with large numbers of potential viewers. For instance, Montreal-based MissMe, who works primarily in wheat paste posters, installs street art that challenges outdated patriarchal attitudes and empowers women. In a 2018 street installation, she called into question the male-centred Christian origin story (in which the first women grew from the first man) while simultaneously reminding viewers of the pain and sacrifice demanded of women as bearers of new life, asserting that "I didn't come from your rib, you came from my vagina."

Even when not literally on the street, artists engaged in Identity Art still "intervene" in the expected viewer/artist relationship. Cuban-American artist Ana Mendieta's 1973 multi-media installation and performance Untitled (Rape Scene) , for example, was a feminist piece created to foreground the high incidence of rapes and murders of women that were occurring on the University of Iowa campus while she was in attendance there. Audience members arrived via an elevator to be immediately confronted with the scene within the confines of a regular apartment, forcing them to contemplate a realistic scene of rape outside the distancing and "safe" space of a gallery. It was also possible that members of the campus community who were not aware of the performance could enter and think it the aftermath of a real assault, blurring the line between art and real experience. The work highlighted the urgency of the issue and the reality of being a woman at the time.

Public intervention has proved to be a highly effective strategy for artists of color seeking to create art that reflects the struggles of their communities, particularly in the context of living in predominantly white areas, states, and countries. American artist Adrian Piper , for example, who is African-American but could pass as white due to her light skin tone, carried out a performance in 1989-1990 titled My Calling Card #1 , in which she passed out a small card in various social situations to individuals around her who made racist remarks in her presence. The card informed readers that Piper is in fact black, although they may not have been aware of that, and that the racist comment they had just "made/laughed at/agreed with" was in fact discomforting to her. The performance was one that played out within everyday life, with only the documentation (in the form of the calling cards themselves) available for display as a record of the intervention.

Disabled artists have also made regular interventions into the relationship between art and audience. An important early work of the Disability Arts movement is English artist Tony Heaton's 1989 sculptural intervention titled Wheelchair Entrance . The work was composed of a wooden board labelled "wheelchair entrance" which was hung across a gallery doorway at a height that blocked ambulatory visitors but permitted entrance beneath it to anyone in a wheelchair. The work acted as a simple but effective means by which to make gallery visitors aware of architectural barriers to mobility. Moreover, it encouraged an embodied engagement with disability by forcing ambulatory visitors to confront a moment of physical limitation without attempting to explain or analyze the encounter, simply allowing it to create meaning through the perspective of the body. This piece reflects the social model of disability now prevalent in civic and political discourse - the idea that it is not someone's body which disables them, but the society around them. A person is prevented from entering a building not because they use a wheelchair, for example, but because there is no ramp. Heaton's intervention in the space reflects this, with the space "othering" ambulatory visitors and preventing their easy access.

Identity and Politics through Art: Critique on the Gallery Wall

Issues and politics of identity are not only played out in non-conventional spaces or in ways that are unfamiliar to art audiences. Many artists create work fully able to be displayed and evaluated as more conventional painting, installation, or sculpture, whilst still maintaining a strong political message about identity. This critique from within the gallery system often intersects with Institutional Critique , the questioning of the gallery system itself.

Frida Kahlo's work frequently depicted her experience of disability in her self-portraits (namely, the numerous broken bones and fractures she experienced as a result of a bus accident when she was a teenager, as well as her inability to carry a pregnancy to term, also a result of the accident). Her work highlights the intersectional position of her identity as both a woman and an artist with a disability, foregrounding, when considered in detail, the relative lack of both in museum and gallery collections. Historically, few artists dealing directly with issues of disability in their work are represented in museum collections or the international art market, but Kahlo has achieved a high level of renown, particularly in the twenty-first century.

Other artists have drawn on their sexual identity explicitly in their work, with the rise of the gay rights movement (and related movements, such as the transgender rights movement) after the Stonewall riots in 1969 in particular encouraging LGBTTQQIAAP (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, transsexual, queer, questioning, intersex, asexual, ally, and pansexual, henceforth referred to simply as "queer") artists to create works that take up issues prevalent in their communities, such as HIV/AIDS, violence, abuse, stigma, and acceptance. One notable example - of what is sometimes called Queer Art - is David Wojnarowicz , who dealt with pressing issues within the queer community in his work. Wojnarowicz was a target of the "culture wars" of the 1980s and 1990s in the United States, wherein artists dealing with sensitive (often identity-based) content and imagery in their works were attacked by various organizations (including the American Family Association and the Catholic League) on the basis of creating and disseminating what were claimed to be vulgar, immoral, or gratuitous images that were unworthy of the gallery. Other artists who fell victim to the "culture wars" (by being denied funding, as well as receiving harsh disparagement) include Robert Mapplethorpe , Andres Serrano , Karen Finley, Tim Miller, John Fleck, and Holly Hughes.

Despite this political oppression, Wojnarowicz's work has now achieved significant curatorial interest, culminating in his 2018 retrospective at the Whitney Museum of American Art. Like Kahlo's work, it draws attention explicitly to an injustice on the basis of identity and highlights the absence of explicit acknowledgement of minority positions in curatorial agendas. The success of Identity Art is in part encapsulated by the reassessment and incorporation of ideas previously on the fringes into a mainstream process of art world acknowledgement.

Later Developments - After Identity Art & Identity Politics

Today many contemporary artists use art as a tool in the (re-)negotiation of multiple aspects of identity that operate together - or intersectionally - rather than separately. The term intersectionality was first coined in 1989 by race and gender law scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw, who argued that an individual cannot be defined by a single identity, such as gender, but that different aspects of a person's identity work together to determine their social standing, privileges and/or disadvantages. These include (but are not limited to) gender, race/ethnicity/diaspora, sexuality, and disability, as well as class, body type, and age.

Other scholars have proposed using the term "post-identity (politics)", which is related to the concept of posthumanism. Post-identity thinking has its basis in the theories of Nietzsche, Foucault, and Deleuze and Guattari, and argues for an understanding of identity as a process of becoming, characterized by flux, change, impermanence, incoherence, and unpredictability. Many of today's identity-focused artists are incorporating ideas of post-identity into their works, such as the participants in a 2014 exhibition As We Were Saying: Art and Identity in the Age of "Post" at the EFA Project Space in New York. One sculpture in the show, In Spirit of (a Major in Women's Studies) by A. K. Burns and Katherine Hubbard, consisted of a wastebasket filled with various objects, including a studded leather belt, an electrical power strip, confetti, plastic snakes, and a rose made of feathers. These objects do not easily correspond to any one recognizable "identity," but invite multiple associations, even as they are found, after all, in a wastebasket evoking a sense of irrelevance or a lack of value. The work thus insists upon identity as incoherent and imperceptible rather than fixed and knowable.

With multiple facets of identity explored through art and with many artists moving beyond "identity" as such, Identity Art today may be understood less as a fixed category or style, but as an awareness that many artists bring to their artmaking processes (even so as to critique or complicate it). It can also be a critical and historical lens through which we can approach artworks, including those that were not made with "identity" in mind.

Useful Resources on Identity Art & Identity Politics

  • Through The Flower: My Struggle as A Woman Artist By Judy Chicago
  • Cindy Sherman By Eva Respini and Johanna Burton
  • Meet Cindy Sherman: Artist, Photographer, Chameleon By Sandra Jordan and Jan Greenberg
  • Women Photographers: From Julia Margaret Cameron to Cindy Sherman By Boris Friedewalde
  • Glenn Ligon: Encounters and Collisions By Glenn Ligon, Francesco Manacorda, Alex Farquharson, Gregg Bordowitz
  • Kehinde Wiley: A New Republic By Eugenie Tsai
  • Power of Feminist Art: The American Movement of the 1970s History and Impact By Norma Broude and Mary D. Garrard
  • Art and Feminism Our Pick By Helena Reckitt
  • Disability Aesthetics By Tobin Siebers
  • Re-Presenting Disability: Activism and Agency in the Museum By Richard Sandell, Jocelyn Dodd, and Rosemarie Garland-Thomson
  • Cindy Sherman: The Complete Untitled Film Stills Our Pick By Peter Galassi
  • Race-ing Art History: Critical Readings in Race and Art History Our Pick By Kymberly N. Pinder
  • How To See A Work of Art in Total Darkness By Darby English
  • Art and Queer Culture By Catherine Lord and Richard Meyer
  • Trap Door: Trans Cultural Production and the Politics of Visibility By Reina Gossett, Eric A. Stanley, and Johanna Burton
  • Judy Chicago, the Godmother Our Pick By Sasha Weiss / The New York Times Style Magazine / Feb. 7, 2018
  • The Topic Is Race; the Art Is Fearless Our Pick By Holland Cotter / The New York Times / March 30, 2008
  • How Identity Politics Conquered the Art World: An Oral History Our Pick By Jerry Saltz and Rachel Corbett / Vulture / April 18, 2016
  • At the Whitney, A Biennial with a Social Conscience By Roberta Smith / The New York Times / March 5, 1993
  • Don't You Know Who I Am? Art After Identity Politics Our Pick Exhibition catalogue / Museum of Contemporary Art, Antwerp / June 13, 2014
  • Becoming an Image: Heather Cassils

Similar Art

Beauford Delaney: Can Fire in the Park (1946)

Can Fire in the Park (1946)

Yoko Ono: Cut Piece (1964)

Cut Piece (1964)

Robert Mapplethorpe: Jim and Tom, Sausalito (1977)

Jim and Tom, Sausalito (1977)

Related artists, related movements & topics.

Harlem Renaissance Art & Analysis

Content compiled and written by Alexandra Duncan

Edited and revised, with Summary and Accomplishments added by Paisid Aramphongphan

Logo

Brill | Nijhoff

Brill | Wageningen Academic

Brill Germany / Austria

Böhlau

Brill | Fink

Brill | mentis

Brill | Schöningh

Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht

V&R unipress

Open Access

Open Access for Authors

Open Access and Research Funding

Open Access for Librarians

Open Access for Academic Societies

Discover Brill’s Open Access Content

Organization

Stay updated

Corporate Social Responsiblity

Investor Relations

Policies, rights & permissions

Review a Brill Book

Author Portal

How to publish with Brill: Files & Guides

Fonts, Scripts and Unicode

Publication Ethics & COPE Compliance

Data Sharing Policy

Brill MyBook

Ordering from Brill

Author Newsletter

Piracy Reporting Form

Sales Managers and Sales Contacts

Ordering From Brill

Titles No Longer Published by Brill

Catalogs, Flyers and Price Lists

E-Book Collections Title Lists and MARC Records

How to Manage your Online Holdings

LibLynx Access Management

Discovery Services

KBART Files

MARC Records

Online User and Order Help

Rights and Permissions

Latest Key Figures

Latest Financial Press Releases and Reports

Annual General Meeting of Shareholders

Share Information

Specialty Products

Press and Reviews

Cover Art and Identity

Art and Identity

Essays on the aesthetic creation of mind, series:  consciousness, literature and the arts , volume: 32.

Prices from (excl. shipping):

  • Paperback: €70.00
  • E-Book (PDF): €70.00
  • View PDF Flyer

Biographical Note

Review quotes, table of contents, share link with colleague or librarian, product details.

  • Literature, Arts & Science
  • Aesthetics & Cultural Theory
  • Cultural Studies

Collection Information

  • Literature and Cultural Studies E-Books Online, Collection 2013

Related Content

Cover J.G. Ballard

Reference Works

Primary source collections

COVID-19 Collection

How to publish with Brill

Open Access Content

Contact & Info

Sales contacts

Publishing contacts

Stay Updated

Newsletters

Social Media Overview

Terms and Conditions  

Privacy Statement  

Cookie Settings  

Accessibility

Legal Notice

Terms and Conditions   |   Privacy Statement   |  Cookie Settings   |   Accessibility   |  Legal Notice   |  Copyright © 2016-2024

Copyright © 2016-2024

  • [66.249.64.20|185.39.149.46]
  • 185.39.149.46

Character limit 500 /500

Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

  • We're Hiring!
  • Help Center

paper cover thumbnail

Introduction - Art and Identity: Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

Profile image of Tone Roald

2013, Brill

Related Papers

PORTO ARTE: Revista de Artes Visuais

Luciano Simão

art and identity essay

Rob Luzecky

Alessandro Bertinetto , Jerrold Levinson , Gerard Vilar , Matilde Carrasco Barranco

The articles in this issue of CoSMo explore possible ways to understand the specific qualities of aesthetics, its areas of application, its relationship with the practices of artistic production, aesthetic enjoyment, and critical interpretation. They also discuss the complex relationship between the reflection on aesthetic experience and its quality and, on the one hand, the problems raised by contemporary art (which often seems to require a kind of non-aesthetic experience of understanding and appreciation) and, secondly, the emergence of new potential areas of aesthetic enjoyment (like cooking and food appreciation).

The Journal of Aesthetic Education

Richard Shusterman

Paul Crowther

This discussion is the basis of Chapter 1 of my book The Aesthetics of Self-Becoming: How Art Forms Empower, Routledge, 2019. The book develops all the ideas presented below, in much greater detail. If aesthetics is to re-establish its philosophical importance a change is needed. Instead of engaging with art mainly through the crude notion of expressive qualities, or making it speak through the voice of ‘authorities’, we need a Copernican turn. This means a re-orientation of aesthetics towards i) those experiential needs which give rise to art, ii) the way they are articulated through artistic creation, and iii) a clarification of the unique effects consequent upon this creation. In the present discussion I offer an approach to all these issues. My starting point is the origin of art. This question is usually approached from an ontogenetic or phylogenetic viewpoint. However, my approach is different – centring on why human beings need to create art in the first place. This has ontogenetic and phylogenetic implications, but as expressions of a greater experiential whole - where the need for art can be seen to emerge from factors conceptually basic to self-consciousness as such. Part One, accordingly, outlines the horizonal basis of our experience of time and space, and then four key cognitive competences which are necessary to this experience. Emphasis is given to the importance of the aesthetic in its narrative form, as a further necessary feature emergent from these competences. Part Two outlines how literature, music, and pictorial art engage with this narrative feature in unique ways on the basis of their distinctive individual ontologies. They transform the aesthetic narrative of experience by embodying it in a more enduring and lucid form than can be attained at the purely experiential level. In this way, art embodies self-becoming, i.e. the developing of one’s own individuality in relation to others, and symbolic compensation for things otherwise lost in the passage of time. (This is a much extended and revised version of a paper on The Need for Art, and the Aesthetics of Self-Consciousness done a s a keynote address at the European Society of Aesthetics annual conference, Dublin Institute of Technology, 11th June, 2015)

The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism

Alan H . Goldman

Mónica Uribe-Flores

The present paper discusses the possibility that aesthetic perception and interpretation reveal themselves as mutually inclusive within the same aesthetic experience of art in a non-trivial way. It will take its point of departure from Hans-Georg Gadamer and Nöel Carroll. Although they belong to different traditions, both philosophers nonetheless coincide in their indication that the experience of art overflows the region of perception and enjoyment of the aesthetic qualities of works of art. Yet while Gadamer subordinates aesthetic perception and maintains that the experience of art is necessarily hermeneutical, Carroll proposes that the aesthetic and the hermeneutical are two equally genuine responses to art. My claim is that perceptual elements in a work of art are decisive for interpretation, and that this should be properly considered when examining the aesthetic experience of art.

Journal of Aesthetic Education

Ciaran Benson

Alfredo Vernazzani

Many artists, art critics, and poets suggest that an aesthetic appreciation of artworks may modify our perception of the world, including quotidian things and scenes. I call this Art-to-World, AtW. Focusing on visual artworks, in this paper I articulate an empirically-informed account of AtW that is based on content-related views of aesthetic experience, and on Goodman’s and Elgin’s concept of exemplification. An aesthetic encounter with artworks demands paying attention to its aesthetic, expressive, or design properties that realize its purpose. Attention to these properties make percipients better able to spot them in other entities and scenes as well. The upshot is that an aesthetic commerce with artworks enlarges the scope of what we are able to see and has therefore momentous epistemic consequences.

RELATED PAPERS

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Ciência e Tecnologia

Harry Schulz

… de Obstetricia y …

luisa artola alvarez

Luis Carlos Paschoarelli

Veterinaria México

Fernando Ivan Flores Perez

Mahesh Edirisinghe

BMC health services research

Merethe Hustoft

Journal of the Association for Vascular Access

Richard Steiner

SEG Technical Program Expanded Abstracts 2013

Gordon Poole

Global Business & Economics Anthology

Anna-Vanadis Faix

The 7th International Conference on Advanced Communication Technology, 2005, ICACT 2005.

K59 Le Tuan Anh

European Heart Journal

Galina Zemtsovskaja

Cadernos de Prospecção

Camilo Freddy Mendoza Morejon

Journal of Molecular Graphics and Modelling

Md sameer Hassan

Acta Scientiarum. Technology

geraldo maciel maciel

Theresa Scharl

Nurmala sari, Inna Sabitah, Mindi juwita hamdi

nurmala sari

Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association : JAMIA

Ritankar Das

Vietnam Journal of Science and Technology

Nguyen Khai

Key Engineering Materials

André Chrysochoos

Ciencia, Docencia y Tecnología

Diana Fresoli

Damiano Baldassarre

Jurnal farmasi sains dan komunitas

Nicholas Rafael Susanto

Astronomy & Astrophysics

Ophthalmology

Günther Rudolph

Micromachines

maryam aghaseyedi

  •   We're Hiring!
  •   Help Center
  • Find new research papers in:
  • Health Sciences
  • Earth Sciences
  • Cognitive Science
  • Mathematics
  • Computer Science
  • Academia ©2024

Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction Essay

A matter of identity is a very sophisticated subject and it is closely connected with social dimension. Paradoxically, the notion of the self cannot be alienated by one principle and, therefore, it cannot be purely centered. The identity construction, hence, is not only connected with the core of individuality, as presented by the Western conceptions.

On the contrary, the center of the self is constantly changing and it is always multiple and diverse. More importantly, our body is primarily outward directed because our interests and preferences could only be satisfied in gratification. Therefore, a person’s self is located within social circumstances dictated by momentous actions and deeds.

With regard to Bakhtin’s theory of identity, I have presented my vision of identity and the self. In particular, the work provides the concept of a human psycho that is composed of “I-for-myself”, “I-for-the-other”, and “other for me” (Emerson 199).

My works present the idea that a person’s identity is constructed through different visions of others. Interpreting this, the identity is rendered via “Not-centered” component and through how other people perceive a person’s self and identity. Analyzing the components of the self-revealed in the Art work, the pictures on the plate personify a “not centered” component, a second dimension of the self.

Through this technique, I sought to show the relations between two worlds – the world of events and culture and the world of life and how those events influenced each person’s life (Bakhtin et al. 2). Indeed, the concept of identity cannot exist without the culture a person lives in; therefore, he/she is unable to reveal his/her individuality unless being attained to those two dimensions.

The work also represents the postmodern culture and how outward aesthetic and ethic tendencies relate to a sense of identity. Another component presents the “faces” attached to the flesh which symbolize different perceptions dependence of a human psyche on the source of identity (Zbinden 59). Faces also encompass the concept of a group identity that is closely related to the way a person evaluates his/her place in society.

The works of art under consideration provide a proof that our needs and interests are conceived through Freudian understanding of human nature. In particular, the flesh of meet reflects that the self exists in libidinal space and everything is cognized through sexual desire (Radley 19).

This is the component that constitutes the basics of your being. It is not vain that I presented the body as a piece of flesh covered with the material objects and events. In other words, the work intends to render a person’s identity through the things and objects constructed by society as well as events in relation to his/her preferences, goals, and needs.

In relation to Bakhtin’s theory, the self presents itself in creating an architectonic connection between life activities which an individual constitutes and natural and cultural environments that surround an individual (Clark and Holquist 68).

Hence, if the outer world is able to characterize a person, then a person is also able to define the world. No mater to what extent a personality is dependent from the laws of nature, an individual has always an opportunity to identify his/herself through other individual (Barker 268). This is a unique ability permitting a person to negotiate and adjust to constant changes and societal claims.

The relation between “the self” and “the other” also include complicated processes and actions. Their unique interaction is constructed around the main values of our life and culture (Felch and Contino 33). In the first work, it is possible to see a woman wearing fashionable clothes in bright colors. Behind her, there is the woman’s silhouette that is represented through grey color without any distinctive features.

While looking at this picture, it is possible to assume that a person’s identity can be unveiled when being evaluated by others. Otherwise, the self can be compared with this grey and unidentified silhouette. The same can be viewed when judging other works at issue where a formless piece of flesh is decorated by objects from the outer world that serve for constructing the identity (Bell and Gardiner 190).

The work also represents Freudian concepts of the body that are closely connected with Bakhtin’s vision of a human psyche (Radley 19; Diaz-Diocaretz 6). Hence, the work presenting a piece of flesh covered with pictures and words shows what a person needs and how his/her need are associated with the cultural and social environment of postmodern world.

Through these conceptions, it is possible to emphasize that a human nature consist of sexual, and deterministic and biological dimensions (Good 99). In this way, the work enables to debunk the myths of objectivity in social and cultural context (Shepherd 183).

In general, the works demonstrate complex relation between the self and cultural and social environment that identifies the unique features of a human psyche. They represent in what way an individual interacts with external life activities that result in obtaining an experience. With the help of this experience, a person has a better opportunity to conceive their needs and interests.

Works Cited

Bakhtin, Mikhail, M., Holquist, Mikhail, and Vadim Liapunov. Toward the Philosophy of an Act. University of Texas Press, 1993. Print.

Barker, S. Signs of change: Premodern, modern, postmodern . US: SUNY Press, 1996. Print.

Bell, Michael and Michael Gardiner. Bakhtin and the human sciences: no last words . US: Sage, 1998. Print.

Clark, Katerina, and Michael Holquist. Mikhail Bakhtin . US: Harvard University Press, 1984. Print.

Diaz-Diocaretz, Myriam. The Bakhtin Circle today UK: Rodopi, 1989. Print.

Emerson, Caryl. The First Hundred Years of Mikhail Bakhtin . US: Princeton University Press, 2000. Print.

Felch, Susan, M. and Paul J. Contino. Bakhtin and Religion. US: Northestern University Press, 2001. Print.

Good, Peter. Language for Those Who Have Nothing: Mikhail Bakhtin and the landscape of psychiatry . US: Springer, 2000. Print.

Shepherd, David G. Bakhtin: Carnival and other subjects: Selected papers from the Fifth International Bakhtin Conference . UK: Rodopi, 1993. Print.

Zbinden, Karine. Bakhtin between East and West: Cross-Cultural Transmission . US: MHRA, 2006. Print.

  • Chicago (A-D)
  • Chicago (N-B)

IvyPanda. (2024, February 26). Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction. https://ivypanda.com/essays/art-and-ideology-in-the-twentieth-century-identity-construction/

"Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction." IvyPanda , 26 Feb. 2024, ivypanda.com/essays/art-and-ideology-in-the-twentieth-century-identity-construction/.

IvyPanda . (2024) 'Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction'. 26 February.

IvyPanda . 2024. "Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction." February 26, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/art-and-ideology-in-the-twentieth-century-identity-construction/.

1. IvyPanda . "Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction." February 26, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/art-and-ideology-in-the-twentieth-century-identity-construction/.

Bibliography

IvyPanda . "Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction." February 26, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/art-and-ideology-in-the-twentieth-century-identity-construction/.

  • The Multivoicedness of Meaning
  • Literature: The Grapes of Wrath and As I Lay Dying
  • Carnival in Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream
  • “Korean Film: History, Resistance, and Democratic Imagination” by Min et al.
  • Presenting Freudian Concepts: Mr. and Mrs. Smith
  • The General Process Description of Orthodox Freudian Analysis
  • Freudian Theory of Personality
  • 19th Century Clothing Activity and Exhibition Analysis
  • Viewing the Society through the Lens of Freudian Theories. Meghnagi’s Interpretation
  • The Freudian Theory and the Adlerian Theory
  • How Digital Technology Influences Art
  • Matua, Abelam and Baining People's Masks
  • Demystifying Chinese Art and Its Relation to Culture
  • Early African Art History and Features
  • On the Correlation Between Art and Human Values

Smarthistory Logo

A-Level: Sample set of works for Identities

This is an example of a set of works that can be used for the theme of Identities in Art and Architecture.

The links associated with the objects listed below have been curated by Smarthistory, and include museum pages and other resources that we think are particularly helpful.

(SA) denotes works by specified artists + architects

(NE) denotes specified non-European works

Pre-1850:  

The sultanganj buddha (ne) .

  • video on this work (Birmingham Museums)
  • object page (Birmingham Museums)

Rembrandt,  Raising of the Cross  (SA)  

  • essay on the artist (The Met)
  • object page (Alte Pinakothek)

F.N. Souza,  Crucifixion

  • object page with essay (Tate)

Portraits in 2D

Rembrandt,  Self-Portrait  (SA)  

  • video about this work (Smarthistory)

Frida Kahlo,  Self-Portrait Along the Borderline (NE)

  • video about this work (Open Arts Archive)

Portraits in 3D

Augustus of Primaporta

  • video and essay about this work (Smarthistory)

Grayson Perry, Self-Portrait with Eyes Poked Out  (SA) 

  • essay on the artist (Victoria Miro Gallery)
  • object page (Victoria Miro Gallery)

Gender identity

Titian,  Venus of Urbino  

Artemisia Gentileschi,  Susanna and the Elders

  • essay on the artist (Brooklyn Museum)
  • image of this work (Wikimedia)

Grayson Perry,  Claire’s Coming Out Dress  (SA)

  • interview with the artist (Saatchi Gallery)

Louise Bourgeois,  Femme Maison

  • essay on the artist (Guggenheim)

Ethnic identity

Marie Benoist,  Portrait of a Negress

  • article on this work (19th-Century Art Worldwide)
  • object page (Louvre)

Chris Ofili, No Woman No Cry

  • video about this work (Tate)

Adrian Piper, Decide Who You Are: Skinned Alive

  • essay on the artist (Indiana University Museum)

Architecture

Sinan, Süleymaniye Mosque (NE) 

  • video about this building (Smarthistory)

Zaha Hadid, Heydar Aliyev Centre (SA)

  • images of this building (Zaha Hadid Architects)

Zaha Hadid, Bridge Pavilion, Zaragoza (SA)

Cite this page

Your donations help make art history free and accessible to everyone!

  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About Art Class Curator
  • Media & Press
  • Programs for Schools
  • Member Login
  • Search this website

Art Class Curator

Hands-on and Minds-curious Art Learning

Experience Art Book and Card Deck on Kickstarter!

May 4, 2021 2 Comments

Exploring the Self: 15 Identity Artworks

Inside: A collection of identity artworks to help students explore and understand their own identity and relate to others around them.

art and identity essay

Have you ever wondered, ‘Who am I?” Have you ever thought about how who you’re around and where you are affects the person who become? Consider how you’ve changed over time and what sparked those shifts in your identity. The answers are not always as straightforward as we might imagine.

Artists have long explored themselves and others through identity artworks. Portraiture and personal expression have been an integral part of art since the first handprints were left on cave walls.

art and identity essay

Art class is the perfect place for students to explore their own identity and connect with others who may or may not share their traits.

You can find lessons for all 15 of these artworks included in this post in the Curated Connections Library , complete with presentations, discussion questions, worksheets, and more.

art and identity essay

Get the Full Lesson!

This Lesson is in The Curated Connections Library!

Find the full lesson from this post along with hundreds of other art teaching resources and trainings in the Curated Connections Library. Click here for more information about how to join or enter your email below for a free SPARKworks lesson from the membership!

Identity Artworks

art and identity essay

Rosa Rolanda, Autorretrato (Self-Portrait)

Rolanda worked frequently with Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera while living in Mexico. Early in her career, she experimented with photography and it is thought she may have been influenced by Man Ray. Many of her paintings consist of brightly colored folklore scenes featuring festivals, children, and portraits of her friends.

Lesson: Rosa Rolanda Jigsaw Art Learning Activity: Each Piece Tells a Story

With her marriage crumbling, Rolanda painted this self portrait of her in turmoil. Her hands clasped her ears as if refusing to hear reality. The clock in the lower right symbolizes the passing of her youth. The tossing figures represent Mexico City dance company where Covarrubias was the director, and where he met a dancer 30 years his junior — the affair tore their marriage apart. -Soodie Beasley

art and identity essay

Kyle Meyer, Unidentified 48 from the series Interwoven

Meyer uses his photography background to address the question: “How can a digital image serve any human connection when it is entirely produced – and ubiquitously reproduced – by mechanical means (camera, computer, printer)?”

He also seeks to explore his own identity as a gay man within the LGBTQ communities. He draws upon his experiences growing up in conservative rural Ohio and living in Swaziland where homosexuality is illegal.

For my series Interwoven, I explore the challenges of homosexuality in a hyper-masculine culture within Swaziland. Given that homosexuality is illegal in this small African country, gay men constantly have to hide their sexuality and suppress their true identity. After befriending several gay men in Swaziland, who confided in me their personal stories of struggle, I asked them to choose a piece of fabric typically worn by women with which I made unique wraps on each of their heads. It would be taboo for men to wear these head-wraps in public, as that would indicate homosexual tendencies. This was one simple way for them to express their individuality that they regularly have to hide. -Kyle Meyer

art and identity essay

Angelica Kauffmann, Self Portrait of the Artist Hesitating between the Arts of Music and Painting

Kauffmann was a child prodigy, skilled at both painting and music. She struggled to choose which art to pursue, as shown in this self portrait.

It presents the artist as a kind of female Hercules, choosing not between Virtue and Vice, but between her profession as a painter, which was traditionally a male dominated field (the figure of Painting points to a far away temple, symbolizing the difficulty of her journey), and a career devoted to the easier, more traditionally feminine, Art of Music. In recent years, this self portrait has become an icon of the feminist interpretation of art history. -Arthur, Digital Museum

art and identity essay

Kehinde Wiley, Mary, Comforter of the Afflicted I

Wiley is known for his portraits of black people in grand poses with bold, patterned backgrounds—including the official portrait of President Barak Obama. He references art history in many of his paintings, substituting contemporary black figures in place of the people in the original work. This piece was inspired by an artwork featuring the Biblical figure Mary.

Lesson: Portraits for a New Century: Kehinde Wiley Art Lesson

My work is not about paint. It’s about paint at the service of something else. It is not about gooey, chest-beating, macho ’50s abstraction that allows paint to sit up on the surface as subject matter about paint. -Kehinde Wiley

art and identity essay

Sadie Red Wing, Lakȟóta + Dakȟóta Visual Essay

Visual Essay was created because the artists wants to preserve and communicate the Lakȟóta visual language and share her cultural perspective. Each element represents a different aspect of the artist’s life, journey, and cultural heritage by using Lakȟóta symbols.

If you cannot be comfortable in your own skin, it reflects in your work, studies, and communication. -Sadie Red Wing

art and identity essay

Gustav Klimt, Adele Bloch-Bauer I

One of Klimt’s most famous paintings, this work is often called Woman in Gold . Her true identity was obscured because she came from a prominent Jewish family during the rise of Nazism and World War II. This artwork is a great way to talk about identity with your students by exploring the difference between how we see ourselves versus how others see us.

Ignore the gold. That’s Klimt. Look at my face. Does it resemble me? -Antje Traue as Adele Bloch-Bauer in the 2015 film Woman in Gold

The Sunflower Quilting Bee at Arles by Faith Ringgold

Faith Ringgold, The Sunflower Quilting Bee at Arles

These women included in this artwork are influential leaders and important figures in American history including (from upper left) Madam Walker, Sojourner Truth, Ida Wells, Fannie Lou Hammer, Harriet Tubman, Rosa Parks, Mary McLeod Bethune, and Ella Baker. The ninth woman is a fictional character invented by Ringgold named Willa Marie Simone. Vincent van Gogh stands behind them.

Lesson: Faith Ringgold’s Celebration of African American Women

I had something I was trying to say and sometimes the message is an easy transmission and sometimes it’s a difficult one, but I love the power of saying it so I’m gonna do it whether it’s hard or easy. -Faith Ringgold

art and identity essay

Molly Crabapple, Portraits of myself and Lola Montes with things said about us by our contemporaries

This artwork is a powerful, transfixing two-sided sculpture that confronts the dark side of social media—focusing on the pervasive culture of bullying and how hurtful words hurled through a screen can erode confidence and self-esteem.

Lesson: Things Said About Us: Art-Inspired Self Esteem Activity for Kids

If there’s a theme in my work, it’s that I like to focus on smart people who are facing oppression and who are fighting back against it. -Molly Crabapple

Frida Kahlo, Self Portrait with Cropped Hair, 1940

Frida Kahlo, Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair

Frida Kahlo painted this after she divorced Diego Rivera. The lyrics from the Mexican song translate as, “Look, if I loved you it was because of your hair. Now that you are without hair, I don’t love you anymore.” Changing your appearance when you’re going through changes in your life is a typical part of reshaping identity and one students will relate to.

I paint self-portraits because I am so often alone, because I am the person I know best. -Frida Kahlo

Tracey Moffatt artwork

Tracey Moffatt, Useless

Each photograph from Moffatt’s photo series Scarred for Life documents small, but not insignificant, bad things that happen to us in our lives—small digs at our worth in the world that slowly bring us down and subconsciously teach us about society, how it works, and how we fit in (or don’t).

Lesson: Scarred for Life: Using Art to Analyze the Small Moments that Define Us

My work is full of emotion and drama, you can get to that drama by using a narrative, and my narratives are usually very simple, but I twist it. There is a storyline, but there isn’t a traditional beginning, middle, and end. -Tracey Moffatt

art and identity essay

Anila Quayyum Agha, All the Flowers Are for Me

This immersive artwork draw inspiration from the Agha’s home of Pakistan. The geometric patterns are characteristic of Islamic Art. She was inspired by opposing forces such as light and shadow, life and death, and chose red because brides in Pakistan often wear red. Many of Agha’s artworks are meant to create welcoming places where no one feels like an outsider.

This artwork offers us an opportunity to explore our place in the world—where we feel welcomed and comfortable and where we don’t. It also gives students the chance to consider the spaces that are and are not welcoming to all and how those places and interactions shape our identity.

Artists have the ability to bring historical perspectives to the current time. I’m interested in that thought process of taking responsibility and seeing how we can move to the future and make a better environment for people. -Anila Quayyum Agha

art and identity essay

Cindy Sherman, Untitled Film Still #21

When first looking at this image, you might think it is merely a candid photo of a young woman on a city street, but that is not the case. Sherman set it up to look as though she, herself, is a female character from a black and white movie of the 1950s-60s. For this series, the artist played with identity—dressing as different characters by putting on wigs, clothing, and make up, then placing herself in carefully framed scenes meant to evoke film stills.

If I knew what the picture was going to be like, I wouldn’t make it. -Cindy Sherman

Auguste Rodin, The Thinker, Rodin Museum, Paris, Photo Credit: deror avi

Auguste Rodin, The Thinker

Rodin was a master of manipulating light and shadow. Even though The Thinker is just sitting, he wanted it to seem as though it moved. He manipulated the face with extra clay to make it seem as though the facial expression changes as you move around the sculpture—inviting us to ponder our own lives and identities.

I invent nothing, I rediscover. -Auguste Rodin

art and identity essay

Margaret Macdonald Mackintosh, The Mysterious Garden

Perhaps as a part of a dream, eight heads or masks float above a seemingly sleeping figure. It is thought that this work was inspired by the play The Blue Bird by Maurice Maeterlinck.

Margaret has genius, I have only talent -Mackintosh’s husband, Charles Rennie Mackintosh

art and identity essay

Marcos Raya, The Anguish of Being and the Nothingness of the Universe

This artwork depicts an inside-out view of Raya’s head and explores the social impact of technology on humanity, as well as his personal battle with alcoholism. Raya painted several versions of this painting, each has different views through the eyes.

Creating is a revolutionary act. -Marcos Raya

You May Also Enjoy These Posts:

art and identity essay

Reader Interactions

' src=

February 7, 2024 at 9:41 am

You left out RENEE COX who has been doing self portraits since the 90 s ( YO MAMAS LAST SUPPER 2001)

' src=

February 16, 2024 at 5:40 am

Thank you for bringing this artwork to our attention.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

art and identity essay

Get Art Inspiration To Your Inbox!

Free Worksheets!

*Free Bundle of Art Appreciation Worksheets*

In this free bundle of art worksheets, you receive six ready-to-use art worksheets with looking activities designed to work with almost any work of art.

Identity – Controversy – Justice

  • #2 (no title)
  • Picasso’s Guernica: The Story from a Bombing to a Painting
  • Crying Girl Essay
  • Barack Obama Essay
  • Unsung Founders Essay
  • A Tale of Two Hoodies
  • El Agua Origen de la Vida Essay

Kahlo Essay

  • Founding of Chicago Essay
  • Japanese Triptych Essay
  • Qing Vase Essay
  • Crossing Sweeper Essay
  • Begging for Change Essay
  • Boy with Skittles Essay
  • About this Exhibit

Frida Kahlo’s honest, often bizarre, self-portraits reflect a beauty beyond the physical– an impishness in the wide eyes, a small smirk teasing at the corners of her mouth.  In her renderings, her cheeks are always heavily rouged, and exotic flowers adorn her raven hair.  Self-Portrait in a Velvet Dress uses the contrast of light — Kahlo’s glowing skin — and dark– the black background, and in doing so, this painting not only communicates the subject’s outward beauty. It also points to an unspoken turmoil inside of the painter: as dark as the night sky and as deep as rolling sea.

Much of Kahlo’s life was characterized by immense pain resulting from a lifelong battle with polio, and a bus accident in 1925 that left her crippled at the age of eighteen. It was in those lonely evenings, laid up in her hospital bed when Kahlo began to paint herself, as she was the only subject matter she had.

Frida Kahlo was born Magdalena Carmen Frieda Kahlo y Calderón on July 6, 1907 in Mexico to Matilde Calderón and Guillermo Kahlo. She was a middle child of four, and she spent her childhood in Coyoacán, Mexico City in la Casa Azul, the Blue House. Though she was born in Mexico and stands today as a pioneer of Mexican folk art, Kahlo was actually ethnically half-European. “Frieda” was the original Hungarian spelling of her name, but she came to use the Spanish spelling, “Frida” furthering her carefully crafted persona. Her father, Wilhelm— he only later changed his name to Guillermo— was Hungarian, and her mother, Matilde was of Spanish, and indigenous, descent.

This work stands out among the rest of Kahlo’s collection for its references to European art and a European standard of beauty. The woman portrayed here is only a version of the artist. Her hand is placed delicately on her arm; her white neck, elongated. The piece conjures images of Da Vinci’s Mona Lisa in the subject’s knowing smile and Van Gogh’s Starry Night with the rolling waves in the background. These works in and of themselves were fitting inspirations, as both were, at their debuts, ill-received, misunderstood and wholly under-appreciated. At the time, critics questioned Mona Lisa’s smile, and scoffed at Van Gogh’s celestial cityscapes. Kahlo herself never saw much recognition in her lifetime, as she spent most of her career being tied to another artist, her husband, Diego Rivera.

The audience could interpret this use of the European style as a nod to the well-respected European greats like Da Vinci and Van Gogh, or one could interpret this as Kahlo’s attempt to thumb her nose at these painters. Take the exaggerated features of this work; one could suppose that the woman’s neck is too stretched, her tempting dress to too red, the cut of it too low. Consider these features, and this here Self-Portrait in a Velvet Dress becomes a caricature-Kahlo and is no longer the genuine artifact.

This mockery is Kahlo’s rejection of the European standard, a rejection of the culture, and it acts as the artist’s way of further embracing her Mexican culture and identity. It would not be too hard to imagine, given that the artist was a notorious firecracker , a rebel and a patriot to the very end. “I was born a bitch,” she was once quoted for saying, “I was born a painter.”

With this piece, Frida Kahlo bucked tradition using a subtly that only skilled artists possess. Self-Portrait in a Velvet Dress draws the audience in with its unintimidating size, holds them in a vice grip and fascinates them with its beauty. But, in truth, Kahlo was painting more than just a pretty picture. Kahlo’s Velvet offers a shining example of her own talent and versatility while never abandoning her signature style. Chiefly, it demonstrates the artist’s complexity and her ability to critically examine her cultural identity and herself, as only she could.

Works Cited

  • “Frida Kahlo Biography.” Frida Kahlo Biography . N.p., 2015. Web. 16 July 2015.
  • “Frida Kahlo Biography.” Bio.com . A&E Networks Television, n.d. Web. 17 July 2015.
  • “Frida Kahlo: Her Photos.” 9788492480753: . Editorial RM, n.d. Web. 17 July 2015
  • Search for:

Recent Comments

  • No categories
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • All comments

Après le rave, c’est moi? Geoffrey Mak examines his pursuit of social status and identity in ‘Mean Boys’

A book of essays by a critic and style expert has its limits as a chronicle of self-reflection.

Geoffrey Mak, author of the essay collection "Mean Boys."

“No, we couldn’t stay in the rave forever,” writes Geoffrey Mak in “ Mean Boys: A Personal History, ” a book of essays that attempts to find meaning in the art critic’s formative years, which span Trump’s presidency, COVID, and its aftermath. The title suggests the book will examine the author’s mean-boyness, but ultimately, this straightforward coming-of-age memoir is most concerned with the author’s meanness to himself.

The reader is invited into countless raves at Berghain, Berlin’s iconic nightclub; an extensive tour of the author’s drug-fueled racial and sexual insecurities; and a compelling chronicle of his rise as a critic and style expert. But larger questions about identity and the lasting importance of the fashion and art industry that Mak has staked his career upon feel elided. This reader can’t help but wonder what we’re to take away from the author’s experiences now that the raves are over.

A son of an evangelical minister, Mak flees the Los Angeles County suburb of Diamond Bar for New York and then Berlin, because he “didn’t want to miss out on ‘the Paris of our time.’” Away from his family’s homophobia, he freely explores his identity as a gay man. He aspires to be an art critic. “I imagined the art critic lived a life of status, which was real and autonomous here in Berlin,” Mak observes. “…Berlin, specifically the East, carried the residue of a Soviet mentality, from the times when, in theory, class did not exist, but status still did.”

Mak is also drawn to the world of fashion due to its status. The author describes himself as a “club kid” whose “highest destiny was to serve as decoration to somebody who had attained a level of status that was evidently not in the cards for us.” He tried to stand out among those “dressed up for the club with an impatience to be noticed: lavish outfits cut from flowing satin; chains, directly sourced from Bauhaus; or vintage looks bought head to toe from the Humana thrift store in Friedrichshain.” Readers not into fashion on this level of granularity will wonder, as I did: What does this status mean in the end? Is the pursuit of status a positive or negative? Where does the author stand on these questions?

Advertisement

As many expats experience, the shine of being a perpetual foreigner, no matter your status, can fade over time; all parties must end. Mak’s search for love and healthy expressions of intimacy is derailed by a sexual assault in New York, causing him to abuse drugs and pornography and become suicidal. “In the all-bets-off economy of cruising, wokeness doesn’t save you,” Mak writes. “Asian men rank at the bottom of the sexual hierarchy. The virtual nonexistence of Asian men in gay porn tracks with the desert of desire I’ve detected in other men, white or otherwise, who have seen me more like a green leather couch…”

Mak’s racial and sexual insecurities are further explored in the book’s closing essay, “Mean Boys.” The author writes about Elliot Rodger, who went on a violent rampage on the campus of the University of California, Santa Barbara in 2014, killing six before shooting himself, targeting female students (because they wouldn’t sleep with him) and Chinese men (Rodger’s mother was Malaysian Chinese). Mak gives Rodger’s disturbing manifesto a close reading and finds himself empathizing with the killer, imagining himself in Rodger’s body, “walking down my own high school hallways that were so narrow it was impossible to dodge eye contact with anyone I wanted to avoid.”

In “My Father, the Minister,” the book’s most poignant essay, Mak’s father visits the author in New York and appears ready to repudiate his homophobic beliefs. But when Mak asks his father to tell his congregation about his gay son, his father refuses. It’s a heartbreaking moment to see a father fail his son so deeply, despite his good intentions. In this essay, Mak seems to get closest to the root of his struggles as a young person:

“…I was never able to believe that I deserved love, that I was no less capable of receiving it, assuming I’d be able to recognize love if I ever saw it.… I was unable to love myself, much less accept it from others.”

I couldn’t help but wish for more of these epiphanic moments in “Mean Boys.” Too much time is spent introducing and following party people who sound more important to Mak the status-seeker than Mak the author of a book about his own life. Chillingly, his essay about Elliot Rodger, who posted photos of himself in $500 Neiman Marcus sweaters, brings up the importance of status again. “Rodger turned to fashion because he wanted to buy something that in fact cannot be bought: status,” Mak writes. But is the author critiquing his own pursuit? If so, what is the author now pursuing in its place?

The book ends with a lovely section about his friend Ellis — not just a party friend, a real one. Ellis and Mak struggle with depression, and share that they’ve had suicidal thoughts. They turn to each other for solace. Mak’s relationship with Ellis gives the reader a much-needed glimpse into the author after the party’s over, and that boy seems far from mean.

MEAN BOYS: A Personal History

by Geoffrey Mak

Bloomsbury, 288 pp., $28.99

Leland Cheuk is an award-winning author of three books of fiction, most recently “No Good Very Bad Asian.” His writing has appeared in The Washington Post and NPR, among other outlets.

Numbers, Facts and Trends Shaping Your World

Read our research on:

Full Topic List

Regions & Countries

  • Publications
  • Our Methods
  • Short Reads
  • Tools & Resources

Read Our Research On:

How Pew Research Center will report on generations moving forward

Journalists, researchers and the public often look at society through the lens of generation, using terms like Millennial or Gen Z to describe groups of similarly aged people. This approach can help readers see themselves in the data and assess where we are and where we’re headed as a country.

Pew Research Center has been at the forefront of generational research over the years, telling the story of Millennials as they came of age politically and as they moved more firmly into adult life . In recent years, we’ve also been eager to learn about Gen Z as the leading edge of this generation moves into adulthood.

But generational research has become a crowded arena. The field has been flooded with content that’s often sold as research but is more like clickbait or marketing mythology. There’s also been a growing chorus of criticism about generational research and generational labels in particular.

Recently, as we were preparing to embark on a major research project related to Gen Z, we decided to take a step back and consider how we can study generations in a way that aligns with our values of accuracy, rigor and providing a foundation of facts that enriches the public dialogue.

A typical generation spans 15 to 18 years. As many critics of generational research point out, there is great diversity of thought, experience and behavior within generations.

We set out on a yearlong process of assessing the landscape of generational research. We spoke with experts from outside Pew Research Center, including those who have been publicly critical of our generational analysis, to get their take on the pros and cons of this type of work. We invested in methodological testing to determine whether we could compare findings from our earlier telephone surveys to the online ones we’re conducting now. And we experimented with higher-level statistical analyses that would allow us to isolate the effect of generation.

What emerged from this process was a set of clear guidelines that will help frame our approach going forward. Many of these are principles we’ve always adhered to , but others will require us to change the way we’ve been doing things in recent years.

Here’s a short overview of how we’ll approach generational research in the future:

We’ll only do generational analysis when we have historical data that allows us to compare generations at similar stages of life. When comparing generations, it’s crucial to control for age. In other words, researchers need to look at each generation or age cohort at a similar point in the life cycle. (“Age cohort” is a fancy way of referring to a group of people who were born around the same time.)

When doing this kind of research, the question isn’t whether young adults today are different from middle-aged or older adults today. The question is whether young adults today are different from young adults at some specific point in the past.

To answer this question, it’s necessary to have data that’s been collected over a considerable amount of time – think decades. Standard surveys don’t allow for this type of analysis. We can look at differences across age groups, but we can’t compare age groups over time.

Another complication is that the surveys we conducted 20 or 30 years ago aren’t usually comparable enough to the surveys we’re doing today. Our earlier surveys were done over the phone, and we’ve since transitioned to our nationally representative online survey panel , the American Trends Panel . Our internal testing showed that on many topics, respondents answer questions differently depending on the way they’re being interviewed. So we can’t use most of our surveys from the late 1980s and early 2000s to compare Gen Z with Millennials and Gen Xers at a similar stage of life.

This means that most generational analysis we do will use datasets that have employed similar methodologies over a long period of time, such as surveys from the U.S. Census Bureau. A good example is our 2020 report on Millennial families , which used census data going back to the late 1960s. The report showed that Millennials are marrying and forming families at a much different pace than the generations that came before them.

Even when we have historical data, we will attempt to control for other factors beyond age in making generational comparisons. If we accept that there are real differences across generations, we’re basically saying that people who were born around the same time share certain attitudes or beliefs – and that their views have been influenced by external forces that uniquely shaped them during their formative years. Those forces may have been social changes, economic circumstances, technological advances or political movements.

When we see that younger adults have different views than their older counterparts, it may be driven by their demographic traits rather than the fact that they belong to a particular generation.

The tricky part is isolating those forces from events or circumstances that have affected all age groups, not just one generation. These are often called “period effects.” An example of a period effect is the Watergate scandal, which drove down trust in government among all age groups. Differences in trust across age groups in the wake of Watergate shouldn’t be attributed to the outsize impact that event had on one age group or another, because the change occurred across the board.

Changing demographics also may play a role in patterns that might at first seem like generational differences. We know that the United States has become more racially and ethnically diverse in recent decades, and that race and ethnicity are linked with certain key social and political views. When we see that younger adults have different views than their older counterparts, it may be driven by their demographic traits rather than the fact that they belong to a particular generation.

Controlling for these factors can involve complicated statistical analysis that helps determine whether the differences we see across age groups are indeed due to generation or not. This additional step adds rigor to the process. Unfortunately, it’s often absent from current discussions about Gen Z, Millennials and other generations.

When we can’t do generational analysis, we still see value in looking at differences by age and will do so where it makes sense. Age is one of the most common predictors of differences in attitudes and behaviors. And even if age gaps aren’t rooted in generational differences, they can still be illuminating. They help us understand how people across the age spectrum are responding to key trends, technological breakthroughs and historical events.

Each stage of life comes with a unique set of experiences. Young adults are often at the leading edge of changing attitudes on emerging social trends. Take views on same-sex marriage , for example, or attitudes about gender identity .

Many middle-aged adults, in turn, face the challenge of raising children while also providing care and support to their aging parents. And older adults have their own obstacles and opportunities. All of these stories – rooted in the life cycle, not in generations – are important and compelling, and we can tell them by analyzing our surveys at any given point in time.

When we do have the data to study groups of similarly aged people over time, we won’t always default to using the standard generational definitions and labels. While generational labels are simple and catchy, there are other ways to analyze age cohorts. For example, some observers have suggested grouping people by the decade in which they were born. This would create narrower cohorts in which the members may share more in common. People could also be grouped relative to their age during key historical events (such as the Great Recession or the COVID-19 pandemic) or technological innovations (like the invention of the iPhone).

By choosing not to use the standard generational labels when they’re not appropriate, we can avoid reinforcing harmful stereotypes or oversimplifying people’s complex lived experiences.

Existing generational definitions also may be too broad and arbitrary to capture differences that exist among narrower cohorts. A typical generation spans 15 to 18 years. As many critics of generational research point out, there is great diversity of thought, experience and behavior within generations. The key is to pick a lens that’s most appropriate for the research question that’s being studied. If we’re looking at political views and how they’ve shifted over time, for example, we might group people together according to the first presidential election in which they were eligible to vote.

With these considerations in mind, our audiences should not expect to see a lot of new research coming out of Pew Research Center that uses the generational lens. We’ll only talk about generations when it adds value, advances important national debates and highlights meaningful societal trends.

  • Age & Generations
  • Demographic Research
  • Generation X
  • Generation Z
  • Generations
  • Greatest Generation
  • Methodological Research
  • Millennials
  • Silent Generation

Kim Parker's photo

Kim Parker is director of social trends research at Pew Research Center

How Teens and Parents Approach Screen Time

Who are you the art and science of measuring identity, u.s. centenarian population is projected to quadruple over the next 30 years, older workers are growing in number and earning higher wages, teens, social media and technology 2023, most popular.

1615 L St. NW, Suite 800 Washington, DC 20036 USA (+1) 202-419-4300 | Main (+1) 202-857-8562 | Fax (+1) 202-419-4372 |  Media Inquiries

After Reports About Trump Jurors, Judge Demands Restraint From the Press

Some news reports have included details about jurors that had been aired in open court. One was excused after she developed concerns about being identified.

  • Share full article

Reporters stand near lights and cameras.

By Jesse McKinley ,  Kate Christobek and Matthew Haag

  • April 18, 2024

The judge in former President Donald J. Trump’s criminal trial ordered reporters to not disclose employment information about potential jurors after he excused a woman who said she was worried about her identity becoming known.

The woman, who had been seated on the jury on Tuesday, told the judge that her friends and colleagues had warned her that she had been identified as a juror in the high-profile case. Although the judge has kept prospective jurors’ names private, some have disclosed their employers and other identifying information in court.

She also said that she did not believe she could be impartial.

The judge, Juan M. Merchan, promptly dismissed her.

Moments later, Justice Merchan ordered the press to not report the answer to two queries on a lengthy questionnaire for prospective jurors: “Who is your current employer?” and “Who was your prior employer?”

The judge conceded that the information about employers was necessary for lawyers to know. But he directed that those two answers be redacted from the transcript.

Justice Merchan also said that he was concerned about news outlets publishing physical descriptions of prospective or seated jurors, asking reporters to “simply apply common sense.”

“It serves no purpose,” Justice Merchan said about publishing physical descriptions, adding that he was directing the press to “refrain from writing about anything you observe with your eyes.”

William P. Marshall, a professor at the University of North Carolina School of Law in Chapel Hill, said that Justice Merchan’s order appeared “constitutionally suspect.” Professor Marshall said that a landmark Supreme Court ruling in a 1976 case, Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart, struck down a trial judge’s ruling barring the news media from reporting information introduced in open court.

“The presumption against prior restraint is incredibly high in First Amendment law,” Professor Marshall said. “It’s even higher when it’s publishing something that is already a matter of public record.”

Lawyers for news outlets, including The New York Times, were expected to seek clarification on the order.

With the loss of the female juror on Thursday morning, six seated jurors remain.

In early March, Justice Merchan issued an order prohibiting publicly disclosing the names of jurors, while allowing legal teams and the defendant to know their identities.

But before the trial, Mr. Trump’s lawyers requested that potential jurors not be told that the jury would be anonymous unless he or she expressed concerns. Justice Merchan told the parties that he’d “make every effort to not unnecessarily alert the jurors” to this secrecy, merely telling jurors that they would be identified in court by a number.

On Thursday, Justice Merchan seemed frustrated by news reports that included identifying characteristics of potential jurors that had been aired in open court. He said: “There’s a reason why this is an anonymous jury, and we’ve taken the measures we have taken.”

“It kind of defeats the purpose of that when so much information is put out there,” he said.

He added that “the press can write about anything the attorney and the courts discuss and anything you observe us do.”

But he also said he had the legal authority to prevent reporters from relaying employer information on prospective jurors. He added that “if you can’t stick to that, we’re going to have to see if there is anything else we can do to keep the jurors safe.”

Jesse McKinley is a Times reporter covering upstate New York, courts and politics. More about Jesse McKinley

Kate Christobek is a reporter covering the civil and criminal cases against former president Donald J. Trump for The Times. More about Kate Christobek

Matthew Haag writes about the intersection of real estate and politics in the New York region. He has been a journalist for two decades. More about Matthew Haag

Our Coverage of the Trump Hush-Money Trial

News and Analysis

Donald Trump’s criminal trial in Manhattan is off to an ominous start for the former president, and it might not get any easier  in the days ahead. Here’s why.

The National Enquirer was more than a friendly media outlet  for Trump’s presidential campaign in 2016. It was a powerful, national political weapon that was thrust into the service of a single candidate , in violation of campaign finance law.

As prosecutors argued that Trump had repeatedly broken a gag order , they called one episode “very troubling”  — his sharing of a commentator’s quote disparaging prospective jurors as clandestine operators for the left.

More on Trump’s Legal Troubles

Key Inquiries: Trump faces several investigations  at both the state and the federal levels, into matters related to his business and political careers.

Case Tracker:  Keep track of the developments in the criminal cases  involving the former president.

What if Trump Is Convicted?: Could he go to prison ? And will any of the proceedings hinder Trump’s presidential campaign? Here is what we know , and what we don’t know .

Trump on Trial Newsletter: Sign up here  to get the latest news and analysis  on the cases in New York, Florida, Georgia and Washington, D.C.

IMAGES

  1. Identity in Art Essay Example

    art and identity essay

  2. Business paper: Identity essay

    art and identity essay

  3. Identity Essay Examples

    art and identity essay

  4. identity essay 2014

    art and identity essay

  5. Art And Identity Exploration Essay Examples

    art and identity essay

  6. Visual Arts Essay

    art and identity essay

VIDEO

  1. ART IDENTITY

  2. Our Culture our Identity essay in English l Essay on our Culture our Identity in English l

  3. Identity essay example

  4. Изобразительное искусство. Семья пространственных искусств. Художественные материалы

  5. Art Progress this week and tips on how to reinforce your Art Identity

  6. 13 literature & film recommendations

COMMENTS

  1. Art and Identity

    Introduction. Art depicts people's identity in all its dimensions. In this essay, through explaining notions of identity in relation to art, it will become clear enough that art depicts the fullness of individuals' identity. When it comes to identity, two distinct categories emerge i.e. personal identity and collective identity.

  2. Identity Art

    In art, the term "identity politics" appeared most prominently in the 1970s and 1980s American art scene and referred to art that addressed topics related to identity and what identity is societally understood as. These included topics of gender, race, and sexuality, which are all crucial aspects of each person's individuality and identity.

  3. Identity Art & Identity Politics Movement Overview

    Summary of Identity Art & Identity Politics. The twentieth and twenty-first centuries have seen many artists use art as a way to present their authentic life experiences, interrogate social perception of their identity, and critique systemic issues that marginalize them in society. These include women artists, artists of color, LGBTQ+ artists ...

  4. Art and Identity: Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    Art and Identity: Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind. January 2013. DOI: 10.1163/9789401209045. ISBN: 9789401209045. Authors: Tone Roald. University of Copenhagen. Johannes Lang. Danish ...

  5. PDF Art, Identity and Everyday Experience

    art, identity and everyday experience are interrelated. The body of this essay will take the following form: It is divided in three main sections. The first section establishes and explains Dewey's theoretical background in order to argue that art is a double-barreled word. From here, I move on to the subject of

  6. PDF Rastko Močnik, Identity and the Arts

    Rastko Močnik. "Identity is the poor artist's survival strategy" - this is how I first intended to open this contribution. Yet, I soon decided not to use this opening: not only that it comes close to class-chauvinism in its ambiguous use of the expression "poor", it also hides the fact that also established artists often define themselves in ...

  7. Art and Identity : Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    Art has the capacity to shape and alter our identities. It can influence who and what we are. Those who have had aesthetic experiences know this intimately, and yet the study of art's impact on the mind struggles to be recognized as a centrally important field within the discipline of psychology. The main thesis of Art and Identity is that aesthetic experience represents a prototype for ...

  8. Art and Identity

    Tone Roald and Johannes Lang: Introduction Mark Johnson: Identity, Bodily Meaning, and Art Ciarán Benson: Acts not Tracts! Why a Complete Psychology of Art and Identity Must Be Neuro-cultural Gerald C. Cupchik: I Am, Therefore I Think, Act, and Express both in Life and in Art Simo Køppe: Sense, Modality, and Aesthetic Experience Judy Gammelgaard: Reading Proust: The Little Shock Effects of ...

  9. Art and Identity Essay. It's curious the way how identity is an…

    Art and Identity Essay. ... This text was part of the activities required by the Modern Art course taught by the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) and written by me (Gabriel Green Fusari), as the final writing of the 3rd and pre-penultimate weeks, September 4th 2019. Art. Identity----

  10. Smarthistory

    videos + essays. A-level: Marc Quinn, Self. This work is an example of provocation with a purpose. ... gender identity, ethnicity, and the urban environment. A-Level: Looking east—how Japan inspired Monet, Van Gogh and other Western artists ... We believe art has the power to transform lives and to build understanding across cultures. The ...

  11. Art and Identity: Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    This is the introduction to the book, Art and Identity : Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind, edited by Tone Roald and Johannes Lang, and published by Brill in 2013. I. Introduction Tone Roald and Johannes Lang University of Copenhagen and the Danish Institute for International Studies Art has the capacity to shape and alter our minds.

  12. The Body in Art

    The Body in Art. The human body is central to how we understand facets of identity such as gender, sexuality, race, and ethnicity. People alter their bodies, hair, and clothing to align with or rebel against social conventions and to express messages to others around them. Many artists explore gender through representations of the body and by ...

  13. Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction Essay

    Art and Ideology in the Twentieth Century: Identity Construction Essay. Exclusively available on IvyPanda. Updated: Feb 26th, 2024. A matter of identity is a very sophisticated subject and it is closely connected with social dimension. Paradoxically, the notion of the self cannot be alienated by one principle and, therefore, it cannot be purely ...

  14. Smarthistory

    by Smarthistory. This is an example of a set of works that can be used for the theme of Identities in Art and Architecture. The links associated with the objects listed below have been curated by Smarthistory, and include museum pages and other resources that we think are particularly helpful. (SA) denotes works by specified artists + architects.

  15. Art and Identity: Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.. Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.. Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations. Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.

  16. Full article: Art makes society: an introductory visual essay

    The scale, visibility, and accessibility of these objects and images are further sources of information about their cultural significance. In the rest of this essay, we present a range of examples to consider the varied ways in which art makes society. We consider: (1) the ways art can frame a setting; (2) art as participation; (3) art as ...

  17. Exploring the Self: 15 Identity Artworks

    Art class is the perfect place for students to explore their own identity and connect with others who may or may not share their traits. You can find lessons for all 15 of these artworks included in this post in the Curated Connections Library, complete with presentations, discussion questions, worksheets, and more.

  18. Editors' Introduction: Art, Identity, and Social Justice

    uncover the tangled relationship between art and social change. Following the tremendous number of submissions to the first issue (Vol. 33, No. 2) on Art, Power, and Social Change, we organized a second focusing on the relationship between the arts, collective identity, and social justice. York City and the San Francisco Bay Area.

  19. Art and Identity in "The Danish Girl"

    Conclusion. "The Danish Girl" masterfully weaves the themes of art and identity, illustrating how the canvas becomes a space for exploration, empowerment, and authenticity. Through Gerda's artistic expression and Einar/Lili's transformative journey, the novel underscores the lasting impact of art on personal growth and societal conversation.

  20. Identity

    Frida Kahlo's honest, often bizarre, self-portraits reflect a beauty beyond the physical- an impishness in the wide eyes, a small smirk teasing at the corners of her mouth. In her renderings, her cheeks are always heavily rouged, and exotic flowers adorn her raven hair. Self-Portrait in a Velvet Dress uses the contrast of light — Kahlo ...

  21. Art and Identity : Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    Art has the capacity to shape and alter our identities. It can influence who and what we are. Those who have had aesthetic experiences know this intimately, and yet the study of art's impact on the mind struggles to be recognized as a centrally important field within the discipline of psychology. The main thesis of Art and Identity is that aesthetic experience represents a prototype for ...

  22. Tattoo Culture: a Journey into Art, Identity, and Expression

    This essay delves into the multifaceted aspects of tattoo culture, focusing on its historical significance, the evolution of tattoos as an art form, the influence of tattoos on individual identity, and the challenges faced by tattooed individuals in modern society. Tattoos have a rich and storied history that dates back thousands of years.

  23. Geoffrey Mak's Mean Boys is a coming of age memoir with limits

    A book of essays by a critic and style expert has its limits as a chronicle of self-reflection. Geoffrey Mak, author of the essay collection "Mean Boys." Daniel Tepper/Ecco. "No, we couldn't ...

  24. How Pew Research Center will report on generations moving forward

    Pew Research Center has been at the forefront of generational research over the years, telling the story of Millennials as they came of age politically and as they moved more firmly into adult life. In recent years, we've also been eager to learn about Gen Z as the leading edge of this generation moves into adulthood.

  25. Art and Identity : Essays on the Aesthetic Creation of Mind

    Art has the capacity to shape and alter our identities. It can influence who and what we are. Those who have had aesthetic experiences know this intimately, and yet the study of art's impact on the mind struggles to be recognized as a centrally important field within the discipline of psychology. The main thesis of Art and Identity is that aesthetic experience represents a prototype for ...

  26. Judge in Trump Trial Asks Media Not to Report Some Juror Information

    April 18, 2024. The judge in former President Donald J. Trump's criminal trial ordered reporters to not disclose employment information about potential jurors after he excused a woman who said ...